Concept
Nature of Express Warranties
Express warranties
Creating Express Warranties
Nature of Express Warranties
An express warranty is a term the seller writes into the bargain through its own words or conduct.1 Section 2-313 of the Uniform Commercial Code names three ways to write one: an affirmation of fact or promise relating to the goods, a description of the goods, or a sample or model, each of which must become part of the basis of the bargain.2 Each route has the same effect: the goods must conform to what was affirmed, described, or shown.3 Because the seller supplies the term, express warranties rest on the “dickered” aspects of an individual bargain, the features these parties actually negotiated.4 Every express-warranty problem therefore asks the same thing: did something the seller communicated become part of the deal?
The Code’s other warranties start from the opposite premise. The warranty of title and against infringement (§ 2-312), the implied warranty of merchantability (§ 2-314), and the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose (§ 2-315) do not arise from any particular conduct of the seller; the law imposes them unless they are excluded.5 No particular language or action is needed to evidence them, and they arise automatically in common factual situations unless unmistakably negated.6 A buyer who invokes an implied warranty points to the kind of sale or seller. A buyer who invokes an express warranty points to what this seller said or showed. The implied standards can also be hard to fix: one commentator asks how strong the roof of a Ford Aerostar must be before the vehicle is unmerchantable.7 An express warranty measures the goods against the seller’s own statement.8
The law holds a seller to what it says because a specific claim does the buyer’s investigating for it. A seller who states a fact about the goods discourages the buyer from checking independently, and by making the statement without qualification the seller takes on the risk that it is wrong.9 A seller who is unsure has an easy alternative: it can describe a painting as “attributed to” an artist instead of declaring it the artist’s work.10 The market supplies a second reason. If sellers answer for their statements, every seller must price in the cost of repairing or replacing goods that fail them, and that cost runs higher for low-quality goods than for high-quality goods. Sellers of poor goods cannot afford to copy the warranties of sellers of good goods, so buyers can read an express warranty as a signal of quality.11
Any seller can make an express warranty. The Code speaks of affirmations made “by the seller,”12 and § 2-313 gives a cause of action only against a seller; a lessor or bailor answers, if at all, under Article 2A or by analogy to § 2-313.13 Merchant status is not part of the test. It belongs to the implied warranty of merchantability, which attaches to sales by a “merchant with respect to goods of that kind.”14
The seller need not use formal words such as “warrant” or “guarantee,” and need not have a specific intention to make a warranty.15 The test is objective. The Official Comment asks what statements of the seller have, “in the circumstances and in objective judgment,” become part of the basis of the bargain.16 A seller who later testifies that she meant nothing by a flat factual claim cannot unmake a warranty that the statement itself created. Most express warranties are no more than a plain statement. In many cases the seller simply makes an explicit oral or written representation that is unquestionably an affirmation of fact or promise relating to the goods. In Rhodes Pharmacal Co. v. Continental Can Co., the seller said that rustproof linings in the cans would prevent discoloration and adulteration of the Perform solution.17
Dropping the formalities does not turn every remark into a warranty. Section 2-313(2) also provides that an affirmation merely of the value of the goods, or a statement purporting to be merely the seller’s opinion or commendation, does not create a warranty.18 The line between fact and opinion gets its own section below, but two markers show how it runs. In one dispute over diamonds, the court distinguished a case in which a jeweler’s assurance of value was mere opinion, reasoning that this seller “did more than give a mere opinion of the value of the goods; he specifically described them as diamonds of ‘H color and v.v.s. quality.’”19 Verifiability marks the same boundary. A seller’s statement about when a painting was painted sounds like a factual indication rather than an opinion.20
Liability on an express warranty also does not depend on fault, which sets it apart from negligence and fraud. Fraud requires a material misrepresentation made with knowledge of its falsity or recklessly, intended to be acted on, relied on, and damaging; take away that knowledge, called scienter, and fraud closely resembles breach of an express warranty.21 A warranty claim needs no such showing. The seller may have been entirely blameless, may have said nothing but the truth as it understood it, and may have done everything humanly possible to live up to the statement, and the seller is still liable if the goods do not conform.22 A statement can reach the buyer on packaging as well as from a salesperson’s mouth; for a can-label example, see Lane v. C.A. Swanson & Sons.
Although liability does not depend on fault, the buyer still has a case to prove. The buyer must show that the seller made a warranty, that the goods did not conform to it, that the nonconformity caused the injury in fact and proximately, and what damages resulted. The seller may then raise defenses such as disclaimer, the statute of limitations, privity, lack of notice, and assumption of the risk.25 A complaint for breach of an express warranty follows the same order: a contract between the parties, containing an express warranty by the defendant about a material fact, which was part of the basis of the bargain and which the defendant breached.26 This chapter concerns the first steps in that sequence, the creation of the warranty.
The third question is where the law is least settled. Section 2-313 dropped the pre-Code requirement that the plaintiff specifically rely on the warranty.30 Some states nonetheless still demand a showing of reliance, a position that sits uneasily with the drafters’ intent.31 Breach, causation, damages, and defenses such as disclaimer come after a warranty has been found, and each has its own reading.