Concept
Cure Within the Contract Time
Seller's right to cure
Cure Within the Contract Time
When a buyer rejects a nonconforming tender while time remains under the contract, §2-508(1) lets the seller try again. The seller seasonably notifies the buyer of its intention to cure and then makes a conforming delivery within the contract time.1 The setting usually follows an early tender. A seller that delivers well ahead of the due date may find that the buyer, acting with reasonable promptness, rejects the goods before that date has passed.2
New York recognized this form of cure before the Code. Bartus v. Riccardi describes subdivision (1) as enacting into statutory law what had been New York case law: a seller could cure a nonconforming delivery before the contract time expired by notifying the buyer of its intention to cure and delivering within the contract period.3
Two illustrations show the pattern. A seller promises a white stove on or before June 1 and delivers a tan one on May 25, and the buyer rejects it. The seller may cure by notifying the buyer of its intention to cure and delivering a white stove by June 1.4 Likewise, Acme contracts to deliver 500 anvils to Road Runner, Inc. (RRI) by May 7 and tenders them on May 1. RRI inspects the shipment, finds it nonconforming, and rejects it, and Acme has the right to cure.5 If Acme tells RRI that it intends to cure, it must deliver conforming goods by May 7, the original performance date.6
The perfect tender rule is the reason a cure right is needed at all. A buyer may reject goods that fail to conform “in any respect,” however slight the defect, and that rule exposes sellers to strategic rejection. The Code reduces the risk by giving sellers a second bite of the performance apple.7 How strong that second bite is depends on the calendar. When the seller tenders early and the buyer rejects before the due date, the seller's right to cure is much greater than when delivery comes on or after the due date.8 The right also fits Article 2's general policy of preserving the deal whenever possible.9
The first step matters because the cure right begins with an effective rejection, and a rejection is ineffective unless the buyer seasonably notifies the seller.10 The second step is the only one that looks at the calendar, and none of the five asks what the seller believed when it shipped. Subsection (1) conditions the right on timing and notice. The requirement that the seller have had reasonable grounds to believe the tender would be acceptable appears only in subsection (2), which governs cure after the date has passed.11 Where the buyer rejects before the date, the seller has the unconditional right that subsection (1) describes: to notify the buyer seasonably of its intent to cure and to substitute a conforming delivery before the time expires.12 A seller that carelessly shipped the wrong model, with no reason to expect the buyer to take it, can therefore still cure inside the window.
The seller's first act after rejection is notice, and the statute asks that the notice be seasonable. The commentary quoted in the materials ties seasonableness to the calendar: “The closer, however, it is to the contract date, the greater is the necessity for extreme promptness on the seller's part in notifying of his intention to cure.”13 Notice also fixes the seller's deadline. A seller that tells the buyer it will cure must then deliver conforming goods by the original contract date, as Acme must by May 7.14
The two scenes differ in what the seller did after the rejection. Prompt notice followed by delivery inside the window preserves the contract, and notice followed by a late shipment does not.
Cure is the seller's option. The seller is not required to cure, but if the buyer rejects before the performance date and the seller does not cure, the seller is liable for damages for breach of contract.15 The buyer, for its part, cannot simply refuse a proper cure. If RRI does so, it is in breach, and Acme can sue for damages.16
Everything above depends on the date. If the buyer rejects after the contract time has expired, subsection (1) offers the seller nothing, however quickly it responds. Subsection (2) takes over and carries its own conditions: reasonable grounds to believe the tender would be acceptable, seasonable notice, and then a further reasonable time to substitute a conforming tender.17 One New York opinion divides §2-508 along exactly this line, between cure offered when “the time for performance has not yet expired” and cure that, by granting a further reasonable time, extends beyond the date set for performance.18 The next section takes up that second category.