Concept
Discharge When a Condition Fails
Conditions (express and constructive)
Discharge When a Condition Fails
A condition that has not occurred leaves a conditional duty in one of two very different states, and this section turns on telling them apart. Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 225, performance of a duty subject to a condition cannot become due unless the condition occurs or its non-occurrence is excused.1 Section 225(2) supplies the other half: unless the non-occurrence has been excused, the duty is discharged, meaning ended for good, once the condition can no longer occur.2 While the event is still possible, the duty waits. Once the event is impossible, the duty is gone.
Bertha's horse purchase shows both states on one timeline. She has agreed to buy on condition that a veterinarian certify the animal by noon on the closing date. At 10:00 a.m., with no certificate yet, the condition has not occurred but still can, so her duty is not yet due and she remains bound to a contract that may ripen. Merger agreements work the same way: the parties sign a binding contract, name the conditions to be met before a closing months away, and stay bound in the meantime.3 When noon passes without a certificate, the condition can never occur, and Bertha's duty is forever discharged. If her contract also makes time of the essence, the deadline holds to the minute: a veterinarian who misses noon by one minute gives her the right to refuse to buy.4
Discharge relieves Bertha without voiding the agreement. The contract is not void when a condition fails; the party whose duty depended on the event simply does not have to perform.5 A deadline is the usual way an event becomes impossible, but the test is impossibility itself, so anything that makes the event unable to occur has the same effect.6
The two states follow from how a conditional duty is built. Such a duty ripens only if the condition occurs or is excused, so a duty whose condition can never occur can never ripen, and discharge records that fact.7 Until that point the duty may still ripen, which is why the contract keeps binding both sides while the event remains possible.
The option-notice illustration shows the rule costing the party who needed the event. Sprawling Malls held an option to buy land that had to be exercised in a stated manner and within a stated time, and its notice arrived a day late. Had the condition's language been unclear, a court might have had room to read it generously, but this language was unambiguous and gave no basis for an interpretation favorable to Sprawling Malls.8 Unless some ground excused exact compliance, the day's delay meant the condition was not fulfilled, and Sprawling Malls lost its right to buy.9
A land sale conditioned on tax liens being discharged by July 31 follows the same pattern. The seller pays the arrears at once and works diligently, but the county discharges the liens on August 1. Because the condition is express, it is strictly enforced; the buyer may refuse to proceed, and the seller cannot argue that an August 1 discharge was substantial satisfaction.10 Effort is a separate question from occurrence. The seller's diligence does not bring the condition about, and the missed date ended the buyer's duty.
In a 1986 decision, the lapse cost a party the chance to leave a contract rather than the chance to enter one. The buyers of real estate could cancel on written notice to the seller within three days if the property taxes proved to exceed $3,500. Their attorney telephoned the seller's counsel the day after contracting and mailed a certified letter on the second day, but the seller did not receive the letter until the sixth day. The court called it settled law that a written notice required by a contract is ineffective unless actually received within the stated time.11 The call was oral, and the only written notice arrived too late, so the attempted cancellation failed. The deadline closes the opportunity for whichever party the event would have served.
Two questions sit beside this rule, and the chapter takes them up later. Whether an event that arrives slightly off the stated terms counts as the condition is the question of strict compliance. Whether a lapse can be forgiven is the question of excuse, which § 225(2) signals with its opening phrase, unless it has been excused. Discharge is therefore the default result of a lapse, and excuse is the exception. The usual error is to treat any absent event as a failed condition, but the calendar decides that question. While the event can still occur, the duty is only not yet due. Once it cannot, the duty is discharged unless a recognized excuse applies.