Concept
Burden of Proving Breach
Acceptance and notice of breach
Burden of Proving Breach
Once a buyer accepts goods, § 2-607(4) puts on the buyer the burden of establishing any breach with respect to them.1 A burden of proof is the duty to produce enough evidence to persuade the factfinder of a disputed fact, and the party who carries it loses on that fact when the evidence falls short. In a dispute over disappointing goods, the disputed fact is nearly always whether the goods conformed to the contract, so the allocation often decides the case. The rule also carries its own condition, because it speaks only of goods accepted. Every burden analysis therefore starts with the question that opened this chapter: did the buyer accept?
Sessa shows the acceptance finding assigning the burden. The buyer, Sessa, argued that he had not accepted the horse and that telephone calls made after it was shipped amounted to an effective rejection. The court answered with § 2-607, under which acceptance of goods precludes rejection of the goods accepted. Since Sessa could not reject effectively, the burden of proving the breach of warranty rested on him as the buyer.2
The allocation fits the contract's basic division of duties and the way evidence decays. The seller must transfer and deliver the goods, and the buyer must accept and pay for them in accordance with the contract.3 A buyer who has accepted and now says the goods fell short of that standard is the party asking for relief. Time also works against that party's account: the longer a buyer holds goods, the harder it becomes to tell whether the seller or the buyer caused a defect. Scratches reported on new furniture a week after delivery leave exactly that doubt, while a table ordered at twelve feet that measures eleven leaves almost none, since tables do not shrink and buyers seldom saw off a foot.4 Proof comes easily to one buyer and with difficulty to the other, yet where goods have been accepted, § 2-607(4) leaves each to prove the defect.
Acceptance costs the buyer the right to reject, and it leaves the buyer's damages remedy intact. A buyer who receives nonconforming goods with a defect that is not easily detected does not lose the right to recover damages for the seller's breach of warranty by simply having accepted.5 The same source marks the limits of the opportunity to inspect. A buyer's silence, without more, does not impute acceptance until the buyer has had adequate time to inspect, but goods that the buyer has drastically changed and used cannot later be rejected as though unaccepted, even when a latent defect is present.6 The price of keeping the damages remedy is the burden of proving the breach.
A buyer who rejects effectively stands elsewhere. Section 2-607(4) allocates the burden for goods accepted, and Sessa's reasoning ran through the failed rejection: the burden fell on the buyer because he could not reject effectively.7 When the buyer has effectively rejected, nothing has been accepted, and a seller who sues is claiming that it performed by delivering goods in accordance with the contract.8 That seller must show that its tender conformed.
Revocation of acceptance does not rescue a buyer from this allocation. A footnote in Sessa observed that the buyer could invoke revocation under § 2-608 but that the incidence of the burden of proof would not be affected.9 Section 2-607(4) places on the revoking buyer the burden of proof as to all the requirements for revocation.10 Revocation asks the court to undo an acceptance the buyer has already made, so the buyer remains the party seeking relief and the party who must prove its grounds. A buyer who proves a serious defect but fails on any other requirement has proved only part of the case, and the unproved part is the buyer's loss.
Buyers sometimes fail to carry the burden, and Smart & Associates, LLC v. Independent Liquor (NZ) Ltd. shows how. The buyer, Smart Beverage, had contractually assumed the risk of loss under paragraph 4.3 of its distribution agreement, and it claimed that the goods were out of rotation. To prevail, it had to establish that the out-of-rotation problem arose before it assumed that risk. Its only proof was a set of communications from the warehouse operator, Western Carriers, advising that the warehouse followed a first-in-first-out policy. That evidence fell short of the buyer's burden, because the warehouse's assurance that it did not get the stock out of rotation does not let a buyer avoid the very risk it contractually assumed.11
The burden follows the buyer from the question whether a breach occurred to the question what it is worth. When a seller sues for the price, a general breach by the seller does not defeat the action. The buyer must instead prove any setoff damages under the pertinent sections of the Code, by proving rejection, revocation of acceptance, or breach of warranty.12
Proof of timely notice sits on the same side of the ledger. Texas law, for example, bars a buyer from any remedy unless the buyer notifies the seller of the breach within a reasonable time after discovering it, or after the time the buyer should have discovered it. The burden of alleging and proving proper notice is the buyer's, and failure to notify the seller, which denies the seller an opportunity to cure, bars recovery on a breach of warranty claim.13 An accepting buyer must therefore establish that the goods breached the contract, that notice of the breach reached the seller in time, and, when the buyer seeks damages or a setoff, that the claimed loss exists. The seller can prevail by defeating any one of the three.