Concept
Mutual Rescission Defined
Rescission
Rescission by Agreement
Mutual Rescission Defined
Performance is the usual way a contractual duty ends, but discharge covers any means by which a duty is extinguished, and agreement is one of them.1 The Restatement (Second) of Contracts defines an agreement of rescission as an agreement under which each party agrees to discharge all of the other party's remaining duties of performance under an existing contract.2 Another common name for it is mutual rescission.3 The full label matters because rescission by itself also names a different remedy: a party's unilateral unmaking of a contract for a legally sufficient reason, such as the other side's material breach.4
The definition packs three requirements into one sentence. First, there must be an existing contract, so that something is there to discharge. Second, the discharge must run in both directions, because the definition speaks of each party. Third, what each party releases is the other's remaining duties, the performance not yet rendered.
Parties who made a contract by agreement may unmake it by agreement, so long as a third party's vested rights are not affected.5 An agreement of rescission is itself a contract, and an effective one ends the original contract and waives all rights to enforce or sue on it.6 Sokaitis v. Bakaysa shows the principle at work. Two sisters, Sissy and Sybil, had a signed agreement to share gambling winnings for a term of two years. When Sybil later sued on it, Sissy's defense was that the sisters had rescinded the agreement by mutual consent. The court agreed. Sissy had made an offer to terminate, Sybil had accepted it, and the result was a valid agreement to rescind.7 The court added that the rescission fell outside the statute of frauds because it involved an instantaneous performance, under which each party's duties under the original contract were discharged at once.8
Because a rescission is a contract, it needs consideration, and when both sides still owe performance the consideration is already built in. Each sister gave up her rights under the old agreement, and that surrender was the price of being freed from her own duty.9 The same structure appears in any contract that remains executory on both sides: each party gives up the right to receive performance in exchange for avoiding the duty to perform.10 The two releases are exchanged for one another, so neither party must pay anything extra. The structure also explains why the agreement must be mutual. A party who has not agreed to let go has surrendered nothing, and no one loses a right to counterperformance without consenting.
Suppose the caterer instead replies, "Fine, consider it cancelled." The couple has released its right to the catered reception, the caterer has released its right to the fee, and each release is the price of the other. Every duty under the booking is still unperformed, so every duty is a remaining duty, and the discharge is complete. Where performance has already begun, only what is still owing falls within the discharge. Where one party has fully performed, the other's release raises a consideration problem at common law, which a later section takes up.11
The couple's reason for wanting out plays no part in the analysis. A mutual rescission needs no legal ground such as fraud or breach, because those grounds matter when one party tries to escape a contract over the other's objection. When both parties agree, the questions are whether each assented and whether consideration supports the exchange of releases. Motive matters only through the quality of assent. Assent obtained by coercion that amounts to duress may be defeated, and the resulting contract avoided.12 An agreement of rescission is a contract, so that principle reaches it as it reaches any other agreement. A common mistake is to hunt for a breach or a misrepresentation before asking whether both parties agreed to let go, and that order reverses the analysis. The first question is whether each party manifested assent to discharge the other's remaining duties under an existing contract.