Concept
Analyzing a Disclaimer Problem
Exclusion or modification of warranties
Analyzing a Disclaimer Problem
Section 2-316 contains three separate rules, each built for a different kind of warranty, so a disclaimer problem is solved by matching the rule to the warranty before testing anything else. Subsection (1) covers the seller's own promises: words that create an express warranty and words that limit it are read as consistent with each other wherever reasonable, and the limit is inoperative to the extent that reading is unreasonable, all subject to the parol evidence rule of §2-202.1 Subsection (2) sets out the formal route for implied warranties. To exclude merchantability, the language must mention merchantability and, if written, be conspicuous; to exclude fitness, the exclusion must be a conspicuous writing, and a statement such as “There are no warranties which extend beyond the description on the face hereof” is enough to exclude all implied warranties of fitness.2 Subsection (3) then adds three general methods that need none of those formalities: as-is or similar language, the buyer's examination of the goods or refusal to examine them, and course of dealing, course of performance, or usage of trade.3
The three rules follow the order in which the Code protects the buyer. An express warranty is something the seller affirmatively said, so a court first tries to harmonize it with any limiting words, and when the two cannot honestly coexist, the seller bears the contradiction.4 Implied warranties can be removed by the formal route or by a general method, and outside law then polices whatever disclaimer survives. That policing matters because disclaimers bite hardest where buyers know least: consumers of new products know little about a product's dangers, have little power to bargain for safety, and have few skills for valuing warranties, while sellers gain most when buyers neither see nor understand the disclaimer.5
Subsection (2) opens with the words “Subject to subsection (3),” which makes the formal route a safe harbor and not the only way to exclude an implied warranty.6 A seller who never mentions merchantability may still win on as-is language, on the buyer's examination, or on dealing and usage. Courts do not treat the general methods as automatic, however: “as is” or “with all faults” is at best a start, and some courts are wary of enforcing broad disclaimers.7 That is why the questions below check the formal route first, since a compliant clause ends the inquiry, and the general methods second, since a failed clause has not necessarily failed.
The questions form a sequence, not a rigid checklist. An express-warranty claim travels through question two and never touches questions three and four, while an implied-warranty claim skips question two and runs through three and four. The last three questions apply after a disclaimer appears to have worked: outside law may still defeat it, a remedy limit may stand between a proven breach and any recovery, and the description may survive in any event. Defeating the disclaimer also does not guarantee compensation, because the buyer must still prove that the goods did not conform to the warranty, that provable damages followed, and that no affirmative defense applies, such as a limitations period, lack of privity, absence of notice, or a contractual limit on remedies.8
Clean facts move through the sequence quickly. Suppose a buyer test-drives a used pickup and then signs an invoice that reads “SOLD AS IS” in bold capitals directly above the signature line. A week later the transmission fails, and the buyer sues on the implied warranty of merchantability. The warranty is implied, so question one sends the analysis past question two. The formal route fails at question three, because the invoice never mentions merchantability. Question four rescues the seller: unless the circumstances indicate otherwise, an expression like “as is” excludes all implied warranties because in common understanding it calls the buyer's attention to the exclusion and makes plain that there is no implied warranty.9 Nothing in the facts raises outside law, a remedy limit, or a conflicting description, so the analysis ends there.
Students lose points by stopping when the formal route fails. A clause that names merchantability in type a reasonable buyer would overlook fails subsection (2), but concluding that the warranty is intact at that point skips question four, which exists because subsection (2) is itself subject to subsection (3).10 A seller's drafter sees the same structure from the other side and learns the same caution: as-is language alone is at best a start, and no single device is safe.11
The express-warranty questions have short illustrations of their own. A contract that promises 36 miles per gallon and also disclaims all warranties is resolved at question two: the terms cannot be read together, the contradiction is construed against the seller, and the mileage promise survives.12 The same figure spoken by a salesperson before signing is resolved at the parol evidence step, where a writing that disclaims warranties can bar the buyer from proving that the statement was made at all.13 The two scenes differ only in where the promise lives, and that location decides which rule governs.
Question five can swallow the whole analysis when the disclaimer's very presence in the contract is in doubt. A disclaimer printed on a package raises the threshold question whether its terms governed the purchase. In the Step-Saver software litigation, that question was the central issue on appeal, after the trial judge held that the license printed on the package governed the sale and directed a verdict against the buyer's warranty claims.14
Question seven carries the most force against a seller who has done everything else right. Whatever a clause says about quality, the words describing what is being sold are words relevant to an express warranty, and a blanket disclaimer that cannot reasonably be read as consistent with them is inoperative to that extent.15
The result follows from what each rule removes. A disclaimer takes away assurances the law would otherwise supply, while the description is something the seller actually said. If a disclaimer could reach it, the buyer would have paid the price for a described thing and received nothing the seller was bound to deliver. That is why question seven comes last, and why it can rescue a buyer who has lost every implied-warranty question before it.