Concept
Effect of Breach
Risk of loss
Effect of Breach
Section 2-509 allocates the risk of loss on the assumption that the seller has not breached; its first comment says it applies “[w]here there has been no breach by the seller.”1 Section 2-510, headed “Effect of Breach on Risk of Loss,” covers the cases where someone has. Its first two subsections deal with breach by the seller and its third with breach by the buyer.2
Each § 2-509 default moves the risk at an event, such as delivery of the goods to a carrier, and the event means something only when the party who brought it about has performed. A seller who ships goods the buyer may reject could otherwise point to the handoff and collect the price when the goods are lost. A buyer who has refused to perform could point to the seller's continued possession and disclaim any loss. Each would profit from a timing rule it failed to honor. The Code frames the duties plainly: the seller must transfer and deliver, and the buyer must accept and pay, each in accordance with the contract.3 Section 2-510 ties the risk to whichever party departed from that framing.
The stakes are concrete, because a buyer who has the risk when the goods are destroyed is liable for the price under § 2-709.4 The breach rules also follow the Code's general method. Under the Uniform Sales Act, title to goods unascertained at contracting presumptively passed when they were ascertained and delivered to a carrier, or at destination if the seller had to pay the cost of transportation.5 Article 2 dropped that approach. Legal consequences now flow from the contract and the action taken under it, so that practical questions such as who bears the risk of loss turn on words and actions of a tangible character instead of on the location of an intangible something no one can prove.6 Each breach rule asks what a party did, whether it tendered goods the buyer could reject, revoked acceptance, or repudiated, and none asks who owned the goods.
Three rules result. Subsection (1) keeps the risk on a seller whose tender gave the buyer a right to reject. Subsection (2) lets a buyer who rightfully revokes acceptance treat the risk as the seller's, and subsection (3) lets a seller treat the risk as the buyer's after the buyer's breach. Subsections (2) and (3) both stop at the deficiency in the innocent party's insurance. All three presuppose a breach. A loss with no breach behind it falls under § 2-509, subject to a narrow exception in § 2-613 for goods damaged without either party's fault before the risk passes. That exception applies only where the contract requires goods identified when the contract is made, and it does not reach the typical sale of garden-variety goods.7
Nonconforming Tender
Section 2-510(1) provides that where a tender or delivery of goods so fails to conform to the contract as to give a right of rejection, the risk of their loss remains on the seller until cure or acceptance.8 A carrier handoff, a tender at destination, or a receipt therefore cannot move the risk unless the goods conform when tendered. The first comment says so directly: a seller “cannot shift the risk of loss to the buyer unless his action conforms with all the conditions resting on him under the contract.”9 Section 2-509(1) does not pass the risk when the goods are nonconforming, and § 2-510(1) makes that result explicit.10
Without this rule, a seller could turn its own breach into the buyer's liability: ship goods the buyer may reject, point to the carrier handoff as the moment the risk moved, and collect the price if the goods are lost. A buyer with a right of rejection has not been offered what it agreed to take. The statute therefore names two events that can carry the risk to it. The buyer can accept the nonconforming goods, and a number of cases examine what conduct counts as acceptance for this purpose. Or the seller can cure, so that what was tendered conforms.11 Until one of those events occurs, the seller who created the problem carries the loss.
Conformity is judged at tender, which in a shipment contract means when the goods are loaded onto the carrier.13 Testing it later would swallow the shipment rule. If the goods had to conform on arrival, any damage in transit would make the tender nonconforming, and every shipment contract involving damaged goods would become a destination contract. Damage after a conforming handoff therefore stays with the buyer, while a defect present at loading, like the missing stakes, belongs to the seller. A stem that describes goods arriving crushed or spoiled calls for one question first: did the goods conform when they went to the carrier?
Cure has a narrow meaning here. The cure that subsection (1) contemplates is a change to the goods already tendered, such as repairing a defect. Repossessing the goods and tendering new ones has no effect on the risk of the original goods.14 A replacement shipment says nothing about the first goods, which the buyer rightly rejected, so their risk stays with the seller even while they travel back. Had Gardenworks instead sent a crew to fit stakes into the boxes at Hearth & Home's dock, the change would have been to the goods already tendered, and the nonconformity would no longer have held the risk on Gardenworks.15
Only defects that justify rejection keep the risk on the seller, because the trigger in subsection (1) is a right to reject. In a single-delivery contract that rarely screens anything out, since § 2-601 lets the buyer reject for a failure to conform in any respect. Two situations do screen defects out. In an installment contract, only a nonconformity that substantially impairs the value of the installment and cannot be cured, or a defect in the required documents, justifies rejection under § 2-612(2). And a defect that results from the seller's improper shipment contract but causes no substantial delay gives no right of rejection under § 2-504. Where no right to reject exists, the risk does not stay on the seller, and the usual § 2-509 allocation applies.16
Both shipments were destroyed in transit, and the difference between them was whether the defect gave a right to reject. A stem that mentions a defect in an installment contract does not by itself keep the risk on the seller.
Revocation of Acceptance
A buyer that accepts a nonconforming tender ordinarily takes the risk along with the goods, because acceptance is one of the two events that ends the seller's hold on the risk under subsection (1).18 Subsection (2) gives a way back to the buyer who accepted because the defect was hidden. Where the buyer rightfully revokes acceptance, it may, to the extent of any deficiency in its effective insurance coverage, treat the risk of loss as having rested on the seller from the beginning.19
The trigger differs from subsection (1)'s in a way that is easy to miss. Subsection (1) asks whether the buyer had a right of rejection. Subsection (2) applies only when the buyer has actually revoked acceptance and the revocation was rightful under § 2-608. Grounds to revoke, without a revocation, change nothing about who bears the risk.
