Concept
Drafting Around Gaps
Court supplies an omitted essential term
Drafting Around Gaps
A court can finish an incomplete contract, but a drafter should not leave it the job. When the parties to a bargain sufficiently defined to be a contract have not agreed on a term essential to their rights and duties, Section 204 has the court supply a term that is reasonable in the circumstances.1 The missing term can usually be supplied one way or another, so the contract probably survives.2 The drafter reads the same rule from the other side: any contract that has to be salvaged this way reflects poorly on whoever wrote it.3 Drafting around gaps therefore has two parts. The drafter must know what the law will add when a document is silent, and must write down the important terms anyway.
The first part is an inventory. Statutes frequently contain "unless otherwise agreed" provisions that supply omitted terms for certain types of contracts, and UCC Article 2 contains innumerable gap fillers, meaning terms read into a contract for the sale of goods when the contract is silent.4 Even without a statute, a court that finds the parties intended a contract may imply a term to keep the transaction from failing. If the contract says nothing about the time for performance, for example, courts will often hold that performance must come within a reasonable time.5 Custom and usage are implied terms of many contracts under both the common law and the UCC, and courts will imply a covenant of good faith and fair dealing in certain types of contracts.6 With this inventory, a drafter can predict what silence will mean on each point and ask whether the client can live with that meaning.
Knowing that a term will be implied is no reason to leave it implied, for three reasons. The first is surprise. The drafter may know which term a court will imply, but the parties may not, and a client who later learns that the contract does not say what was intended will be angry at the lawyer who relied on the default.7 Even when the implied term matches what the client wants, the better practice is to make it express.8 The second is mismatch. The supplied term may be one that one or even both parties would never have agreed to originally.9 The third is expense. The supplied term nearly always comes only after costly litigation, which means the client pays for a lawsuit to learn what one sentence could have said at signing.10
The two patio contracts differ in when the timing question gets answered. The first reconstructs the answer after a dispute, and the second records it in advance. A contract has more than one audience, and one of them is a later court or other entity enforcing it after voluntary performance has ceased.11 An express term gives that reader something to apply. Without one, the reader must rebuild the term from the surrounding circumstances. The existence of a gap-filler shows only that the contract will probably survive. It does not show that the term filled in will be the one the client wanted.
Some omissions are conscious. The parties may agree at signing to settle a term later, such as the price for a second year, because the information needed to set it does not yet exist. A clause that says only that the term is to be agreed commits the parties to nothing a court can measure, and an agreement of that kind may be regarded as illusory, meaning it appears to bind but gives the court nothing to enforce. To prevent that result, the drafter should do one of three things:12
- Impose a good faith bargaining requirement, which turns the deferral into a promise about process, so that a party who stonewalls has breached a duty a court can identify.
- Identify an objective basis for supplying the term, such as a formula, a published market index, or an independent appraisal, so that a figure from outside the negotiation fixes the term.
- Provide for mediation or binding arbitration, so that an impasse goes to a neutral instead of to a lawsuit.
Without any of these, a bare "to be agreed" clause leaves a failure to agree to litigation, and the term then arrives after the fact, from a court, and may be one neither side would have chosen.13 The earlier discussion of agreements to agree explains why a court may be reluctant to fill such a clause at all.
Each of the three devices lets the deferred term be fixed without anyone choosing it for the parties after the dispute has begun. Because a court-supplied term is only a fallback for what the parties have not agreed, the safest contract is one that gives the fallback nothing to do.14