Concept
Dealing and Usage
Exclusion or modification of warranties
Dealing and Usage
A seller can exclude an implied warranty without saying a word about warranties, if the parties' history or the habits of their trade already told the buyer what was on offer. Subsection (3)(c) of §2-316 says so directly: an implied warranty can also be excluded or modified by course of dealing, course of performance, or usage of trade.1 The clause stands beside two other routes around the drafting steps of subsection (2), the as-is expression and the buyer's examination of the goods or refusal to examine them,2 and subsection (2) itself opens with the words “Subject to subsection (3).”3
Circumstances can do the work of drafting because the drafting rules serve one purpose. Section 2-316 aims to protect a buyer from unexpected and unbargained language of disclaimer, and it permits the exclusion of implied warranties only by conspicuous language or by other circumstances that protect the buyer from surprise.4 The comment to subsection (3) states the test in terms of the buyer's attention: exclusion is allowed when the circumstances surrounding the transaction are in themselves sufficient to call the buyer's attention to the fact that no implied warranties are made or that a certain one is excluded.5 A buyer who has bought from the same seller on the same terms for years, or who buys in a market where goods of the kind are routinely sold without assurance of quality, needs no bold heading to know what is on offer.
Those circumstances come from two directions. Course of dealing and course of performance look to the conduct of these two parties: their earlier sales to each other, and how they have behaved under the contract now in dispute. Usage of trade looks outward, to a practice observed in the trade whether or not the parties ever dealt before. The clause speaks only of implied warranties. A seller's express promise stays protected by the rule that disclaimer language is denied effect when it is inconsistent with the language of express warranty.6
Prior Dealings Between the Parties
Parties who have sold to each other before carry that history into their next sale. A course of dealing is the pattern of earlier contracts between the same buyer and seller. A course of performance is the pattern of conduct under the contract in dispute, as when a buyer accepts delivery after delivery on the same terms. Either can show that both sides understood the goods to come without implied warranties.
The leading illustration is the repeat as-is sale. If a seller and buyer have made several contracts over the years with the understanding that the seller was selling “as is,” their next deal is “as is” too, unless the parties expressly negate the earlier course of dealing.7 Courts use evidence of this kind to reveal what a contract means, and here it reveals that a form silent about warranties still sells the goods as is.
The rule follows from what the formalities are for. A required word and conspicuous print exist to make the exclusion apparent to the buyer, who is otherwise exposed to unexpected and unbargained language.8 A buyer who has bought on the same terms before has already learned the lesson from the transactions themselves. Examination under (3)(b) runs on similar logic: a buyer who examined the goods as fully as he desired, or refused to, has no implied warranty for defects the examination ought to have revealed.9 In both settings the buyer's own experience does the work a printed disclaimer would otherwise do. The warranty of merchantability, for its part, rests on the merchant's advantage: a repeat player who knows more than the buyer about pricing, breakdown rates, likely damage, and the cost of repair.10 A buyer who has bought the same goods from the same seller many times has had a chance to learn some of what the seller knows.
The parties can speak to the subject themselves, and when they do, the earlier pattern gives way.
The stakes of an exclusion show why the history behind it matters. In Moulton, a steering defect in a 14-month-old car sent it off a bridge and severely injured its owner. The 12-month, 12,000-mile express warranty had expired, the contract of sale disclaimed the implied warranty of merchantability in accordance with §2-316(2), and a one-year statute of limitations barred the tort claims. The court ruled that the properly drawn disclaimer barred the warranty claim, so the law gave no redress to a consumer severely injured by a dangerous defect in a nearly new car.11 An exclusion by history takes away the same protection, and it is only as good as the understanding the earlier dealings actually established. In the repeat-sale example, the sales proceeded on the understanding that the seller was selling as is. Several purchases with no such understanding show repetition and nothing more.
Usage of Trade
A usage of trade comes from a community of sellers and buyers, not from these two parties. It is a practice so regularly observed in a place, vocation, or trade that people expect it to be followed in the sale at hand. If dealers and farmers in a region routinely leave the risk of defective used tires with the buyer, the tire dealer in the hypothetical above has a second argument for excluding the implied warranties, one that does not depend on his earlier sales to this farmer.
Two questions decide whether a practice removes a warranty: whether it is regular enough, and whether it reaches this buyer. Regularity matters because a practice that some sellers follow some of the time tells no one what a given sale will be like. Reach matters because the exclusion works only when the circumstances call the buyer's attention to it.13 A custom does that for people who work in the trade, who absorb its habits as the background of their deals. It does nothing for an outsider. Freedom to define the terms of a sale rests on two assumptions, that both parties have reasonable access to information about the product and that both can bargain effectively to protect their interests,14 and a buyer who has never heard of the custom has neither access nor any chance to bargain around it. Enforcing the custom against that buyer would produce the unexpected loss of protection that the disclaimer rules exist to prevent.15
Frantz v. Cantrell shows where the line falls. A roofer who installed asphalt shingles argued that roofing usage excluded the implied warranty of merchantability, and his expert testified that roofers do not warrant the shingles they use. The homeowner stood outside the roofing trade and knew nothing of the usage. The court concluded that the exclusion required both parties to be engaged in the trade, or the usage to be one of which both were or should have been aware.
The same practice removes the warranty against one buyer and leaves it standing against the other, and the buyer's connection to the trade draws the line. Agricultural sales supply the default against which such practices operate. Livestock, feed, seed, and pesticides are goods, so their sale creates warranties, and the UCC reads implied warranties into the agreement absent specific language or circumstances excluding them.16 A usage of trade is one of those circumstances, but only for a buyer it actually reaches.
Usage of trade also stops short of the warranty of title. Subsection (3)'s methods do not apply to that warranty, which can be modified or excluded only by specific language, or by circumstances giving the buyer reason to know that the seller does not claim title in himself or is selling only such right or title as he or a third person may have.17 A buyer who purchases goods from the trunk of a car parked in an alley has that reason to know. Sheriff sales and sales by executors may likewise be so far out of the ordinary commercial course that they warn the buyer in the same way.