Concept
Effect of the Accord
Accord and satisfaction
Effect of the Accord
An accord affects the original duty in two stages, and Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 281 names both.1 From the day the parties make the accord, the original duty is suspended: it still exists, but the obligee cannot enforce it while the accord stands.2 When the obligor performs the accord, the original duty is discharged and ends for good.3
Mel owes Alice $1,000, and in March they agree that he will deliver his car in June in full settlement. From March until the car changes hands, and so long as Mel does not breach the agreement, Alice cannot sue for the $1,000. When she accepts the car in June, the debt is gone. This section assumes the accord binds both parties, through consideration or one of its substitutes.
Keep the two states apart. Discharge ends the obligee's rights on the original claim, while suspension only holds them in abeyance, so an answer that treats the two alike misstates what the obligee may do. Suspension has one qualification: if the obligor breaches the accord in a way that discharges the obligee's duty to accept the substitute, the obligee may enforce either the original duty or the duty under the accord.4 The next section develops that exception.
Satisfaction Discharges the Duty
Performance of the accord discharges the original duty.5 The obligor performs by delivering the substitute the parties agreed on, and that delivery is the satisfaction. Satisfaction is always something given in place of what was originally promised; performance, by contrast, is the identical thing the contract called for.6 Once the substitute arrives, the obligee holds everything the accord promised. The original claim ends, and the accord has nothing left to do. A surviving claim would give the obligee both the substitute and the original performance.
Discharge depends on a match between what the accord specified and what the obligor delivers. An accord is a promise to accept a stated performance, so only that performance satisfies it.7 A tender of anything else is no satisfaction, however much it is worth.
A check that follows an agreed settlement shows the same point. In the full-payment check cases covered later in this chapter, the check carries the offer, and cashing it amounts both to acceptance and to performance of the accord.8 When the parties have already agreed, offer and acceptance came first, so sending and cashing the check only perform that agreement.9 Take a seller who claims $450 on a piano and a buyer who honestly disputes the amount. On July 1 they agree that a $425 check delivered on August 1 will settle the matter. That agreement is an executory accord: an accord not yet carried out. When the seller cashes the check on August 1, the executory accord ripens into an accord and satisfaction, and it is too late for the seller to change course and recover the extra $25.10
Suspension Before Performance
Until the accord is performed, the original duty is suspended.12 A suspended duty still exists, but the obligee cannot enforce it while the accord stands. Suspension fills the interval between agreement and delivery, and if the accord fails, the duty comes back into play.
Two simpler rules would work worse. If the obligee could sue on the original claim the day after agreeing to settle it, the promise to accept the substitute would give the obligor nothing. If the original duty vanished the moment the accord was made, an obligee who had accepted only a promise would hold nothing but that promise whenever the substitute failed to arrive. Suspension protects the obligor from suit while the obligor performs and keeps the obligee's original claim alive until the substitute actually arrives.
A litigation settlement shows the rule at work. Plaintiff sues Defendant for $800,000, alleging that Defendant's negligence caused an auto accident. The parties then agree in writing to settle the claim for $300,000, payable in three annual installments of $100,000, plus another $75,000 to Plaintiff's lawyer.13 That agreement is an accord, and it does not discharge Defendant's tort duty. It suspends the duty, and Defendant discharges it only by completing the payments.14 If Plaintiff sues on the tort claim before the first installment falls due, Defendant answers with the accord, and the suit fails. If Defendant instead breaches the accord seriously enough to discharge Plaintiff's duty to accept the remaining payments, say by refusing the second installment outright, Plaintiff may enforce either the original tort duty or Defendant's duty under the accord.15 That choice exists only because the duty was suspended; a discharged duty cannot come back.
The label executory accord makes the same point: the accord itself discharges nothing.16 The label also preserves a historical anachronism, now generally rejected, under which an unperformed accord was no defense to an action on the underlying duty.17 Today the accord defends from the day it is made, before any substitute changes hands.
Return to the piano. Suppose the seller sues for $450 on July 10, before the check is due and with the buyer in no breach. The suit fails, because the $450 duty is suspended until the buyer performs. Suppose instead that on July 15 the buyer announces that no payment will come, and none does. The next section covers when a breach like that ends the suspension. The first question is what the July 1 agreement did to the $450 duty, and contract law presumes it only suspended the duty. A creditor would give up an existing right to $450 for actual payment of $425, and not for a bare promise of $425.18
The presumption yields to contrary intent. The Restatement defines a substituted contract as one the obligee accepts in satisfaction of the original duty, and that thereby discharges it. If the parties meant the July 1 promise to replace the $450 duty at once, the duty is gone even though the buyer never paid, and the seller can sue only for $425.19 The law presumes against that reading because a rational creditor would not accept a mere promise to pay part of a debt in place of a promise to pay all of it.20 An unperformed accord therefore suspends the original duty unless the parties intended an immediate replacement. The later section on substituted contracts takes up that distinction.