Concept
Casualty to Identified Goods
Impossibility
Casualty to Identified Goods
A seller whose goods burn, flood, or spoil before delivery will argue that the contract is over. Section 2-613 of the Uniform Commercial Code accepts that argument in a narrow case: the contract requires goods identified when it is made, the goods suffer casualty without fault of either party, and the casualty comes before the risk of loss passes to the buyer.1 The section is the sale-of-goods counterpart to the common-law excuse for the destruction of a thing essential to performance. In Taylor v. Caldwell, a hall burned down shortly before the first performance, and the court absolved Caldwell of liability because the hall was essential to the contract and the parties had contracted on the basis of its continued existence.2
What follows the casualty depends on how much of the goods was lost. A total loss avoids the contract.3 A partial loss, or deterioration that leaves the goods nonconforming, lets the buyer demand inspection and then either treat the contract as avoided or accept the goods with an allowance from the price.4 The subsections below take the three conditions first, then total loss, then partial loss, and finally the line between excuse and risk of loss, which decides whether the section is reached at all.
Identified Goods and No Fault
Each of the three conditions in § 2-613 screens out a different kind of claim, and a claim that fails any one of them falls outside the section.5 A party who cannot bring itself within § 2-613 or § 2-615 must still perform, and the other side may sue for breach if it does not.6
Identification screens out the most claims, because it asks whether the contract itself made particular goods the foundation of the deal. The section applies only where the continuing existence of identified goods is a presupposition of the agreement, a point the Washington court made in Colley v. Bi-State.7 Unique goods meet that test easily. A buyer who contracts for a particular Matisse painting that burns in the seller's warehouse, with no one at fault and the risk of loss still on the seller, holds a contract that no other painting could perform, and the contract is avoided.8 Uniqueness is not required, however. The section asks whether the contract called for those goods, and the answer can be yes for goods that are not one of a kind.9
Fungible goods, meaning interchangeable units such as bushels of grain or pairs of boots, are harder to bring within the section, because identifying them in the contract by kind and amount is not enough. A New York court said so in Valley Forge Flag Co. v. New York Dowel & Moulding Import Co.10 The reason is the open market. A seller who promised ordinary goods can usually replace a lost lot, and the section should not let every such seller treat the accidental loss of its own stock as a way out of the contract.11 Excuse also carries a general cost, because judicial intervention may reduce the incentive of those best able to avoid a risk to take advantage of their position.12 In Bende & Sons, Inc. v. Crown Recreation, Inc., a seller of combat boots was not excused when a train wreck destroyed the boots, because nothing showed that the contract required those particular boots. The boots in the wreck were the seller's chosen means of performing, and the promise could be kept with any conforming boots.
Crops show how a promise can fall inside the section by designating its source. A farmer who contracts to sell crops growing on a certain piece of land, and whose crop fails from bad weather, is excused if the risk of loss does not pass to the buyer until the crop is delivered to a carrier.13 The designated land is what makes the goods identified when the contract is made.
The second condition requires that the casualty occur without fault of either party.14 If the seller's own carelessness started the fire, the loss is no longer an outside event, and the same is true if the buyer's conduct contributed to it. In either case the section does not apply, and the ordinary rules of breach and risk of loss decide who pays.
The third condition ties the section to the period in which the seller still carries the risk. If the risk of loss has passed to the buyer before the casualty, § 2-613 has no application, and the buyer bears the loss under § 2-509.15 The farmer's excuse above turned on exactly this fact: the risk stayed with the farmer until the crop reached a carrier. The last subsection returns to the line between excuse and risk of loss.
The opening text of § 2-613 also reaches, in a proper case, a contract containing a “no arrival, no sale” term, which § 2-324 addresses.16 The commentary sends readers to § 2-613 and its Comment 3 for such a contract.17 A fact pattern built around a shipment with that term therefore signals that this section is in play.
