Concept
Rescission Versus Look-Alike Terms
Rescission
Rescission Versus Look-Alike Terms
In the Restatement (Second) of Contracts, an agreement of rescission is an agreement under which each party discharges all of the other party's remaining duties of performance under an existing contract (§ 283(1)).1 Practice is looser. Courts, lawyers, and exam writers apply the word rescission to almost any occasion on which a contract stops binding someone, including occasions on which only one party wants out. The looseness matters because the different ways of ending a contract draw their power from different sources, and the source decides what each party can recover afterward.
An agreement of rescission draws its power from the assent of both parties. Under § 283(2), it discharges all remaining duties of performance of both parties, and whether they also agree to make restitution for performance already rendered is a question of interpretation.2 Because the other side consents, the party who wants out needs no ground. The look-alikes differ on exactly this point. In each, one party ends the contract by a power of its own, either one the law supplies because of a defect or a wrong or one the contract itself reserves, and the other party has agreed to nothing. With no shared agreement to fix the terms of the ending, the ground the ending party relies on answers the questions about damages and restitution.
The two subsections below sort the look-alikes from the agreement of rescission. The first treats unilateral rescission, in which a party avoids the contract over the other's objection. The second separates termination and cancellation, two further endings by one party's own power. When a fact pattern says that someone rescinded, ask who ended the contract and by what authority. The answer places the facts in the right doctrine before any consequence is analyzed.
Unilateral Rescission
The word rescission also names an event with nothing mutual about it. One party unmakes the contract for a legally sufficient reason, such as the other party's material breach, whether or not the other party agrees.3 This event is also termed avoidance. It shares only a label with the agreement of rescission. Its power comes from a rule of law that lets a mistaken or wronged party escape the bargain, and that source brings with it a requirement of grounds and a different treatment of restitution.
The requirement of grounds follows from the structure of the situation. In an agreement of rescission, the other party has consented to give up counterperformance, so no one loses a right without agreeing. In a unilateral rescission, the other party has surrendered nothing and may be counting on performance, and the law takes that expectation away only for cause. The grounds can include mistake, fraud, duress, unconscionability, and misrepresentation, in addition to the material breach just mentioned. Courts weigh the materiality of the ground and reserve this drastic remedy for cases in which the basic assumptions of the contract are affected. An action for rescission typically operates as a complete avoidance of the contract.4 Each ground has elements of its own, taught elsewhere. Here it is enough to see that without one of them, the power to rescind unilaterally does not exist.
A buyer who paid $1,000 for goods that the seller fraudulently misdescribed shows the remedy at work. The buyer may declare the transaction rescinded, offer to return the goods, and demand the money back.5 If the seller agrees, the rescission is accomplished by agreement. If the seller refuses, the rescission still stands, and the buyer sues to recover the money. The buyer, not the court, effects the rescission. The court's part is to enter a judgment for restitution if one is needed.6
The dispute in B & B Equipment Co. v. Bowen had the posture that unilateral rescission produces. B & B Equipment sued for a judgment declaring its right to terminate a contract under which Bowen was entitled to buy 100 shares of its stock, and Bowen counterclaimed for a declaration that the contract was valid and subsisting and that his right to buy the shares continued.7 One side claimed a power to end the deal, and the other insisted on holding it to its terms. In that posture, the ending party's claim stands or falls on its ground.
Restitution marks the third difference. Unilateral rescission is accompanied by restitution of any partial performance, which restores the parties to their precontractual positions.9 The reason lies in what is being undone. The law unwinds the entire transaction, not just the future duties, and unless each side gives back what it received, one party would keep the benefit of a bargain that no longer exists. An agreement of rescission works differently, because § 283(2) leaves open whether the parties also agreed to make restitution and treats that as a question of interpretation.10 Where the parties wrote their own exit, their agreement sets its terms. Where the law supplies the exit, the law supplies the restitution too. Rescission is nonetheless distinct from the restitution that follows it. To decide that a transaction is avoided is not to decide the form or measure of restitution.11
Set side by side, the two kinds differ on three points:
- Source of power: an agreement of rescission rests on the assent of both parties, and unilateral rescission rests on a power the law gives one party.
