Concept
Carrier Cases
Risk of loss
Carrier Cases
Article 2 frames the seller’s obligation as one to transfer and deliver the goods in accordance with the contract, and the buyer’s as one to accept and pay.1 When a third-party carrier moves the goods, the words “in accordance with the contract” decide how far the seller’s delivery obligation reaches, and that reach decides when risk of loss shifts to the buyer. Section 2-509(1) governs every contract that requires or authorizes the seller to ship by carrier. A seller who delivers in its own vehicle falls outside it and under the residual rule taken up later in this chapter.2
The Code does not ask who held title when the goods were lost. It ties the shift to words and actions of a tangible character, which the parties can prove, rather than to the location of an intangible that no one can prove.3 For carrier cases, § 2-509(1) offers two such events, and one question chooses between them: does the contract require the seller to deliver the goods at a particular destination? If not, the risk shifts when the seller duly delivers the goods to the carrier. If so, it shifts when the goods are duly tendered at that destination. A contract that authorizes shipment and says nothing about destination belongs in the first group.4
| Shipment contract | Destination contract | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical term | F.O.B. the seller’s place | F.O.B. the buyer’s place |
| Seller’s undertaking | Make an appropriate contract for shipment and get conforming goods into the carrier’s possession | Transport the goods to the named place at its own expense and risk, and tender delivery there |
| Risk shifts | On due delivery to the carrier | On due tender at the destination, even while the carrier still holds the goods |
| Text | § 2-509(1)(a) | § 2-509(1)(b) |
The table states defaults. The parties may allocate the risk of loss as they see fit, and § 2-509 applies only when their contract does not do so.5 Even the F.O.B. rules yield to agreement: under § 2-319(1) the parties can agree that the seller bears the risk to the place of destination.6
Shipment Contracts
Under § 2-509(1)(a), when the contract requires or authorizes the seller to ship the goods by carrier and does not require delivery at a particular destination, the risk of loss passes to the buyer when the goods are duly delivered to the carrier, even though the shipment is under reservation.7 A contract with those features is a shipment contract. The seller’s only obligations under it are to make an appropriate contract for shipment and to get conforming goods into the carrier’s possession.8 Once the seller has done both, it has finished what the contract asks, and the risk moves to the buyer. Shipping under reservation (§ 2-505) does not postpone the shift.
The shift decides who absorbs a loss. The party with the risk when the goods are destroyed bears the loss: a buyer in a shipment contract owes the price for goods destroyed after due delivery to the carrier, and a seller who still holds the risk must tender a replacement or be in breach.9 Delivery to a carrier is the kind of tangible, provable event the Code prefers to title as the dividing line.
What follows F.O.B. tells you which contract you have. A term that names the seller’s place makes the contract a shipment contract, with the seller bearing the expense and risk of putting the goods into the carrier’s possession.10
The handoff shifts the risk only if it is “due,” and that word imports the seller’s other obligations into the rule. Tender under § 2-503(1) generally requires conforming goods, goods put and held at the buyer’s disposition, and any notification reasonably necessary to enable the buyer to take delivery. Where the case is within § 2-504, § 2-503(2) adds that tender requires the seller to comply with that section.11 Section 2-504 requires, among other things, that the seller make a contract for transportation that is reasonable given the nature of the goods and the circumstances.12 Due delivery therefore means conforming goods, a reasonable contract of carriage, and notice to the buyer. A seller who hands nonconforming goods to the carrier does not shift the risk, because it cannot shift the risk unless its action conforms with all the conditions the contract places on it.13 The section on the effect of breach returns to that problem.
Egregious violations of the reasonable-carriage requirement do arise. In La Casse v. Blaustein the package was underinsured, misaddressed, shipped by fourth-class mail, and marked with a “theft-tempting” inscription. The court held that § 2-504(a) was not met and that the risk of loss did not pass.14
Not every flaw in the arrangements keeps the risk on the seller. In a shipment contract, a failure to make proper arrangements for transportation or to notify the buyer justifies rejection only if material delay or loss ensues.15 A defect that results from an improper shipment contract but causes no substantial delay gives no right of rejection, and so does not leave the risk with the seller.16 La Casse falls on the other side of that line because its faults put the shipment itself in jeopardy.
