Concept
Coexisting and Excluded Warranties
Implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose
Coexisting and Excluded Warranties
A buyer who proves the fitness warranty and its breach still faces two questions about the rest of the sale: whether the seller's other promises crowd the warranty out, and whether the seller contracted out of it. Both turn on the last clause of § 2-315, which says the warranty arises “unless excluded or modified under the next section.”1 That clause makes the warranty a default term, a rule the law supplies when the contract is silent and that gives way to agreement only on the terms the Code sets.
The first question has a short answer: other warranties in the same sale sit beside the fitness warranty and do not displace it. The second takes longer, because the Code regulates how a seller may remove the warranty, and the buyer's trust in the seller's selection is exactly what a careless exclusion would erase.
Cumulation With Other Warranties
One sale can carry an express warranty, a warranty of merchantability, and a fitness warranty at once, because each rests on different facts. Express warranties appear in the sales agreement and become part of the basis of the bargain, while implied warranties are read in by the UCC unless language or circumstances exclude them.2 Merchantability is implied in any sale by a merchant who sells goods of that kind,3 and it promises goods of good quality that are at least fit for the ordinary purposes for which such goods are used.4 Fitness asks something different: whether the seller knew the buyer's particular purpose and knew the buyer was relying on the seller to select suitable goods.5
Overlap is routine. A hardware salesman who picks one saw from several for a buyer who needs to cut out stumps below ground level has probably made an implied fitness warranty. If he adds, “This one will work just fine,” he has made an express warranty as well. The statement gives the buyer a second route to recovery and does not cancel the first, because the fitness warranty never depended on the salesman's words. A case against Sears Roebuck & Co. shows both at work. The plaintiffs bought a riding mower on the salesman's recommendation for their hilly property, subject to his inspection of the property to confirm that the mower was appropriate, and he pronounced it suitable provided it was driven vertically up the steepest hills.6 When the mower tipped over backwards on a steep slope, the court affirmed a verdict for the husband for breach of an implied warranty of fitness in addition to breach of express warranty.7
UCC § 2-317 governs how such promises fit together, and it starts from a presumption. Warranties, express or implied, are construed as consistent with each other and as cumulative. Only when that construction is unreasonable does the parties' intention decide which warranty dominates, and then an express warranty displaces an inconsistent implied warranty other than the implied warranty of fitness for a particular purpose.
The exception for fitness makes sense in light of what the warranty rests on. A general express statement about the goods records what the parties agreed on that subject, so it can fairly override a general implied default such as merchantability. It says nothing about this buyer's particular purpose or about the buyer's reliance on the seller's choice, and letting it shrink the fitness warranty by implication would withdraw protection that the buyer's trust had earned.
None of this protects the fitness warranty from the seller's own disclaimer. Cumulation answers whether other warranties displace fitness, and § 2-316 answers whether the seller removed it.