- Need for grounds: an agreement of rescission needs none, and unilateral rescission needs a legally sufficient ground such as mistake, misrepresentation, duress, or material breach.
- Effect on restitution: after an agreement of rescission, restitution turns on interpretation of the parties' agreement, and unilateral rescission carries restitution that restores the pre-contract positions.
When a fact pattern says a party rescinded, two questions therefore decide the doctrine. The first is whether the other party agreed, which points to § 283. The second, asked only if the other party did not agree, is whether the rescinding party had a ground, which points to unilateral rescission. A party with neither agreement nor ground remains bound.
Termination and Cancellation
Two other endings are routinely called rescission in ordinary speech, and the Uniform Commercial Code's vocabulary keeps them apart from it because their consequences differ. Rescission is the term of art for a mutual agreement to discharge contractual duties. Termination is the discharge of duties by exercising a power the agreement itself grants. Cancellation is the putting an end to the contract because the other party breached.13 Section 2-720 recognizes, however, that parties do not necessarily use these terms in this way,14 so a loose label in a letter or a pleading can cost a party something it never meant to give up.
The three labels differ in where the ending party's power comes from, and that source decides what survives the ending. Rescission draws on the other party's assent, so no one loses a right without agreeing to lose it. Termination draws on the contract itself: the parties wrote into their bargain, in advance, a right to bring it to an end, and exercising that right is the contract operating on its own terms. Cancellation draws on the other party's breach, which gives the injured party a legal basis to stop performing even though the other side has agreed to nothing.
A lease shows the middle category at work. When a lessee stops paying rent and the lessor ends the lease pursuant to the lease itself, the future obligations on one or both sides come to an end. The ending is not necessarily a rescission, there is no restitution for past performances, and damages to the lessor may be in order.15 The lessor is enforcing the lease according to its terms, so the transaction stays intact for the period already performed, and the breach that triggered the clause can still support a claim for what the lessor lost. Two parties who instead sign a document calling off their sale and releasing each other present the opposite pattern. No clause was invoked and no one breached, so the ending rests on assent alone. It is a rescission under § 283(1), and whether restitution follows is a question of interpretation under § 283(2).16
Cancellation matters most when the other side's breach is serious. At common law, a party whose contract has been materially breached has two courses open. The victim may rescind, which discharges all rights and duties under the contract and may support a restitution action for benefits the victim conferred on the breaching party. The victim may instead declare a total breach, which discharges the victim's own obligation to perform and any obligation to accept further performance from the breaching party, yet preserves the right to damages for breach of the entire contract.17 The second course is the common-law counterpart of what the Code calls cancellation, and a victim who wants compensation for the lost bargain should take it.
The trap springs when a victim of breach reaches for the first course by name while intending the second. Restitution returns to each side what it gave, as though the bargain had never been made. Damages measure what the victim lost by not receiving the performance the bargain promised. A victim who declares the contract rescinded has described the bargain as undone, and a claim for the benefit of a bargain sits awkwardly beside a statement that the bargain no longer exists. If the victim of a material breach responds by stating that the contract is rescinded, a court may read that word literally and deny any right to recover damages for the breach.18
The two letters describe the same breach and differ only in the consequence each invites. For sales of goods, the Code removes much of this risk. When the parties mutually terminate a contract, or when either party puts an end to it for the other's breach, remedies for breach of contract are preserved unless a contrary intention clearly appears (§§ 2–106(3) and (4) and 2–720).19 Outside goods, the safer course is to match the word to the remedy sought: damages go with a declared total breach, and restitution goes with rescission. A fact pattern in which the victim of a breach announces that the contract is rescinded and then sues for damages is built to test exactly this point.