Concept
Why Disclaimers Are Regulated
Exclusion or modification of warranties
Disclaiming Warranties Under the UCC
Why Disclaimers Are Regulated
A steering defect in a fourteen-month-old car caused it to veer off a bridge and fall to the street below, and its owner was severely injured. His 12-month, 12,000-mile express warranty had expired. His tort claims were barred by a one-year statute of limitations. And his sales contract had disclaimed the implied warranty of merchantability in compliance with §2-316(2). In Ford Motor Co. v. Moulton, the court held that the properly drawn disclaimer barred the warranty claim. The law thus gave a consumer, seriously hurt by a dangerous defect in a nearly new car, no redress.1
The result follows from what a disclaimer does. Section 2-316 governs how a seller may exclude or modify the warranties a sale would otherwise carry: the express warranties created under §2-313 and the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose under §§2-314 and 2-315.2 An effective disclaimer keeps the warranty from arising, so the buyer has nothing to sue on. A remedy limitation under §2-718 or §2-719 works later in the story. It assumes a valid warranty that the seller breached, then fixes the nature and extent of recovery, typically by confining the buyer to repair or replacement and barring incidental and consequential damages.3 Remedy limits receive their own section below.
Why does Article 2 permit a result like Moulton's at all? Because a free market lets buyers and sellers define their own deal. A buyer who pays less for old furniture or a used car, at a price reflecting both parties' view of what the item is worth in its flawed condition, may sensibly agree that the seller will not answer for unknown problems.4 Article 2 generally allows that shift of responsibility for breach of warranty from seller to buyer, which reintroduces caveat emptor into the contract.5 Yet the implied warranties are sticky defaults. Simple agreement to the contrary does not remove them, and §2-316 demands more before they drop out of the contract.6
The stickiness exists because a seller profits most from a disclaimer that the buyer never sees or understands.7 The seller also holds the informational advantage. It meets the full range of similar goods far more often than the buyer does, and so knows more about breakdown rates, likely damage, and repair costs. A merchant seller of cars knows the reliability of its automobiles better than any random customer.8 A buyer cannot price a risk that is buried in language she never notices, and a clause she cannot see is no part of a bargain. Article 2 works most fairly between merchants, who are informed and able to bargain, and it recognizes the frailties of consumer markets only in a secondary way.9
Comment 1 to §2-316 states the Code's response:
This section is designed principally to deal with those frequent clauses in sales contracts which seek to exclude “all warranties, express or implied.” It seeks to protect a buyer from unexpected and unbargained language of disclaimer by denying effect to such language when inconsistent with language of express warranty and permitting the exclusion of implied warranties only by conspicuous language or other circumstances which protect the buyer from surprise.10
The parties may restore caveat emptor, then, but the change must be made apparent to the buyer. The Code's aim is that buyers know when a product lacks a warranty that would ordinarily attach, so that sales reflect consensual bargains as far as reasonably possible.11
The comment names two ways to meet that standard: conspicuous language, or other circumstances that protect the buyer from surprise. Circumstances can do the work alone. When the buyer, before contracting, has examined the goods or a sample or model as fully as he desired, or has refused to examine them, §2-316(3)(b) leaves no implied warranty for defects that an examination ought in the circumstances to have revealed.12
A seller who wants Moulton's result must draft for it. In South Carolina Electric and Gas Co. v. Combustion Engineering, Inc., the court held that a written disclaimer was, as a matter of law, not conspicuous as subsection (2) requires for excluding the implied warranties of merchantability and fitness for a particular purpose. The agreement ran twenty-two typewritten pages, mostly single-spaced. The disclaimer sat in the last sentence of a two-paragraph item on page 17 and was indistinct in both color and type.13 Both sellers put their exclusions in the contract. What separates the cases is whether the buyer was placed to see what was being taken away. Writing does help, because an oral term must be proved word for word and the parties often remember the conversation differently.14 But a written exclusion still fails if the buyer would never have noticed it.
One warranty sits outside this machinery. The methods in §2-316(3) for disclaiming implied warranties do not apply to the warranty of title.15 Under §2-312(2), title is modified or excluded in only one of three ways: by specific language, by circumstances giving the buyer reason to know that the seller does not claim title in himself, or by circumstances giving the buyer reason to know that the seller is selling only such right or title as he or a third person may have. Goods bought from the trunk of a car parked in an alley are the standard example. Sheriff's sales and executors' sales may likewise be so far out of the ordinary commercial course as to alert the buyer.16 A clause that disclaims implied warranties therefore leaves the title warranty untouched.
The rest of the chapter takes the seller's options in turn. Express warranties come first, under subsection (1). Next is the formal route for implied warranties under subsection (2), followed by the circumstance-based routes of subsection (3) that can displace it, and then the separate question of limiting remedies under subsection (4). The chapter ends with limits that come from outside §2-316, such as unconscionability and consumer statutes, and a sequence of questions for working a problem. Along the way you will keep asking whether a term was conspicuous, a standard the section on conspicuous terms takes up directly.