Disclaiming the Warranty
A seller who does not want to answer for a buyer's special use can write the fitness warranty out of the contract, but only by following UCC § 2-316. The warranty arises “unless excluded or modified under the next section,”9 and implied warranties are generally easier to disclaim than the express warranties a seller makes as part of a specific agreement.10
The Code attaches formalities because buyers have difficulty evaluating and negotiating the warranties that come with a product.11 Henningsen, decided in 1960, was widely hailed for exposing sharp practices that buried disclaimers in fine print. The Code's conspicuousness requirement in § 2-316(2) invalidated the buried disclaimer, yet the same section explicitly allowed conspicuous disclaimers of merchantability that did little more than mention the word, and as states adopted the Code, the protection Henningsen offered consumers dimmed.12 The Code therefore does not forbid exclusion; it requires that the exclusion be visible. In states that permit complete exclusion of implied warranties, courts tend to disfavor disclaimers and read them narrowly in favor of consumers.13
The main route is § 2-316(2), and it treats fitness more gently than merchantability. To exclude an implied warranty of fitness, the exclusion must be by a writing and must be conspicuous, and the statute supplies a sentence that suffices: “There are no warranties which extend beyond the description on the face hereof.”14 Merchantability is harder to exclude, because the language must mention merchantability and, in a writing, must be conspicuous.15 General language such as “no warranties of any kind accompany the sale of this product” therefore excludes fitness and leaves merchantability in place.16
Conspicuousness carries real weight. The exclusion must stand out from the rest of the contract through larger, bolder, or differently colored or styled type, through a heading such as DISCLAIMER OF IMPLIED WARRANTIES, through a prominent location such as immediately above the buyer's signature line or beside a separate signature or initial line, or by any other method that protects the buyer from “unexpected and unbargained language of disclaimer.”17 Dorman v. International Harvester Co. applied that test and refused to give effect to a tractor manufacturer's disclaimer that did not stand out from its form.18 A form that sets the Code's sample sentence in capitals under a heading announcing a disclaimer, directly above the buyer's signature line, has the features the test looks for. A form that tucks the same words into a paragraph printed like those around it lacks them, and naming the warranties inside that paragraph does not rescue it.
Subsection (2) is subject to subsection (3), which offers routes that need no special wording. The best known is language such as “as is” or “with all faults,” which excludes all implied warranties, fitness included, unless the circumstances indicate otherwise.19 In common understanding that language calls the buyer's attention to the exclusion and makes plain that there is no implied warranty, so the seller need not mention fitness. In Schneider v. Miller, a court applying Ohio's version of § 2-316 relied on Official Comment 7, which explains that terms like “as is” in ordinary commercial usage mean the buyer takes the entire risk as to the quality of the goods.20 A buyer who says he wants a used generator to run a remote cabin and then buys it marked “as is” has been told, in ordinary commercial language, that the generator's quality is his risk. The seller's knowledge of his purpose does not revive the warranty, because a disclaimer operates on a warranty that would otherwise have arisen.
Examination offers a second route under subsection (3). A buyer who before contracting has examined the goods, or a sample or model, as fully as he desired, or who has refused to examine them, has no implied warranty regarding defects that an examination ought in the circumstances to have revealed.21 The limiting phrase keeps the exclusion proportionate to the buyer's knowledge. A buyer who asks for a ladder rated for three hundred pounds and, while handling it, reads a stamped 150-pound rating can hardly say he trusted the seller about the rating. A hidden weld flaw that no ordinary inspection would show stays with the seller.
The parties' own history can do what a form otherwise would, since an implied warranty can also be excluded or modified by course of dealing, course of performance, or usage of trade.22 A buyer and seller who have repeatedly dealt on terms that left out such warranties may be held to that understanding on the next deal.
A disclaimer that satisfies § 2-316 can still be overridden by law outside the Code. The UCC applies to consumer sales as well as sales between merchants, and consumer protection statutes can make some duties owed by merchants to consumers immutable.23 A number of state statutes and the federal Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act prohibit or substantially restrict disclaimers of implied warranties in sales of consumer products.24 Under that Act, a warrantor who makes a written warranty, even a “limited” one that falls short of the federal minimum standards, may not disclaim or modify an implied warranty.25 A refrigerator seller that gives a written warranty against defects and then states that all implied warranties are disclaimed has therefore not removed the fitness warranty owed to a buyer who relied on the seller to recommend a suitable model. A valid disclaimer also leaves untouched the general obligation of good faith and fair dealing, which every contract imposes as a matter of law and which the parties cannot exclude by agreement.26
Finally, a disclaimer must be part of the contract before it can operate. When a seller's terms arrive with the goods, the question is one of contract formation, and Article 2's formation rules, §§ 2-204 and 2-207, do not compel a particular answer; the debate over “rolling contracts” asks which application gives buyers the better result.27 A seller who instead adds a disclaimer after the parties have agreed is changing the contract, and the rules on modification, rescission, and waiver govern whether that change binds the buyer.28