The common-law doctrine looks for a supervening event, but § 2-613 applies regardless of when the goods were damaged or destroyed, so long as its other requirements are met. Goods already destroyed when the parties contracted fall within it if neither party knew of the destruction.18
Two errors recur here. The first treats the destruction of whatever goods the seller meant to deliver as casualty to identified goods, which the combat boots show to be wrong, since the contract never required those boots. The second overlooks the risk-of-loss condition and treats the section as freeing a buyer from paying for goods lost after the risk had already passed to the buyer.
Total Loss Avoids the Contract
When the conditions are met and the goods are wholly lost, the Code states the consequence in a single clause: “if the loss is total the contract is avoided.”20 Avoidance excuses the failure to perform, so there is no breach and the seller owes no damages for goods that never arrived.21 The release runs both ways. The buyer owes nothing for goods it will never receive, because the discharged contract leaves it with no liability.22
A total loss leaves the buyer nothing to choose among, and that is why the Code ends the contract outright where a partial loss gives the buyer an option. The parties bargained over particular goods, and none of them survives. The section reaches only casualty without fault of either party, so avoidance spares the seller a damages claim for a loss it did not cause and spares the buyer a price for goods that no longer exist.23
The standard illustration is the farmer who contracts to sell crops growing on a certain piece of land. Bad climatic conditions cause the crop to fail, and the contract keeps the risk of loss on the farmer until the crop is delivered to a carrier for shipment, so the farmer's performance is excused.24 Each fact carries part of the result. The designated land makes the crop identified when the contract was made. The weather is outside either party's control, so the loss is without fault. The risk of loss has not left the farmer, so the casualty falls inside the period the section covers. And the crop failed entirely, so the loss is total.
The same failed crop comes out differently if the risk of loss had already passed to the buyer before the weather struck. Section 2-613 then has no application, and the buyer bears the loss under the risk-of-loss rules.25 A seller who cannot bring itself within the section also keeps its original duty. A seller whose goods are destroyed while it holds the risk must still tender conforming goods, and the buyer may sue for breach if the seller fails to do so.26 Fault produces the same denial of excuse, as the next scene shows.
Students often treat every total loss as an excuse. A total loss avoids the contract only when the three conditions hold, and the loss of a seller's ordinary stock of fungible goods, which could be replaced on the open market, does not meet them.27 The first questions are whether the contract required those particular goods and whether either party's fault contributed to their loss. If the answers are yes and no, a total loss ends the contract and neither side is in breach.
Partial Loss and Deterioration
Section 2-613(b) governs the case in which something survives the casualty. When the loss is partial, or the goods have so deteriorated as no longer to conform to the contract, the buyer may demand inspection and then, at the buyer's option, either treat the contract as avoided or accept the goods with due allowance from the contract price for the deterioration or the deficiency in quantity, but without further right against the seller.29 The subsection operates only after the opening conditions are met: goods identified when the contract is made, casualty without fault of either party, and casualty before the risk of loss passes to the buyer.30 Subsection (a) already answers the total-loss case.31 Subsection (b) handles goods that are only partly gone or only damaged, which may still have value to a buyer, so the Code gives the buyer a decision to make and does not end the contract automatically.
Two shortfalls trigger that decision. A partial loss means part of the identified goods has been destroyed, so the seller can no longer tender the full quantity the contract called for. Deterioration means the goods still exist but damage has left them nonconforming, as when water ruins the finish on every piece in a lot. Each leaves a gap between the goods promised and the goods that remain, and the same pair of options answers either gap. The right to demand inspection comes first, because the buyer can judge whether the surviving goods are worth taking, and how large a price reduction would be fair, only by examining them.
The first option, treating the contract as avoided, has the same result as a total loss. The buyer owes no price and neither side has a further claim against the other.32 The second option keeps the contract alive on adjusted terms. The buyer takes what survives and pays the contract price reduced by a due allowance for the deterioration or the missing quantity, so the price paid tracks what actually arrives.33
The Code places the election with the buyer, and the structure of the section explains why. The seller is blameless, because the section applies only when neither party was at fault, so neither election exposes the seller to damages. The buyer is the one who would otherwise receive something other than what the contract described. Leaving the decision with the seller would let one party decide whether the other must accept goods different from those promised, while the buyer's option lets a buyer who still wants the goods take them at a fair price and lets a buyer who does not want them walk away. Two buyers facing the same casualty can therefore choose opposite ways, and each choice is a valid use of the option.