The seller does not take the whole loss. The statute reaches only the deficiency in the buyer's effective insurance coverage, the part of the loss that the buyer's own insurance leaves uncovered. A buyer that has accepted holds and controls the goods and is the party likely to have insured them, so its coverage responds first. That ordering follows the Code's general policy, which sends risk to the party who breached and to the party with effective insurance.20 The effect is proportional. If the buyer's insurance covers two-thirds of the loss, the remaining third rests on the seller. A fully insured buyer looks to its insurer, and the seller owes nothing under the subsection.
Two limits keep the rule within its purpose. The first is that the revocation must be rightful. Section 2-608 permits revocation only for a nonconformity that substantially impairs the goods' value to the buyer, and only if the buyer accepted for a reason the statute recognizes, such as a defect too hidden to find before accepting. A buyer whose defect is minor, or whose revocation fails § 2-608's other requirements, has not rightfully revoked and gets no help from § 2-510(2). The mechanics of revocation belong to another subject; for risk of loss, it is enough that the revocation was made and was rightful.
The second limit is timing. Revocation must come before any substantial change in the condition of the goods that their own defects did not cause, so a buyer cannot revoke after an unrelated fire has destroyed them. The requirement answers a temptation built into the rule. A buyer allowed to revoke after the loss could keep defective goods, say nothing, and revoke only if the goods happened to be destroyed. Forcing the decision while the goods still exist makes the buyer choose before it knows how events will turn out.
A buyer that has the risk of loss when the goods are destroyed is liable for the price under § 2-709, which is where the print shop's late notice leaves it.22 A stem that pairs a latent defect with a fire invites the conclusion that the seller bears the loss. Two checks correct it. The first is sequence: was acceptance revoked before the goods were destroyed? The second is scope: even a timely, rightful revocation puts on the seller only the deficiency in the buyer's insurance, so the answer names the uninsured portion, such as a deductible, and not the whole loss.
Buyer's Repudiation
Section 2-510(3) runs the breach in the other direction. Where the buyer, as to conforming goods already identified to the contract, repudiates or is otherwise in breach before the risk of their loss has passed to it, the seller may, to the extent of any deficiency in its effective insurance coverage, treat the risk of loss as resting on the buyer for a commercially reasonable time.24 The first two subsections concern a seller whose goods were defective. This one concerns a buyer that has refused its duty to accept and pay in accordance with the contract.25 It answers the question of who bears the loss if the goods burn while the seller still holds them for a buyer that no longer wants them.
The need arises from the timing of the § 2-509 defaults. Until the event that moves the risk, such as delivery of conforming goods to the carrier, the goods sit with the seller and the loss is the seller's. A buyer that has already refused to perform could invoke that timing and call a fire at the seller's plant the seller's affair. The Code does not shift the whole loss to the buyer; it looks to who controls the goods. The seller holds them and is likely to insure them, so its insurance pays first, and the breaching buyer answers only for the part the insurance leaves uncovered. That division follows the general policy that risk falls, with qualifications, on the party who breached and on the party with effective insurance coverage.26
Taken together, the steps allow the risk to jump to a repudiating buyer only if the goods conform, were already identified, and were lost within a commercially reasonable time, and only to the extent of a gap in the seller's insurance.27 The first and third steps are questions of fact on which a problem may turn. A seller whose goods fail the contract has no claim to the shift, because a buyer entitled to reject them has not breached at all.
The second step supplies the particular goods that the shifted loss can attach to. Goods must be both existing and identified before any interest in them can pass, and the repudiation rule shifts only the loss of goods the contract has singled out.28 Until the seller designates particular goods, its duty can be met with any conforming goods, so a fire in general stock is simply a loss of the seller's own inventory, whatever the buyer has said or done.
The third step marks where the rule does its work. If the risk has already passed to the buyer under § 2-509, the buyer already bears the loss and owes the price, so nothing needs to be shifted.29 Subsection (3) matters only in the window before that moment. In a shipment contract, for example, a buyer that breaches before the seller loads the goods on the carrier has not yet taken the risk, while the seller, the aggrieved party, still holds the goods.
The fourth step keeps the buyer from becoming an indefinite backstop for the seller's coverage. Suppose the buyer repudiates on May 26 and a fire destroys the identified goods at the seller's plant three days later. The loss falls well within a commercially reasonable time, and the buyer answers for any deficiency in the seller's insurance. If the seller instead keeps the goods unsold and they burn in August, the buyer is no longer on the hook, because the statute limits the shift to a commercially reasonable time and the seller cannot keep this risk on the buyer indefinitely.30 The statute fixes no number of days. The natural measure is how long a seller reasonably needs to deal with goods the buyer has refused, and after that period the goods sit with a seller who chose to keep them and who can insure them.
The fifth step limits the shift to the insurance gap, and the arithmetic is proportional. Take a seller that identifies goods and sets them apart in its warehouse, ready to ship under a contract that passes the risk on delivery to the carrier. The buyer wrongfully tells the seller not to ship, and a fire then damages the goods. If the seller's effective insurance covers only two-thirds of the loss, one-third rests on the buyer despite the contract term, provided the loss came within a commercially reasonable time.31 On a $90,000 loss, the insurer pays $60,000 and the buyer bears $30,000. A fully insured seller has no deficiency, so the buyer bears nothing under the subsection.
A stem that has a buyer repudiate and a fire follow invites the answer that the buyer bears the loss. The Code's answer comes from running the steps. If the goods were never identified, nothing shifts. If the risk had already passed, § 2-509 governs and subsection (3) is unnecessary. If the fire came long after the breach, the shift has expired. If the seller's insurance covered the loss, the buyer bears nothing, and in the remaining case the buyer bears only the uninsured fraction.