Concept
What a Condition Is
Conditions (express and constructive)
Express and Constructive Conditions
What a Condition Is
Two questions separate a contract that binds from a duty that can be enforced today. The first asks whether a valid contract exists, so that neither side may walk away at will. The second asks whether a particular duty of performance has come due, so that the other side may demand it now and call a failure to give it a breach. A condition sits between the two. The Restatement defines it this way: “A condition is an event, not certain to occur, which must occur, unless its non-occurrence is excused, before performance under a contract becomes due.”1 Each phrase of that sentence does separate work.
- A condition is an event, which may be an act of one of the parties, an act of a third person, or any other fact of the physical world.2
- The event must be not certain to occur, because uncertainty is what makes it a risk the parties are allocating between them.
- The event must occur before performance becomes due, so the party whose duty depends on it may hold back performance until it happens.
- The requirement yields if the non-occurrence is excused, a qualification that lets a duty ripen without the event and that this chapter takes up later.
The four parts combine into one rule on which the rest of the chapter depends: performance of a duty subject to a condition cannot become due unless the condition occurs or its non-occurrence is excused.3 The contract is formed, but the rights it creates in the other party are held in abeyance until the condition occurs. A breach is a failure to perform when performance is due, so a party whose duty has not ripened cannot be in breach for holding back.4 The condition therefore answers a question that must be settled before any breach analysis can begin: has the duty ripened at all?
Fire insurance is the standard illustration. A homeowner pays a premium, and the insurer promises to pay for serious fire damage that occurs during the policy year. The insurer owes nothing unless a fire occurs, and until one does, whatever rights the insured might otherwise have are in abeyance.5 Fire damage is thus a condition of the payment duty. It also shows how a condition differs from a promise, because neither party promises that the house will burn.6 A promise creates a duty, while a condition postpones one.7 The device lets both sides commit now and leave an uncertain event to resolve later, which is why the law of conditions is fundamental to the contractual allocation of risk.8
Certainty defeats condition status. In the pole-climbing illustration, a climber accepts an offer by scaling a pole, and the promisor agrees to pay $10 next Tuesday. Payment is not due until Tuesday, yet the promisor's duty is unconditional, because Tuesday is certain to arrive and no contingent event must occur first.9 The passage of time postpones performance without allocating any risk, and a term that allocates no risk leaves nothing for a condition to do. The fire, by contrast, might never happen, which is why the insurer can end the year owing nothing.
Legal writing also uses the word loosely, and the looseness can mislead. It sometimes means any term of an agreement at all, and in property and trust law it can mean an event that limits a transfer. The Restatement sets those usages aside and keeps the word for an event that qualifies a duty under a contract, for the sake of precision.10 The same precision governs timing. The older vocabulary called an event that must occur before a duty arises a condition precedent, and it called an event that extinguishes a duty already due a condition subsequent. The Restatement uses the plain word condition for the first and treats the second as a terminating event under § 230, which this chapter takes up later.11 Courts, even those that follow the Restatement, still often use the older labels, so you should recognize both vocabularies.12 How an event comes to be a condition, and when its non-occurrence is excused, come in the sections that follow. This section fixes what a condition is and what it does to the timing of a duty.