A hotel that needed only a handful of chairs for a small lounge could instead have taken the seven at a price reduced for the missing five. In either case the decision is the buyer's, and the seller can neither compel acceptance of the remainder nor insist on cancellation.
The closing phrase of the subsection, “without further right against the seller,” defines what acceptance buys.34 The allowance is the buyer's whole recovery. It already reflects the difference between the goods promised and the goods received, and a blameless seller answers for nothing beyond it. A buyer who avoids the contract instead receives release from the price and nothing more, because the seller is excused and not in breach, so there is no breach to remedy.35
The sequence to run on a fact pattern follows from these rules. Confirm the opening conditions, ask whether the loss is total or only partial or a deterioration, and then give the election to the buyer. The seller has no vote, and a buyer who accepts with an allowance cannot add a damages claim. If the risk of loss had already passed to the buyer when the casualty struck, § 2-613 does not apply at all, a boundary the next subsection takes up.
Excuse Versus Risk of Loss
The last of the three conditions in § 2-613, that the casualty occur before the risk of loss passes to the buyer, ties the section to a second body of law.37 Risk of loss allocates the burden when goods are damaged, lost, or destroyed, and §§ 2-509 and 2-510 decide the moment at which that burden moves from seller to buyer.38 A problem about ruined goods therefore needs both bodies of law, and the excuse analysis cannot begin until the risk question has been answered.
The two answer different questions, which is why a warehouse fire in a fact pattern can look like an excuse problem when the real issue is who held the risk. Excuse asks whether a failure to perform is a breach. A party who establishes excuse under § 2-613 or § 2-615 is not in breach, because the contract is avoided.39 Risk of loss asks who bears the loss when the goods are gone, and a party with the risk of loss must perform or be in breach.40 Risk of loss therefore supplies the default result, and excuse is the exception a party must earn by meeting the conditions of an excuse provision.
Consider a specific classic automobile destroyed in a fire that neither party caused. Whether the buyer owes the price depends on where the risk of loss stood when the fire occurred. If the risk remained on the seller, the seller can be excused under § 2-613, the contract is discharged, and the buyer is not liable. If the risk had already passed to the buyer, the contract is not discharged and the buyer owes the contract price under § 2-709.41 The car and the fire are identical in both versions, and only the position of the risk moved.
A contract for a specific cow splits the same way. The cow's death without the seller's fault excuses the seller's duty to deliver, and whether the buyer must still pay depends on whether the risk of loss had passed to the buyer before the cow died. If it had not, the buyer need not pay and the contract is discharged. If it had, the buyer's promise to pay may survive even though the seller's promise to deliver has been discharged.42 The excuse section is unavailable once the risk has passed, and the buyer bears the loss under § 2-509.43 A buyer in that position cannot escape the price by pointing out that the goods were identified and that no one was at fault, because the third condition of § 2-613 is missing.
The opposite error appears when the seller holds the risk and the goods are not identified. Suppose a buyer and a seller contract for widgets, and the widgets are destroyed while the seller has the risk of loss. If the seller cannot satisfy § 2-613 or § 2-615, the seller must still tender conforming widgets, and if it fails to do so the buyer may sue for breach.44 The destroyed lot was only the seller's chosen means of performing, because the promise was for widgets of a description that other widgets can satisfy. Section 2-613 requires more than a description by kind and amount for exactly this reason: it keeps a seller from escaping a contract for ordinary goods that could be replaced on the open market.45 Holding the risk of such goods is a burden on the seller, who must replace them, and it does not release the seller from the promise.
Students tend to skip the first step, because a fact pattern about destroyed goods suggests that the contract is over. That reaction fails when the risk has passed, since the buyer then pays for goods it no longer has. The reverse reaction fails too. A seller who holds the risk of ordinary goods must replace them, while a seller who holds the risk of one specific, identified item is discharged when it is lost. The date of the casualty relative to the passing of risk, together with the question whether the goods were identified, sorts the three outcomes.