Concept
Misrepresentation and Voidability
Fraud, misrepresentation, and nondisclosure
Avoiding Contracts for Misrepresentation
Misrepresentation and Voidability
A buyer agrees to pay $200,000 for a parcel because the seller says a shopping center will soon open next door. No shopping center is planned. The buyer's error did not come from the buyer's own judgment of value; it came from the seller's statement. The Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 164(1) addresses exactly this situation. If a party's manifestation of assent (the words or conduct by which that party signals agreement) is induced by either a fraudulent or a material misrepresentation by the other party, and the recipient is justified in relying on it, the contract is voidable by the recipient.1 That sentence contains four requirements: a misrepresentation, a fraudulent or material character, inducement of the recipient's assent, and justified reliance. This section defines the central word and states the consequence of meeting the test. The sections that follow take the requirements one at a time.
The Restatement defines a misrepresentation in one short sentence: it is an assertion that is not in accord with the facts.2 The definition compares the statement with the facts and stops there. Whether the speaker lied, carelessly failed to check, or simply erred in good faith has no bearing on whether a misrepresentation exists.3 Those three states of mind matter for sorting, though. Restatement (Second) § 159 divides misrepresentations into three categories with different rules. A misrepresentation is fraudulent when the maker knows it is false and intends to induce the other party's agreement. It is negligent when the maker did not know it was untrue but failed to use reasonable care in checking the facts. It is innocent when the maker was without fault.4 Fraud is therefore the narrower concept. It requires a material misrepresentation and usually scienter, an intention to deceive and induce reliance.5
Halpert v. Rosenthal puts the breadth of the definition to work. The seller was the plaintiff, and the buyer counterclaimed on the strength of statements that the house had no termites. The seller argued that the buyer could not prevail without evidence that she or her agent knew at the time that the statement was untrue. Because the representations were made in good faith, she said, the buyer's counterclaim failed as a matter of law.6 The court disagreed. It held that an innocent misrepresentation of a material fact warrants a claim for rescission.7 The seller's good faith, however sincere, did not change what the buyer had been told.
The definition reaches assertions, but an assertion need not be a flat false sentence. A half-truth can misrepresent: a statement that is literally true of the fact stated may still produce a false implication about other facts. A dog seller who says the dog ate well last night has made a misrepresentation if the dog later became so sick that the veterinarian pumped its stomach.8 Partial disclosure works the same way. A party who reads a proposed contract to the other and leaves out portions has made a misrepresentation by omission.9 Pure silence is treated more cautiously. In Massachusetts, for example, a seller of a house need not disclose that it is infested with termites, although the seller must disclose conditions dangerous to health and safety.10 Opinions, statements of intention, and silence each raise the question whether the other party said anything that can be false in the relevant sense, and later sections take them up in turn.
Section 164(1) attaches one consequence to a misrepresentation that satisfies its requirements: the contract is voidable by the recipient. A voidable contract is valid and binding until the recipient elects to avoid it. The recipient may affirm and hold the maker to the bargain, or avoid and be released, and the option belongs to the victim alone. If the contract were void, so that it never bound anyone, the party who told the lie could escape the deal by pointing to its own misstatement, and the law would reward the wrongdoer. A voidable contract keeps the maker bound while the victim decides. It also serves a victim who learns that the lie did no harm, such as a buyer who finds that a misdescribed house is still worth the price. The same label applies to conveyances. Where a deed has all the essential legal requisites, it conveys legal title, and fraud in the inducement makes that effective deed voidable in equity.11
Avoidance also differs from the tort of deceit, which shares the vocabulary but asks more of the plaintiff. Tort liability attaches to one who fraudulently makes a material misrepresentation to induce another to act or refrain from acting, and it compensates the economic loss caused by the other's justifiable reliance.12 The contract defense is wider on the maker's state of mind. It can rest on a material misrepresentation that is not fraudulent, so it reaches an innocent speaker whose good faith would answer a charge of fraud.13 The remedies available to the victim are taken up at the end of this chapter.
The maker's state of mind enters at the second step and decides how much more the recipient must show. A fraudulent misrepresentation supports avoidance irrespective of the importance of the fact misstated. A misrepresentation that is not fraudulent must be material.18