Concept
Place Anchors Tender and Payment
Omitted place of delivery
Place Anchors Tender and Payment
Tender and payment must each happen somewhere, and a contract silent on logistics does not say where. Section 2-308(a) answers for both: unless otherwise agreed, the place for delivery is the seller's place of business, or the seller's residence if the seller has none.1 Courts and legislatures do not pick such terms out of the air. They draw them from common expectations, commercial practice, and public policy, and they aim at what the parties likely would have agreed had they discussed the point. A court that applies one is construing the contract, not finding what these particular parties meant.2
A single silent contract shows how the defaults fit together. Suppose a seller and a buyer agree on one delivery of goods for $5,000 and say nothing about where, when, or how the goods change hands. The Code supplies each missing term, and the terms converge on one event: within a reasonable time, at the seller's place of business, the seller tenders the whole order in a single delivery, unless the circumstances make delivery in lots commercially necessary.3
The seller's tender at that place has real content. The seller must put and hold conforming goods at the buyer's disposition, give the buyer any notice needed to take delivery, and let the buyer inspect them.4 Each of those acts needs a location. Goods have to be held available somewhere, a notice has to tell the buyer where to come, and an inspection happens wherever the goods sit. Without a default place, the seller would have no spot at which to perform and the buyer no moment at which its own duty to respond begins. The buyer carries a matching burden: it must furnish facilities reasonably suited to receiving the goods, and unless that duty is excused, a failure to do so puts it in breach.5
Payment follows the same anchor. Unless otherwise agreed, the buyer must tender payment at the time and place where it is to receive the goods.6 In the silent contract the buyer receives the goods at the seller's premises, so the place of delivery and the place of payment are one. They separate only when the buyer receives the goods somewhere else. In a shipment contract, the seller delivers to a carrier at its own end, and the Code defers the buyer's duty to pay until the time and place of the buyer's receipt. There the buyer can exercise its right to inspect before paying without traveling to the seller's city.7
Delivery and payment meet at one place because neither side has to go first. The Code frames the exchange as mutual: the seller must deliver the goods, and the buyer must accept and pay for them in accordance with the contract.8 Unless otherwise agreed, the buyer is entitled to full possession and control only if it concurrently tenders payment. The seller must make the goods available for inspection, but it need not give up possession until it is paid. The buyer's payment and the seller's relinquishment of full possession and control are therefore concurrent conditions.9 The consequence is practical. A buyer who arrives, inspects the goods, and demands them without offering payment has not tendered, and the seller's refusal to release them is no breach.
The seller's right to hold the goods until it is paid assumes that it has not agreed to extend credit.10 When it has, the buyer takes the goods first and pays on the agreed schedule.
The same place anchors rules outside the exchange itself. Where the goods are never shipped, as under an F.O.B. shipping point contract, market price for a buyer's damages is measured at the place for tender, the seller's place of business, on the assumption that the buyer will look for a replacement contract at the shipping point.11 Delivery also nearly always requires moving the goods, even between next-door neighbors, and movement carries risk: the carrier may lose them, its employees may damage them, thieves may steal them, and fire, storm, or shipwreck may take their toll.12 Where the goods change hands therefore matters beyond the performance itself.