The fourth step depends on fixing the moment of the handoff, and Sessa v. Riegle shows why the date matters. The buyer of a horse claimed that defects breached the seller’s warranty. The Riegles delivered the horse to the carrier on March 23, 1973 for shipment to Freehold, New Jersey. Defects that existed on that date would breach the warranty, and defects that arose afterward would not.18
Applying that line, the court held that the buyer had not carried his burden on the tendinitis. The Riegles testified that the horse received proper care between March 10 and March 23 and went onto the van in sound condition. The expert conceded that an injury on the van could have caused the tendinitis.19 Whatever happened on the van came after the handoff, so it fell on the buyer’s side of the line.
Two contract features resemble destination terms but do not make a destination contract: a direction to ship to the buyer’s address and a term that the seller pays the freight. The last subsection of this unit explains why.
Destination Contracts
Section 2-509(1)(b) governs the carrier case in which the seller has promised more than a handoff. When the contract requires the seller to deliver the goods at a particular destination, and the goods are there duly tendered while in the carrier’s possession, the risk of loss passes to the buyer when the goods are so tendered as to enable the buyer to take delivery.21 The provision starts from the same premise as the shipment rule and changes one variable, the point in the journey at which the risk moves. Under subsection (1)(a) it moves at the seller’s end of the trip. Under subsection (1)(b) it moves at the buyer’s end.
The trade term shows how far the seller’s commitment reaches. Under an F.O.B. term that names the place of destination, the seller must “at his own expense and risk transport the goods to that place and there tender delivery of them.”22 Expense and risk travel together. A seller who has agreed to carry both has not finished until the goods have arrived and been tendered, so the risk stays with the seller for the whole trip.
Due tender at the destination is the seller’s ordinary tender duty applied at the buyer’s end. The seller must put and hold conforming goods at the buyer’s disposition and give the buyer any notification reasonably necessary to enable the buyer to take delivery.23 Because subsection (1)(b) speaks of goods tendered while still in the carrier’s possession, the risk passes at tender, not at physical receipt, and the carrier may still hold the goods when it does. That timing distinguishes a destination contract from the merchant branch of the residual rule, where receipt controls.
Goods that have physically reached the destination have not necessarily been tendered there.
In both versions the desks burned at the destination while the carrier held them, so their location cannot be what decided the case. The decisive fact was whether the seller had made a due tender, with notice and with the goods held at the buyer’s disposition. When a problem puts a fire at the buyer’s dock, ask whether tender was complete when it struck.
Back to the anvils. If the contract between Acme and Road Runner reads F.O.B. Grand Rapids, the buyer’s place follows the abbreviation, and risk does not pass to Road Runner until the anvils are tendered there.24 Suppose the anvils are destroyed in transit. Their destruction does not put Acme in breach. But Acme still has the risk of loss, so it must deliver 100 anvils to Road Runner, and if it refuses on the ground that the goods were destroyed, it is in breach.25 To say that the seller bore the risk when the goods were destroyed is to say that the seller is liable for nondelivery unless it tenders a performance in replacement.26 The only change from the F.O.B. Gary version is one word after the abbreviation, and the same fire now falls on Acme.
Destination contracts are the variant. A contract that merely authorizes carrier shipment and says nothing of destination falls under subsection (1)(a), and a legal dictionary adds that a contract that does not address the terms of delivery is presumed to be a shipment contract.27 A buyer who wants the destination rule needs contract language that requires delivery at the destination.
