Concept
What Rejection Means
Rightful rejection
Rightful Rejection of Goods
What Rejection Means
A buyer who rejects refuses to keep the goods the seller has delivered or tendered, and the opposite act, acceptance, precludes rejection altogether.1 The choice arrives at inspection, and the law treats the two options unevenly. An inspecting buyer must either accept or reject, but only rejection takes affirmative action; failing to act at that moment constitutes acceptance.2
Two separate questions govern every rejection, and this chapter keeps returning to them. The first is substantive: was the buyer entitled to reject? The answer separates rightful rejections from wrongful ones. The second is procedural: did the buyer reject the way the Code requires? The answer separates effective rejections from ineffective ones. Keeping the questions apart is the main skill this unit teaches, because a rejection can be rightful yet ineffective, or wrongful yet effective.
The substantive right comes from § 2-601, which gives the buyer a right of rejection when the goods or the tender of delivery fail to conform to the contract. Section 2-508 sets against it the seller's right to cure an improper delivery.3 Reading §§ 2-601, 2-602, 2-508, and 2-612 together, a rejection is rightful only when three things are true. The buyer has not already accepted the goods, because acceptance precludes rejection. The goods or their tender do not conform to the contract. And the seller either has no cure right or has not exercised it effectively and rightfully.4
A buyer with all three elements still has to reject in a procedurally proper way. Section 2-602 requires rejection within a reasonable time after delivery or tender, and it makes the rejection ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller.5 The notice rule protects the seller. Prompt notice lets the seller cure, if it has a cure right. When the rejection rests on quality, notice lets it use the goods to build its own case against a third party, such as a carrier or a subcontractor. If the goods may perish or decline in value, notice lets it act to preserve some of that value, and it may also need to cart the goods away.6 Because the procedure is what defines an effective rejection, effectiveness turns on timely notice without regard to the buyer's reasons for rejecting.7
In National Fleet Supply, Inc. v. Fairchild, the trial court's findings put both questions in order. The engine the seller delivered did not conform to the sales contract. The buyer refused it because it was not the model he had ordered and would not work in his truck. He also promptly notified the seller of the rejection.8 Substance and procedure were both satisfied, so the rejection was rightful and effective.
Zabriskie Chevrolet, Inc. v. Smith adds a point about possession. The buyer discovered the nonconformity within seven-tenths of a mile and minutes after leaving the showroom, well within a reasonable opportunity to inspect. In a legal sense he never accepted the vehicle, even though he had driven it off the lot.9 The car was practically inoperable and had a defective transmission, a remarkable defect that justified rejection.10 The dealer, for its part, could not insist on acceptance, since the Code continues the policy of requiring exact performance by the seller as a condition of its right to require acceptance.11
The buyer in this hypothetical has failed the substantive test. A seller owes conforming goods, and the buyer must accept and pay for them in accordance with the contract.12 Refusing conforming goods because the price fell is a wrongful rejection, and the buyer breaches by making it. The buyer has passed the procedural test, however. Because an effective rejection is defined by timely notice, a wrongful rejection is as effective as a rightful one: the buyer breaches, but its rejection still operates as a rejection.13 A later section takes up that combination of wrongful yet effective.
Silence has consequences of its own. A buyer who inspects a defective shipment and then says nothing has accepted it, however defective the goods. A buyer who inspects the same shipment and promptly tells the seller it is rejecting has rejected it. The rule requires action for rejection but not for acceptance because most tenders turn out to be acceptable to buyers. Making every buyer signal acceptance would be wasteful, since a seller can safely assume that goods were satisfactory if it has heard nothing to the contrary.14 The burden of speaking therefore falls on the unusual buyer who is dissatisfied.
The later sections on a rejecting buyer's duties also deal with security interests, which work much as a mortgage does: the holder has a right to repossess the assets if the payments are not made.15