Concept
Breach by the Obligor
Accord and satisfaction
Breach by the Obligor
An accord that the obligor has not yet performed suspends the original duty without discharging it, and one exception sits in the same sentence of Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 281(2): the suspension ends if the obligor breaches the accord in a way that discharges the obligee's new duty to accept the performance in satisfaction.1 Once that happens, the obligee may enforce either the original duty or any duty under the accord.2 The rule has two parts that run in order. First comes the kind of breach that ends the suspension; then comes the choice the obligee gains.
Alice's repudiation is the breach that ends the suspension. She has failed to turn the executory accord of July 1 into an accord and satisfaction, and the question is whether you may now seek the $450.4 Under § 281(2) you may, because a flat refusal to pay anything is the clearest case of a breach that discharges your duty to accept the substitute.5
The August 2 check is different. Section 281(2) lifts the suspension only for a breach that discharges the obligee's duty to accept, so a breach that falls short of that leaves you bound to take the check, and the $450 duty stays suspended.6 A one-day delay that harms no one, under an agreement that did not make time essential, falls short. A suit for $450 would fail.
The line falls there because of what the accord put in the obligee's hands. By making the accord, the obligee took on a new duty to accept the substitute, and that duty is what holds the original claim in reserve while the obligor performs. A breach that discharges the duty to accept removes the reason for holding back, so the original claim can be enforced again. A breach that leaves the duty intact leaves the reason in place.
The choice that follows belongs to the obligee. Section 281(2) says the obligee may enforce 'either' the original duty 'or' any duty under the accord, which describes two alternative paths and not two recoveries.7 Alice has already broken the accord and has no say in which obligation you pursue. You may sue for the original $450 or enforce her promise to pay $425, and you take one of them, not both.
A litigation settlement shows the choice in a setting where the two paths look very different. Suppose a plaintiff alleges that the defendant's negligence caused an auto accident and sues for $800,000. During the litigation the parties agree in writing to settle for $300,000, payable in three annual installments of $100,000, plus another $75,000 to the plaintiff's lawyer.8 While the defendant performs, the original duty is suspended. If the defendant later misses an installment, and the breach is serious enough to discharge the plaintiff's duty to accept the remaining performance, the suspension ends. The plaintiff may then enforce a duty under the signed settlement or return to the underlying claim, and picks one.9
Step 3 does the real work, and it is the step students skip when they assume that any missed term revives the original claim. Section 281(2) ties revival to the effect of the breach on the obligee's duty to accept, so the question is always whether the obligee has been excused from taking the substitute.10