Telling the Two Apart
Section 2-509(1) sorts carrier cases into two groups, and the F.O.B. symbols of § 2-319 usually decide which group a contract belongs to. Under an F.O.B. term that names the seller’s place of business, the seller’s only obligations are to make an appropriate contract for shipment and to get conforming goods into the carrier’s possession, so the contract is a shipment contract and the risk passes on due delivery to the carrier. Under an F.O.B. term that names the place of destination, the seller must transport the goods there at its own expense and risk and tender delivery, so the contract is a destination contract and the risk passes only on due tender there.29 The Code adopted trade symbols already in business use, so most contracts that contemplate carriage announce their own classification. Only infrequently do the parties skip the symbols and leave lawyers and courts without a clear legal principle under §§ 2-509 and 2-319 or 2-320.30
The test is therefore mechanical. Look at what follows F.O.B. or F.A.S. If the seller’s location follows it, whether the seller’s business, plant, or city, the contract is a shipment contract. If the buyer’s location follows it, the contract is a destination contract.31 The location works as the test because it marks where the seller’s performance ends. The dictionary entries line up the same way. “FOB shipping” leaves the seller with the risk of placing the goods on a carrier, and “FOB destination” requires the seller to pay freight as far as the buyer’s named destination.32
The fourth step reflects the Code’s default. A contract that does not address the terms of delivery is presumed to be a shipment contract.35 The default tracks the size of the commitment, since a destination obligation stretches the seller’s expense and risk across the whole trip. A seller should not be held to that wider duty on ambiguous language.
The most common attempt to rebut the default relies on a direction to ship to the buyer’s address. Take a contract with an F.O.B. term naming the seller’s place that also directs shipment to a street address in the buyer’s city. A buyer may argue that the ship-to language makes the contract a destination contract. The argument fails because every shipment contract has to tell the seller where to send the goods, and a seller cannot make a contract of carriage without knowing where the goods are to go.36
The Third Circuit’s decision in Swift Canadian Co. v. Banet illustrates the point. The seller sued the buyer for breach, the district court granted the buyer’s motion for summary judgment on stipulated facts, and the Third Circuit reversed with instructions to enter judgment for the seller.37 The contract called for pelts F.O.B. Toronto and also for shipment by rail to Philadelphia. The court treated the Philadelphia provision as a shipping direction and read the F.O.B. term as ending the seller’s responsibility at Toronto, so the risk of loss lay with the buyer from then on.38
A stem that sends the goods to the buyer’s plant invites the label destination contract, but delivery to the buyer’s business alone does not make one, because the goods have to go somewhere. The question to ask is whose location, the seller’s or the buyer’s, follows F.O.B. or F.A.S.39
A term making the seller pay the freight is the second common source of error. Before the Code, a term requiring the seller to pay the cost of transportation was treated as equivalent to an agreement to deliver at the buyer’s destination, and the drafters of the Code omitted that rule on purpose.40 Freight payment fits an F.O.B. destination term, but it fits just as well a shipment contract in which the seller has agreed only to bear the cost of carriage. The dictionary’s “FOB destination” entry mentions freight, but it also names the buyer’s destination, and the destination commitment, not the payment alone, makes the term a destination term. A contract with no F.O.B. term that requires the seller to pay freight is therefore still a shipment contract.41 The result is the same when the seller absorbs only part of the expense. A Gary seller competing with a Pittsburgh seller for eastern buyers may price its goods as if freight ran from Pittsburgh. That pricing does not obligate it to deliver at a particular destination, so the risk passes when the goods are duly delivered to the carrier.42
When the parties abandon the standard symbols, the mechanical test loses force and classification turns on what the contract actually requires. Parties who want a destination contract should say so with F.O.B. the buyer’s place or equivalent language, and parties who want some other allocation may agree to one under § 2-319(1).43 Other terms fix delivery at the seller’s end. Under the trade term ex works, the seller’s delivery is complete, and the risk passes to the buyer, when the goods are made available at the seller’s own location, such as its factory or warehouse, without loading onto a collecting vehicle.44