Concept
Contracts Within Several Classes
Whether the contract is within the Statute of Frauds
Contracts Within Several Classes
A contract may be within one or more sections of the Statute of Frauds, so an oral-contract problem is not finished when the first class fails to fit.1 The statute forbids enforcement of contracts in its listed classes unless there is a written memorandum or an applicable exception.2 The land clause and the one-year clause are independent provisions, and an agreement within either one is subject to the statutory requirements.3 Courts ordinarily consider the clauses separately and apply the most restrictive.4
The one-year clause is the likeliest source of overlap. On the traditional view it applies to all contracts no matter what their subject matter, so a promise can belong to one class because of what it concerns and to the one-year class because of when it can be performed.5 A lease shows how timing alone can bring a contract into the statute. An oral lease of real estate for a term of one year that begins in the future is within the Statute of Frauds, because it cannot be performed within one year of the date the contract was made. It remains subject to the statute unless it is removed from it or performed.6 The year runs from the time the contract is made, not from the start of performance.7
A promise to give land in return for long service falls within two clauses at once.
The land clause reaches this promise because it covers a promise to transfer any interest in land to any person, and its wording does not depend on a price.8 The one-year clause reaches it too, because five years of care cannot be fully performed within a year of the making.9 The granddaughter therefore faces two separate bars.
Exceptions attach clause by clause, which is why the overlap matters. Once one party completes performance, the one-year provision no longer prevents enforcement of the other parties' promises, so the granddaughter's five completed years answer the one-year clause.10 That rule says nothing about the land clause. She still needs a written memorandum or an exception that applies to land contracts. Part performance is the example: a land contract that is specifically enforceable under that doctrine is not blocked by the other clauses.11
An exemption from one clause does not carry over to another. Mutual promises to marry, standing alone, fall outside the clause for promises made in consideration of marriage, yet the weight of authority places them within the one-year provision when they cannot be performed within a year.12
The reverse mistake is treating a contract as within a clause merely because its subject touches the clause. Wheelock's bid on five parcels succeeded, but he refused to let title to two of them pass to Thies, who sued to enforce Wheelock's oral agreement to transfer them. Wheelock raised the statute of frauds as a defense, and the court rejected it. The agreement concerned land, but it was not a contract for the transfer of an interest in land: neither party owned the property when they contracted, and the transfer would occur later between the owner and the buyer.13 The land clause asks whether the promise transfers an interest in land, and a contract about land can answer no.
Goods contracts are the place where the modern rule loosens the independence of the clauses. A contract for the sale of goods for $500 or more is not enforceable unless there is a record sufficient to indicate that a contract for sale has been made, signed by the party against whom enforcement is sought or by that party's authorized agent or broker. The record is not insufficient because it omits or misstates a term, but the contract is not enforceable beyond the quantity of goods the record shows.14 On the traditional view, a goods contract that could not be performed within a year would also have to satisfy the one-year section.15 The weight of recent authority holds instead that a goods contract satisfying the UCC's statute of frauds need not satisfy the one-year section, even if it cannot be performed within a year of the making.16 The Code's own writing requirement still applies; the majority rule removes only the second hurdle.
Because the authorities are not uniform, an answer that names no jurisdiction should state the weight of recent authority and note the older view.