Concept
Full-Payment Checks
Accord and satisfaction
Full-Payment Checks
A debtor who disputes a bill rarely negotiates face to face. The debtor mails a check for less than the creditor claims, adds a legend or a cover letter saying that the check is tendered in full satisfaction, and waits. If the amount is not grossly low, the creditor faces a hard choice: take the $9,000 and forfeit the other $1,000 that may be owed, or refuse the check and hope to collect $10,000 later.1
Contract law reads that exchange as an accord. An accord is a contract under which the obligee promises to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty, and performance of the accord discharges the original duty.2 Traditional analysis treats the check as the offer of such an accord, and the payee who indorses the check and collects payment has accepted the contract and discharged any claim for more.3 The mailed check therefore compresses the sequence traced in the earlier sections. There the parties agreed first and performed later, and the original duty lay suspended in between. Here the offer arrives with the money, so agreement and discharge both occur when the creditor collects.
Courts usually test the consideration for such an accord by asking whether the parties had a good faith dispute about the amount owed or the performance due.4 Article 3 of the Uniform Commercial Code builds on that common law device. A party's obligation to pay an instrument is discharged by any act or agreement that would discharge a money obligation under a simple contract, and accord and satisfaction is the first example listed.5 Section 3-311, added in the 1990 revision, supplies the special rules for the full-payment check.6 Three questions organize those rules: what the debtor must prove, whether a creditor can escape by protesting, and what safeguards the statute gives a creditor who never meant to settle.
Elements of the UCC Rule
Section 3-311(a) names three facts the debtor must prove: that the debtor tendered the instrument in good faith as full satisfaction of the claim, that the claim was unliquidated or subject to a bona fide dispute, and that the claimant obtained payment of the instrument.7 Subsection (b) adds the fourth requirement and the discharge itself. Unless subsection (c) applies, the claim is discharged if the debtor proves that the instrument or an accompanying written communication contained a conspicuous statement that the instrument was tendered as full satisfaction.8 Because the statute says the debtor must prove each point, the burden rests on the party who benefits from the discharge. The creditor's safeguards in subsection (c) come last.
The four requirements do separate work. The dispute requirement keeps the compromise real, since a debtor who owes a fixed sum has nothing to settle. The statement tells the creditor that collecting the check will end the claim. Payment marks the moment of acceptance, because until the creditor collects, the creditor can send the check back and keep the larger claim alive. Good faith polices the tender itself. Together they rebuild the agreement the parties never spoke aloud.
The dispute requirement carries over the common law rule.9 A debt that is fixed and undisputed leaves nothing to compromise, so a smaller check stamped 'full satisfaction' does not discharge it.
Partial admissions raise a related question. Suppose the debtor concedes part of the claim at the outset, disputes the rest, and tenders the conceded part as full satisfaction. Most courts treat the claim as unliquidated and find consideration for the accord, while a minority reasons that the debtor is doing only what the debtor was already bound to do. The majority view better supports party autonomy and the resolution of disputes, and the debtor's early admission does not bind the debtor.10
The statement requirement is flexible about location and strict about content. The statute accepts a conspicuous statement on the instrument or in an accompanying written communication, but a tender that says nothing about full satisfaction creates no accord under Article 3.11
Good faith has caused the most trouble, and the better view looks to the manner of the tender and not to the debtor's conduct on the underlying claim.12 In Webb Business Promotions v. American Electronics & Entertainment, the payer's alleged misrepresentation and concealment concerned an underlying contract for 300,000 units. The court held that the good faith element is violated only when the bad faith relates directly to the tender of the accord, so bad faith in the underlying contract does not defeat the discharge.13 The narrow reading fits the device. A debtor who knows that a claim is contested acts no worse for saying so, because contested claims are exactly what the check exists to settle. Bad faith aimed at the tender itself, such as misleading the creditor about what the check offers, falls on the other side of the line.
Payment completes the sequence. The debtor's check proposes the settlement, and the creditor's collection of the money accepts it.14 Until the creditor obtains payment, the creditor can send the check back with the larger claim intact, which is why payment is the event that binds. A creditor who has already collected can still escape, but only through the safeguards taken up at the end of this unit, and first it helps to see which escape attempts fail.
Reservation of Rights Fails
A creditor who cashes a full-payment check may try to retract the settlement with words. The creditor writes 'under protest' or 'all rights reserved' beside the indorsement, deposits the check, and hopes to keep both the money and the claim for the rest. At common law the words did nothing: cashing the check still amounted to the creditor's acceptance of the debtor's offer of an accord and satisfaction.16
The reasoning is practical. The debtor's offer packaged the money with a condition, that it settle the claim, and a creditor who takes the money takes the offer as made. A protest written after the check is paid also gives the debtor no chance to respond. If protest could preserve the balance, a debtor who offered a compromise would pay part of the bill and still face suit for the rest.
