Concept
Timing of the Memorandum
Whether a memorandum satisfies the Statute of Frauds
Timing of the Memorandum
The Statute does not say when the memorandum must be written, and Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 136 answers that it may be made or signed at any time before or after the contract is formed.1 The answer follows from what the Statute checks. Its original purpose was evidentiary: to give a court proof that a contract exists and what it covers, in an era when the parties could not testify for themselves.2 A signed writing offers the same proof a week before the handshake as a month after it, so the rule runs in both directions, each with its own reason. The Statute no longer always serves that purpose, since courts enforce contracts on oral testimony about a lost writing. The purpose still explains why the date of a signed writing matters so little.
A memorandum may exist before the contract does. A written offer signed by the offeror may itself be a sufficient memorandum to bind the offeror, and a memorandum or signature made before formation may be adopted afterward.3 In the typical case the offeror signs the terms, the offeree accepts orally, and the writing predates the contract it evidences. The order of events adds nothing, because the offeror's signature already records the commitment that the claimant says the other side accepted. Adoption is developed in the later sections on combining writings and on what counts as a signature.
A memorandum may equally come last. Nothing requires it to be contemporaneous with the contract, and it may be made even after breach or repudiation.4 Nor must the writer have prepared it to satisfy the Statute.5 The payroll card in Crabtree v. Elizabeth Arden Sales Corp. shows how ordinary such a writing can be. Miss Arden had offered a two-year contract at $20,000 for the first six months, $25,000 for the next six, and $30,000 for the second year, and Crabtree had called the offer "interesting."6 When he reported for work, a "pay-roll change" card was made up, initialed by Mr. Johns, and forwarded to the payroll department. It named the parties, gave Crabtree's job classification, and set out the same pay scale.7 The card was an office record, not a memorandum drafted to evidence a contract. Whether it satisfied the Statute, alone or with other writings, is a question for the later discussion of Crabtree.
A late memorandum works because the Statute asks whether a signed acknowledgment exists, and an acknowledgment proves the signer's assent as well after the deal as before it, even after the signer has repudiated. A rule demanding a contemporaneous writing would protect the party who signed nothing until trouble began. It would also let a signer escape a deal that he later admitted in writing. The defendant's power to validate the contract by signing an appropriate writing shows what the Statute is. That power could not exist if the oral contract had never come into being, so the Statute limits the enforcement of a contract that exists.8
The opening words of many statutes, "No action shall be brought," have sometimes been read to require a memorandum made before the lawsuit began.9 The first Restatement took that position.10 Comment b to § 136 treats the objection as a procedural defect that modern statutes or rules of court cure. The Reporter's Note adds that the Second Restatement omitted the earlier section on satisfying the Statute after an action is begun, as procedural and contrary to the spirit of modern procedural reforms.11 A memorandum made after breach but before suit is therefore timely beyond doubt.
The timing rule frees only the date. It leaves the content and signature requirements where they were, and the Reporter's Note reports two limits from Computer Servicenters, Inc. v. Beacon Mfg. Co. The court said in dictum that minutes of a directors' meeting would be a satisfactory memorandum if they contained an offer later accepted orally. It held, however, that minutes merely authorizing a corporate officer to enter into a contract on specified terms did not satisfy the Statute, even though the officer later made an oral contract on those terms.12 The two kinds of minutes differ in what they record. Minutes containing an offer record a commitment on definite terms, and they supply the evidence the Statute wants wherever they fall on the calendar. Minutes that only authorize an officer to contract record permission. Permission is not a statement that a contract has been made or offered, which is what a sufficient writing must indicate.13
The same case supplies the second limit: an agent cannot make a memorandum satisfying the Statute after the agent's authority has ended.14 Section 131 accepts a writing signed by the party to be charged or on that party's behalf.15 An agent speaks for the principal only while the authority lasts. A writing signed by an authorized agent, even long after the oral agreement, carries the principal's acknowledgment. One signed after the principal withdrew the authority carries only the words of someone with no power to bind the principal.
Neither writing in those holdings failed because of when it was made. The minutes failed on content, because they indicated no contract made or offered, and the agent's writing failed on signature, because it was not the principal's act. When a question supplies a late writing, treat it as if it had been timely and then ask the content and signature questions.