Concept
What an Accord Is
Accord and satisfaction
Accord and Satisfaction
What an Accord Is
A contractual duty does not have to end by performance exactly as promised; the parties can agree that something different will do. The first half of that arrangement is the accord. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 281(1) defines it as a contract under which an obligee promises to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty.1 The obligee is the party to whom the duty is owed and the obligor is the party who owes it, so in a debt settlement they are the creditor and the debtor. The definition describes a promise about a performance still to come, and when the accord is made nothing has yet been handed over. At bottom the accord is just an agreement, the sort of thing the word covenant covers, which in general terms means simply an agreement and may also stand for a promise.2
Three words must be kept apart. Treatises describe the arrangement as the settlement of an existing claim: the agreement of settlement is the accord, and its execution by rendering the settled performance is the satisfaction.3 Discharge, the ending of the original duty, is the legal consequence, because performance of the accord discharges the original duty.4 How and when the original duty is affected is the work of the rest of § 281, which later sections of this chapter take up.5
Not every payment on a debt involves an accord. Satisfaction is a substitute performance, while ordinary performance is the identical thing the contract promised. The obligee's promise to accept the substitute is just as essential, because without it the obligor has made only a proposal.
The two near misses sit on opposite sides of the definition. The cash payment has no substitute, and the car conversation has no promise by the obligee to accept one. Only when both pieces are present, a stated performance and the obligee's promise to take it in satisfaction of the existing duty, does the arrangement qualify as an accord under § 281(1).6
Because the accord is only the agreement, it is often called an executory accord, executory meaning not yet performed. The label underscores that the accord itself does not discharge the duty.7 It also echoes an older view, now generally rejected, that an unperformed accord was no defense to an action on the underlying duty.8 Treat executory accord as a synonym for an accord that has been made but not yet performed, and leave to the next sections what that unperformed state does to the original duty.