The Uniform Commercial Code briefly clouded this rule. Former § 1-207(1), now § 1-308(a), provides for performance of a contract under a reservation of rights.17 Its comment described the provision as machinery for continuing performance along the lines the contract contemplates despite a pending dispute, by going ahead with delivery, acceptance, or payment 'without prejudice,' 'under protest,' 'with reservation of all our rights,' and the like.18 A creditor could read that language as permission to cash a full-payment check under protest and keep the claim.
Courts split over that argument. Several thought the provision inapplicable when the underlying obligation lay outside the UCC, as with a contract for services, and more refused to apply it because nothing showed an intent to change the common law. The most persuasive objection was that a creditor who accepts a check under a reservation of rights is not assenting to performance in a manner demanded or offered.19
The 1990 revisions ended the debate. The drafters added a second subsection to § 1-207 stating that subsection (1) does not apply to an accord and satisfaction, and § 3-311 finds an accord and satisfaction even when the creditor signs under protest or with reservation of rights.20 The provision now appears as § 1-308, and cashing a full-payment check, even with a reservation of rights, still constitutes an accord and satisfaction that bars the creditor from collecting the unpaid balance, unless the creditor can establish a ground for avoiding it, such as duress.21 A creditor's indorsement is therefore no reason to doubt the discharge.22
The two creditors wrote nearly the same thing and ended in opposite positions, so the words did not carry the result. What separated them was whether the creditor took the money. Betty protested after she had taken the benefit of the offer, which is too late to reject its terms. Dmitri refused before, and a creditor who never obtained payment has accepted nothing. The creditor's real choice is the one the common law always gave: refuse the check, or cash it and give up the balance. A creditor who did cash the check may still try to avoid the accord on a ground such as duress, but that doctrine lies outside this unit.23 The statute's own protections for a creditor who never meant to settle work through notice and the return of the money, not through a protest on the check.24
Claimant's Safeguards
Section 3-311(c) gives a claimant two ways to avoid a discharge it never intended, and subsection (d) takes both away from a claimant who in fact knew that the check was offered as full satisfaction.26 The design makes practical sense. A business that receives checks by the thousand cannot be expected to have someone read every memo line before every deposit, and the safeguards let such a claimant protect itself without that burden.
The first exit belongs only to a claimant that is an organization. The organization must prove two things: that, within a reasonable time before the tender, it sent the person it claims against a conspicuous statement directing that communications about disputed debts, including a check tendered as full satisfaction, go to a designated person, office, or place, and that the check or its accompanying communication was not received there.27 A debtor who ignores the instruction has sent the offer to a place the claimant said was not the place for offers.
The second exit is open to every claimant, organization or not. The claimant avoids the discharge by proving that, within 90 days after payment of the instrument, it tendered repayment of the amount of the instrument to the person it claims against. An organization that sent a designated-destination statement complying with the first exit cannot use this one and must rest on the statement.28 The 90 days run from payment of the check, so a claimant that discovers the legend late still has the rest of the window, and one that waits past day 90 has none.
The exit requires that the claimant actually give the money back. Protest while keeping the funds does not satisfy a rule that asks for tender of repayment. In Estes v. McKinney, a claimant who placed the full-settlement checks in an escrow account and wrote the debtor demanding the balance was held not to have rejected the accord and satisfaction.29 The lesson matches the one from the reservation-of-rights cases. A claimant who wants the balance must surrender the money, because a letter or a legend on the indorsement is only words.
Subsection (d) overrides both exits. A claim is discharged if the debtor proves that, within a reasonable time before collection of the instrument was initiated, the claimant, or an agent of the claimant having direct responsibility with respect to the disputed obligation, knew that the instrument was tendered in full satisfaction.30 Notice and repayment exist to shield a claimant who did not know, and a claimant whose responsible representative did know cannot cash the check and then disclaim the settlement.
The statute asks who knew and what that person was responsible for. A manager who is handling a customer's complaint about defective goods has direct responsibility for the disputed obligation, so what the manager knows counts against the organization. A clerk whose only task is to deposit incoming checks has no responsibility for the disputed obligation, so the clerk's glance at a legend does not.
Step 4 is the one students most often omit, and it can reverse an answer that steps 2 and 3 appeared to settle. A claimant that sent a proper notice, or repaid on day 30, still loses if the person responsible for the dispute knew what the check was offered for before it was collected.31