Concept
When Agreement Controls
Omitted place of delivery
When Agreement Controls
Section 2-308 opens with the words "Unless otherwise agreed," and those words turn every rule that follows into a default, a term the statute supplies only when the parties have supplied none of their own.1 The order of analysis follows from that clause. The seller's place of business, the seller's residence, and the location of identified goods come last, after the search for an agreed place has come up empty. How often those defaults apply therefore depends on how far the word "agreed" reaches.
It reaches well past the words the parties spoke or signed. Three routes carry a term of place into a contract. Express agreement states where delivery occurs. Implied agreement leaves place unsaid but draws it from the parties' earlier deals or from the practice of their trade. A shipment or destination term such as F.O.B. fixes place by trade shorthand. A problem that supplies any one of the three has already answered the delivery question, and the seller's-place default would give the wrong answer.
Express Agreement
The surest way to displace § 2-308 is to say where delivery happens. The parties may specify the place of delivery in their contract,2 and a term that does so controls.3 The seller's place of business, the seller's residence, and the location of identified goods never come into play. A default operates only on ground the parties have left empty, so a term that answers the question of place occupies that ground before the statute can reach it.
The parties are better placed to choose than the drafters of a general rule, because they know facts the rule cannot. They know where the goods sit, what each side can bear in the cost and risk of moving them, and how they ordinarily deal with each other. A buyer with its own loading dock may find it cheaper to receive goods than to send a truck for them, and a seller who stores inventory in a distant warehouse may prefer to hand it over there. The default spares parties from drafting a clause on a detail they never discussed, and a default that overrode their actual words would impose a rule they never chose. A buyer and seller who know the statutory gap-filler but prefer a different answer are therefore free to write one.4 The Code makes the same point in general terms: its provisions may be varied by agreement, and the appearance of "unless otherwise agreed" in some sections does not make the sections without the phrase mandatory (§ 1-302(a), (c)).5
A term displaces the default only if it speaks to place. Problems often include delivery language that sounds decisive but answers a different question, and treating any mention of delivery as an answer to the location question is a common mistake. Time and place are separate gaps, and the seller's-place default fills the second.6
Not every Code term yields so easily. The obligation of good faith in performing and enforcing a contract is imposed by law, and the parties cannot disclaim it by agreement. The place of delivery is a logistical detail. The constructive term that fills it rests on the parties' presumed intention and not on strong policy, so it gives way to whatever they agree, expressly or by implication.7 A clause fixing delivery at the buyer's dock is enforced as written, and a clause excusing both sides from acting in good faith would not be. The same sorting question works on other Code terms: does the term protect a basic policy that the parties may not bargain away, or does it supply a convenience for contracts that happen to be silent?
A careful drafter names the place of delivery and does not lean on the implied term. The drafter may know that § 2-308 will fill the gap, but the client may not, and a client who learns after a dispute that the contract carried a term nobody mentioned is unlikely to be pleased. Even when the implied term matches what the client wants, the better practice is to make it express.8
Course of Dealing and Usage
The place-of-delivery rules of § 2-308 apply only when the parties have not otherwise agreed, and the Code's idea of agreement reaches beyond the words the parties spoke or signed.10 The seller's-place default in subsection (a) therefore gives way when the parties' history together, or the settled practice of their trade, shows where delivery was meant to occur.11 A course of dealing is the pattern in which the same two parties handled their earlier transactions. A usage of trade is a practice so regularly followed in an industry that parties working in it can be expected to follow it too. Each is a source from which a court finds terms the parties impliedly understood to be part of their deal.12 Each has a fuller treatment elsewhere, so this section takes up only its effect on the place of delivery.
The Code's vocabulary draws the line that explains why these sources can override the statute. A term found because the parties' conduct or the surrounding circumstances show what they intended is an implied term. A term the law imposes, whether on the basis of presumed intention or without regard to intention, is a constructive term, because its source is judicial construction.13 The place rule in § 2-308 is of the second kind, while a pattern of dealing yields an implied term that reflects what these parties actually intended.14 When the two collide, the implied term wins. A rule built on a guess about what typical parties want has no claim against evidence of what these parties wanted, and the place rules carry no strong policy that would keep the parties from contracting around them.
B's argument is strong because S can hardly call the request a surprise: S has done the same thing three times before.15 The earlier deals involved other equipment, but the argument turns on the parties' habit and not on the product. If it succeeds, the delivery term is implied from the parties' conduct, and the statutory default never applies.
Usage of trade works the same way, except that the pattern comes from an industry and not from a relationship. A court applying Texas law faced a letter that failed to specify a place for delivery of cross-ties. It observed that Tex. Bus. & Com. Code § 2.308 provides a place, "[u]nless otherwise agreed," the seller's place of business, and it added that the record reflected a common practice in the cross-tie industry of the seller delivering the ties to the buyer's place of business.16 The two sources point to different places, the statute to the seller's and the industry practice to the buyer's, and the passage does not say which would control if the difference mattered. The answer comes from the Code's structure and not from the court: an industry practice that actually governs the deal is an implied term and displaces the default.
