Concept
Accord Versus Substituted Contract
Accord and satisfaction
Accord Versus Substituted Contract
Two settlement agreements can read almost the same on the day they are signed and still part ways when the debtor fails to pay. In both, the creditor agrees to accept a different performance in place of an existing duty. The difference is when the old duty ends. Under an accord, the original duty is discharged only when the substitute is performed. Under a substituted contract, it is discharged the moment the new agreement is made.1
Each form has its own rule. For an accord, Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 281(2) says the original duty is suspended until the accord is performed, unless the obligor commits a breach that discharges the obligee's duty to accept the substitute. If that breach occurs, the obligee may enforce either the original duty or any duty under the accord.2 For a substituted contract, § 279 describes a new contract that the obligee accepts in satisfaction of the original duty and that thereby discharges it.3
The choice between the two matters most on default. A substituted contract immediately discharges the prior claim, which merges into the new agreement. Unless the parties expressly agreed otherwise, the original claim can no longer be enforced, and any suit has to be brought on the substituted agreement.4 An accord keeps the original claim in reserve, and § 281(2) returns it to the obligee when the obligor's breach excuses the obligee from taking the substitute.5 Before any default the obligor is equally safe either way, because a suit on the original claim fails when the duty is suspended and also when it is gone. The two forms diverge only if the new promise goes unkept. An obligee under a substituted contract has already traded a claim for a promise, so there is no original duty left to elect and no suspension to lift.
Because the consequences differ so sharply, classification turns on what the parties intended. If they meant the new contract to replace all the terms of the earlier one, it is a substituted contract. If they meant the original duty to survive until the new performance is rendered, it is an executory accord, and the obligation is discharged on performance.6 Settlement agreements seldom announce which kind they are, so the law supplies a rebuttable presumption: an agreement to accept a different performance is an executory accord, because a rational creditor would not take a mere promise to pay part of a debt in place of a promise to pay all of it.7 A new promise to pay a different amount therefore does not by itself create a substituted contract. The presumption gives way only when the parties' words or circumstances show that they meant immediate replacement.
The presumption follows the way risk falls on the creditor. A creditor owed $450 holds an existing right, and a promise of $425 is worth only as much as the debtor's willingness and ability to keep it. A creditor who accepted that promise as an immediate replacement would hold a smaller claim with no way back to the larger one if the debtor defaulted. Few creditors would make that trade, and the creditor can give up the $450 right only for actual payment of the $425.8 The parties remain free to choose the riskier arrangement, but they have to make the choice clear.
The exam version of this issue usually runs on a short timeline. A debtor and creditor agree on July 1 that the debtor will pay $425 on August 1 to settle a $450 debt, and on July 15 the debtor announces that nothing will be paid. If the parties said nothing about replacing the old duty, the presumption makes the July 1 agreement an executory accord, so the $450 duty was only suspended.9 A flat refusal to pay anything is the kind of breach that releases the creditor from taking the substitute, and under § 281(2) the creditor may then sue for $450.10 If the parties clearly intended the $425 promise to replace the $450 duty at once, the agreement is a substituted contract. The $450 duty was discharged on July 1 even though the debtor never paid, and the creditor can sue only for $425.11
Suppose the document had said only that the homeowner would pay $7,500 in six months in settlement of the dispute, with no word about cancelling the price. The presumption would make it an accord, and the $9,000 would stay suspended until the payment arrived. The new promise is identical in both versions, so the label comes entirely from what the parties said about the old duty. On a settlement problem, classify the agreement first, because that tells you whether the obligee's fallback on default is the original claim, with the election § 281(2) provides, or only the new promise.12
The substituted contract has an awkward history. It was created largely to circumvent the unsatisfactory rules that until recently governed executory accords. Now that those rules have been modernized, the untidy distinction between accord and substituted contract should not complicate litigation about routine claim settlements, and the accord presumption keeps the ordinary settlement inside the rules this chapter has already covered.13 A substituted contract also stays between the original parties. That separates it from a novation, in which a third person takes the place of the original obligor.14