Concept
Due Performance and Breach
Common-law breach: material and partial breach
Material and Partial Breach
Due Performance and Breach
Two rules in Section 235 of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts anchor every breach problem. Full performance of a duty under a contract discharges the duty.1 And when performance of a duty is due, any nonperformance is a breach.2 A contract is a bundle of separate duties, each with its own deadline. When a deadline arrives, a duty stands in one of two positions: the party rendered what was owed and the duty is extinguished, or the party did not and the other side holds a claim.
Starting here sorts the facts before anyone argues about remedies. A claimant who calls a failure a breach must name a specific duty and show that its time had come, because a duty that is not yet due cannot be broken. A party who rendered everything the duty required leaves nothing to litigate, however much the other side regrets the bargain. And because the rule reaches any nonperformance of a due duty, a small shortfall and a total default are both breaches at this first stage. How serious the failure was matters later, when the law decides what the breach does to the parties' remaining duties and remedies.
The subsections below take those questions in turn. The first asks what full performance accomplishes. The second asks what follows when a due duty goes unperformed.
Full Performance Discharges
Section 235(1) states the successful ending of most contracts in one sentence: full performance of a duty under a contract discharges the duty.3 Discharge is the legal term for any means by which a contractual duty is extinguished, and performance is the most common of those means, though not the only one.4 A seller who delivers the promised goods, or a tenant who pays the promised rent, has done what the duty was created to require. Nothing about that duty remains to enforce. Every breach problem measures itself against this baseline, because a breach is a due duty that failed to reach this ending.
The rule has two parts that carry different weight. The word full sets the measure, and the word discharges sets the effect. A duty ends when the party renders everything it required. A performance that falls short does not end it, and the unperformed remainder stays owing. A payment of nearly the right amount therefore leaves the payment duty open, even though the payor has done most of what was asked.
The first tenant's rent duty for the month is discharged by performance, and the landlord has no claim for that payment. The second tenant's duty is not discharged. The $300 balance is still owed, and the shortfall is a breach of a due duty, as the next subsection explains. How serious a shortfall like that is belongs to a separate inquiry, taken up in the sections on partial breach and materiality, and it does not turn a partial payment into full performance. The comparison also marks the limit of this rule. Performance is one route to discharge among several, and a duty can also end by other means, including the obligee's assent to release the obligor, which this chapter takes up at the end.
Nonperformance Is Breach
Section 235(2) supplies the definition every breach claim starts from: when performance of a duty under a contract is due, any nonperformance is a breach.6 Two phrases do separate work. When performance is due sets a threshold, because a duty that has not fallen due cannot be broken. Any sets the standard, because once a duty is due the size of the shortfall has no bearing on whether a breach exists. Due-ness comes first.
A duty is due only if the time for performance has arrived and any condition on it has been satisfied or excused. The timing question can be as simple as whether the stated day, or even the stated hour, has come. Often, though, the agreement says that performance is not due unless and until some specified event has taken place.7 Section 224 calls such an event a condition: an event, not certain to occur, which must occur, unless its nonoccurrence is excused, before performance under a contract becomes due.8 Until the condition is satisfied, nonperformance is not a breach.9
A house purchase illustrates both sides of that rule. Suppose the buyer's duty to buy depends on obtaining mortgage financing. When an express condition simply fails to occur, the conditional duty never arises, and the promisor is justified in not performing.10 A buyer who applies in good faith, is refused by every lender, and declines to close is therefore not in breach. A buyer who made no effort whatever to obtain financing stands differently, because a court may well hold that the financing condition is excused on account of the buyer's bad faith. Excusing the nonoccurrence makes the conditional duty unconditional, and the same refusal to close is then a breach.11
Due-ness has a third component beyond timing and conditions: performance is not due if, for any reason, nonperformance is justified.12 Courts accordingly define a breach as an unjustified or unexcused failure to perform all or any part of what is promised.13 A sympathetic reason does not supply the justification by itself. In one reported case, the promisor's illness, hospitalization, and pending divorce did not make performance impossible, so the failure to tender the balance due was a breach.14
The threshold also means a party cannot breach early. In the warehouse lease, a tenant who has not paid the deposit on July 2 has broken nothing, because payment is not due until July 15. A tenant who tells the landlord on July 2 that it no longer intends to lease has done something different. It has manifested in advance that it will not perform when the date arrives, and that is a repudiation, made in the period before performance was due by either party.15 Repudiation is a separate doctrine, developed below with total breach. It does not turn the deposit duty into one that has already come due.
Once a duty is due and unperformed, the standard is any nonperformance, and the definition asks nothing about whether the failure was large or small. The same idea appears in the courts' phrasing of a failure to perform all or any part of what was promised.16 Every breach gives rise to a claim for damages. Even a party who sustains no pecuniary loss, or cannot prove it with sufficient certainty, has at least a claim for nominal damages. The one qualification is that if a court chooses to ignore a trifling departure, there is no breach and no claim.17 Gradations of seriousness therefore arrive in the consequences of a breach and not in its definition.
Had the same payment arrived at 4 p.m. on July 15, it would have been full performance, and the duty would have been discharged.18 A single day separates a discharged duty from a breached one, which shows how little the size of the failure matters at this stage.
Calling a failure a breach settles that the injured party has a damages claim. It does not settle that the injured party may stop performing. Take a builder who has breached the promise to build in accordance with the plans but has substantially performed. The owner recovers damages for the breach, but the constructive condition to the owner's duty to pay is fulfilled, so the owner owes the contract price minus those damages.19
Disputes about this step are common. Harrison paid only the first monthly installment, then telegraphed that Walker's failure to provide promised maintenance was a material breach, declared the contract 'Voided,' and refused to resume payments. Walker sued for the roughly $5,200 still due on the purchase price.20 Whether Harrison could do that turns on how serious Walker's breach was, the question the next sections take up.