A contract that is silent on place in its text may still carry an answer in the parties' history or in their trade. Facts about earlier transactions or an industry custom signal that the statutory default is not yet the answer, and they belong ahead of the gap-filler in the analysis. The usual error is to reach for the seller's place of business the moment the writing goes quiet. A second error is to call the pattern-based term constructive, when the pattern yields an implied term and the statutory default is the constructive one.
Shipment and Destination Terms
A mercantile term such as F.O.B. leaves the seller's-place default nothing to fill.18 When goods travel, the point at which the seller's duty ends decides who arranges the transport and who bears the risk while the goods are on the road. Parties who settle that allocation in a trade term have answered the question of place, and because § 2-308 applies only to a gap, the term controls and the default is never reached. The Code adopted the trade symbols already in use in business, so cases in which parties who contemplated transportation used no symbol are infrequent.19
The seller's basic obligation is to deliver the goods in accordance with the contract, and a shipment or destination term tells the seller what "deliver" requires.20 A shipment contract requires or authorizes the seller to send the goods to the buyer without requiring delivery at a particular destination. Its usual form is F.O.B. the seller's place of business, under which the seller must, at that place, ship the goods in the manner § 2-504 provides and bear the expense and risk of putting them into the carrier's possession.21 Tender therefore occurs at the seller's end of the journey. Section 2-504 spells out the seller's three duties:
- The seller must put the goods in the possession of a carrier and make a contract for their transportation that is reasonable in light of the nature of the goods and the circumstances, as when perishable goods are shipped under refrigeration.
- The seller must obtain and promptly deliver or tender the documents, such as a bill of lading, that the buyer needs in order to obtain possession of the goods from the carrier.
- The seller must promptly notify the buyer of the shipment, for example by sending an invoice.
Each duty answers a risk that opens once the goods leave the seller's hands. The buyer cannot supervise the trip, so the seller, who makes the shipping arrangements, must make them reasonably. The buyer needs the documents because the carrier releases the goods on the strength of that paper, and it needs prompt notice so that someone is ready to receive the shipment. Because tender occurs at the shipping point, the place of delivery and the place where the buyer takes possession come apart, and the payment default follows the second. Unless the parties agree otherwise, payment is due at the time and place the buyer is to receive the goods, even though the place of shipment is the place of delivery.22 The next section returns to that point.
A destination contract reverses the allocation. Under a term such as F.O.B. the buyer's place of business, the seller must transport the goods at its own expense and risk to that place and tender delivery there.23 The seller's performance is incomplete until the goods reach the named place, so the burden of the whole journey stays with the seller. The buyer's part begins on arrival.
A variation on a sale of lamb pelts by a Canadian seller shows how one word moves the place. It asks whether the result would change if the contract had called for delivery F.O.B. Philadelphia instead of F.O.B. Toronto, and it rests on the Code's distinction between a term naming the place of shipment and a term naming the place of destination.24 With Toronto, the seller's duty is to put conforming pelts with a carrier there under a reasonable shipping contract, and tender occurs in Toronto. With Philadelphia, the seller must carry the pelts to Philadelphia and tender them there. The same goods, parties, and price produce a different place of tender. The variation then asks whether a seller who had undertaken to deliver in Philadelphia would necessarily breach if United States import regulations blocked arrival. That question of risk and excuse is not resolved here.
Agreement still controls at each step. The Code's treatment of F.O.B. terms is qualified by the opening phrase "Unless otherwise agreed," so the parties may move a burden away from what the label ordinarily implies.25 A seller under an F.O.B. seller's-place term can agree to bear the risk all the way to the destination, even though the label alone would not impose it.26 The same attention to the full clause matters when the language mixes the two models. In Bliss Produce Co. v. A.E. Albert & Sons, Inc., an Arizona seller breached a contract to deliver potatoes to a North Carolina buyer, and the contract called for delivery "Arizona, F.O.B., grade guaranteed to destination."27 The court chose North Carolina as the place to measure damages without discussing where tender occurred.28 A clause that pairs a shipping-point label with a guarantee running to the destination invites that question, and a drafter who states the place of tender outright avoids it.
A contract that uses a trade term calls for reading the term before the statute. Treating § 2-308 as the starting point whenever goods are shipped overlooks that the term has already placed delivery. Reading F.O.B. seller's place as an instruction for the buyer to collect at the plant overlooks that the seller must still put the goods with a carrier and notify the buyer.29 This section treats these terms only for their effect on the place of delivery, and the mechanics of tender and the passage of risk of loss are developed in their own treatment.