Concept
Buyer's Refusal to Allow Cure
Seller's right to cure
Buyer's Refusal to Allow Cure
The perfect tender rule lets a buyer reject goods that miss the contract specifications in any respect, however slight, and that power invites strategic rejection.1 The seller's right to cure is the Code's answer: a second chance to perform. That answer works only if the buyer cannot defeat it by saying no. When a seller cures properly, the cure tender is the performance the contract promised, and a buyer that turns it away is rejecting conforming goods. Section 2-602(3) treats that refusal as a wrongful rejection and moves the dispute to the seller's side of the Code: the seller's rights with respect to goods wrongfully rejected are governed by the Article's provisions on seller's remedies in general, § 2-703.2 What follows for the buyer depends on whether it refuses the cure or allows it.
Refusing a proper cure costs the buyer in two ways. First, the buyer loses its own remedies: the wrongful refusal nullifies the seller's breach and deprives the buyer of all remedies against the seller for breach arising from the contract.3 The rule follows from what cure is. A seller that cures is making a second attempt at the same obligation, and a conforming second tender gives the buyer everything the contract promised. A buyer that declines it has refused the very performance whose absence would have supported its complaint, and it may not sue on the first defective tender as well.
Second, the buyer faces the seller's remedies. It may owe the price of the nonconforming goods under § 2-709, the contract-market differential as to conforming goods under § 2-708(1), or the difference between the resale price and the contract price under § 2-706, in the last case less the amount attributable to the nonconformity.4 The deduction in the resale measure reflects the same allocation of fault. The buyer answers for the loss its refusal caused, and the part of a shortfall that traces to the seller's original defect stays with the seller. The detail of each measure belongs to the law of seller's remedies. What matters here is that a wrongful refusal of cure opens that door.
In T.W. Oil, Inc. v. Consolidated Edison Co., the buyer's refusal was driven entirely by the market. Con Ed rejected a cargo of fuel oil that tested at .92 percent sulfur, refused a price reduction roughly responsive to the sulfur difference, and insisted on paying only the latest prevailing price, which in the volatile market of the oil embargo was some 25 percent below the price it had agreed to pay.5 On February 21 the seller offered a substitute shipment of conforming oil due to arrive a week later. On February 22 Con Ed summarily rejected that offer too, adamant in its intention to take advantage of the intervening drop in prices.6 The trial court found that the seller's offer to cure was reasonable and timely and had been improperly rejected, and it awarded the seller $1,385,512.83, essentially the difference between the $3,360,667.14 contract price and what the seller received on resale of the original cargo.7 The Court of Appeals held that a seller who acts in good faith and with a reasonable expectation that the original goods would be acceptable may offer to cure beyond the contract date if it gives seasonable notice.8 Con Ed argued that damages should have been measured by the resale of the substitute cargo instead. The court affirmed without reaching that argument because Con Ed never objected at trial to the seller's method of calculation, so the decision does not settle the proper measure.9
Bartus v. Riccardi reaches the same result on a smaller scale. The seller fitted the buyer with the A-665, a modified and improved version of the A-660 the buyer had ordered, and the buyer complained about the noise.10 The court held that the seller had reasonable grounds to believe its tender would be acceptable because it was the newer and improved version of the model the buyer had ordered. Because the buyer refused the seller's offer of a cure, the court awarded damages to the seller for the buyer's breach.11 The two buyers had different motives. Con Ed was chasing a falling market, and the hearing-aid buyer was unhappy with the noise and the change of model. The outcome was the same because motive never entered the analysis. The only question was whether the seller's offer satisfied § 2-508.
Those decisions protect the seller only when the offer was a proper cure, and a buyer remains free to refuse one that is not. A second tender that is itself nonconforming is no cure, and neither is a substitute that falls outside the bargain, as the earlier section on substitutes explains. A cure offered after the contract date fails as well when the seller lacked reasonable grounds to believe the original tender would be acceptable or gave no seasonable notice.12 Whether a refusal is a breach therefore depends on whether the seller's offer met the conditions developed in the earlier sections.
Subsection (1) asks only for seasonable notice and a conforming delivery within the contract time. Subsection (2) adds the requirement of reasonable grounds and replaces the contract time with a further reasonable time.14 A refusal exposes the buyer to liability only when the offer cleared every condition that applies, and the buyer's reason for refusing, whether market opportunism or simple preference, plays no part in that inquiry.
A buyer that allows a proper cure fares differently. It loses any right to reject, but it keeps the right to sue under § 2-714 if the original nonconforming tender injured it.15
Cure repairs the goods but not what the first failed tender already cost the buyer. The two rules therefore fit together. A buyer that refuses a proper cure forfeits every remedy for the original breach, while a buyer that allows one forfeits only the right to reject and keeps damages for what the defect actually caused.
Nothing here compels the seller to cure. Under the Code the decision to attempt cure rests with the seller, and the buyer has no power to demand it, whereas the CISG gives the buyer a right to require the seller to cure.16 The buyer's duty runs one way: it must not resist a proper cure once the seller chooses to offer one. That is why liability for refusal attaches only after the seller has acted.