Concept
Gap Filling Under Article 2
Omitted time for performance
Reasonable Time as a Gap Filler
Gap Filling Under Article 2
Most contract rules come from state common law, but the Uniform Commercial Code is the important statutory exception.1 Article 2 of the Code governs contracts for the sale of goods, and one of its most practical jobs is to answer silence. Merchants often agree on what is being sold and for how much, then say nothing about when the seller must ship. Article 2 answers that omission in two steps. First, it keeps the contract alive: under § 2-204(3), a contract for sale does not fail for indefiniteness merely because a term is left open, provided the parties intended to make a contract and there is a reasonably certain basis for giving an appropriate remedy.2 Second, it supplies the missing term. For time, § 2-309(1) provides that when neither Article 2 nor the agreement fixes the time for shipment, delivery, or any other action under the contract, the time is a reasonable time.3
That second step is gap filling. A gap filler is a term the law implies to supplement a contract's express language. It supplies a logically inferable term when the parties clearly intended a contract but did not address the question, and it usually applies only when no contextual evidence establishes the term as a matter of fact.4 Courts developed some gap fillers and legislatures enacted others, but none is picked out of the air. Each rests on common expectations, commercial practice, and public policy.5
Section 2-204(3) sets two conditions, and each does separate work. The first asks whether the parties meant to be bound, and the more terms they leave open, the less likely it is that they did.6 The second asks whether a court has a reasonably certain basis for giving an appropriate remedy, because a court that cannot say what was promised cannot say what was lost.7 Without the rule, a party who regretted a bargain could escape it by pointing to a term neither side bothered to write down.
When both conditions are met, the Code fills the open term. If the parties conclude a contract without settling the price, the price is a reasonable price at the time for delivery.8 Courts reached the same result before the Code, and the Code continued it. A reasonable price may be measured by the market price or, where no market exists, by cost plus a reasonable profit.9 Time follows the same pattern. Courts assumed a reasonable time when no time was stated for delivering goods, completing a building, transferring real property, making installment payments, or seeking governmental approvals, so § 2-309(1) codifies a general principle rather than a special rule for sales.10
The reasoning behind the time default explains why it yields to an express date. The law has no policy of its own to impose on time of delivery, which should be whenever the parties intended. A party who fails to name a date most plausibly expected performance within a period reasonable under all the circumstances.11 The default therefore records presumed intent, and it applies only when the time is not agreed upon.12
Gap filling works only where an objective yardstick exists. A reasonable price can be measured against the market or against cost plus profit, and a reasonable time can be measured against the circumstances of the transaction, as the sections that follow show. Quantity has no such measure. Goods may have a market price, but there is no market quantity.13 Courts likewise refuse to fill a gap when the parties omit the kind of goods, because no objective standard can ordinarily be found.14 One summary of the Code puts it bluntly: all terms except quantity may be implied, and a statement of quantity is essential.15 Quantity may be stated as a specific number or measured by a seller's total output or a buyer's requirements, and parties who use neither form will not form a contract without a stated quantity.16
The computer deal survives because the missing term has an objective measure and the quantity is fixed. The fan deal fails because the missing term is the one that defines what was promised.
A drafter should treat these defaults as a safety net rather than a plan. A drafter who relies on an implied term may know the law will supply it while the parties do not, and a client who expected something else will be unpleasantly surprised later. Even when the implied term matches the client's wishes, the better practice is to write it down.17 A reasonable time is an especially poor term to leave unwritten, because it is measured only after a dispute arises, and each party may honestly hold a different expectation. An express date removes that disagreement and displaces the default. Parties who notice the silence after signing can address it by modification, but Article 2 requires a modification to meet the test of good faith, and a market shift may supply a good-faith reason.18