Concept
The Substituted Contract Baseline
Novation
Discharge by Novation
The Substituted Contract Baseline
A substituted contract is a contract that the obligee itself accepts in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty, and that acceptance discharges the original duty.1 The label turns on what the obligee took. The obligee did not take performance of the new promise; it took the new promise itself, as the replacement for the old duty. Intent decides whether that happened. When the parties mean the new contract to replace all the provisions of the earlier one, the new contract is a substituted contract.2
The discharge takes effect when the substituted contract is made, before anyone performs under it. If the obligor later breaches the substituted contract, the obligee has no right to enforce the original duty, so the claim lies on the new agreement alone.3
Contract law is cautious about reading a debt settlement this way. A rational creditor would not accept a mere promise to pay part of a debt in place of a promise to pay the full amount, so a settlement like Maya's is presumed to be an executory accord rather than a substituted contract.4
The accord is the contrast that sharpens the definition. In an accord, the obligee promises to accept a stated performance in satisfaction of the obligor's existing duty, and it is performance of the accord that discharges the original duty.5 Suppose Theo had agreed only to take Maya's guitar in place of the $450, without agreeing to cancel the debt now. The guitar would be the satisfaction, and Maya's $450 obligation would remain undischarged until the guitar was delivered.
Which label fits depends on whether the parties intended an immediate discharge, and that question is answered from the entire circumstances. An immediate discharge is the likelier reading when the contract is an executory bilateral contract and both parties' duties are being changed. Only an accord is the likelier reading when the debtor is having difficulty performing or is already in breach and the creditor is accepting the alternative performance to salvage what it can.6 Immediate discharge is therefore what separates a substituted contract from an accord, and it is the baseline against which novation is measured in the sections that follow.