Concept
Discharge of Remaining Duties
Rescission
Discharge of Remaining Duties
A mutual rescission ends a contract by extinguishing whatever is left of it: an agreement of rescission discharges all remaining duties of performance of both parties.1 That sentence from Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 283(2) turns on three words. To discharge a duty is to extinguish it, so the party who owed the duty is free of it and the party to whom it was owed has nothing left to enforce.2 Remaining confines the discharge to performance not yet rendered. Both makes the discharge run in each direction. The rule gives effect to what the parties agreed to do, because under § 283(1) an agreement of rescission is one in which each party agrees to discharge all of the other's remaining duties of performance under an existing contract.3
Remaining ties the rule to executory duties, the ones still waiting to be performed. Performance is the most common way a contractual duty is discharged, so performance already rendered has satisfied the duty that called for it.4 The rescission therefore acts only on what is still owing when the parties agree. Suppose a harvester has cut 50 of 1,000 acres of wheat when the parties rescind. The duty to cut the other 950 acres and the owner's matching duty to pay for that work are the remaining duties, and both fall away. Whether the harvester may still collect for the first 50 acres is a separate question. The Restatement treats it as a matter of interpretation whether the parties also agreed to make restitution for performance already rendered, and the next section takes it up.5
The same word marks the outer edge of the rule. When one party has already fully performed, only the other party's duties remain to be released, and that release raises a consideration issue at common law.6 The sections on consideration for discharge return to that problem.
Both explains why consideration poses no difficulty when duties remain on each side. Each party gives up the right to receive performance in exchange for being relieved of the duty to perform, so each surrender pays for the other.7 That mutuality is built into the definition, since each party agrees to discharge the other's remaining duties.8
The discharge also takes effect at once. In Sokaitis v. Bakaysa, the court held that the rescission agreement was not subject to the statute of frauds, because the rescission involved an instantaneous performance under which each party's duties under the original contract were immediately discharged.9 Nothing was left to perform once the parties assented, so a party who later sues on the old contract is suing on a duty that no longer exists. The later section on oral rescission returns to the statute of frauds.
A rescission differs from a modification, which changes a term and leaves the contract standing. The test follows from the definition: the parties must have agreed to discharge all of each other's remaining duties.10 If every remaining duty is extinguished, the parties have rescinded. If any duty continues, even in altered form, they have only modified.
The distinction matters because a modification keeps the original contract in force, while a rescission removes it. When a fact pattern has two parties agreeing to change a date, a price, or a quantity, look to what the agreement does to the remaining duties, not to the word the parties use for it.
The discharge has one limit that comes from outside the two contracting parties: they may discharge their duties by mutual rescission only so long as a third party's vested rights are not affected.11 A third-party beneficiary whose right has vested holds that right as its own, and an agreement between the original parties cannot take it away. How a beneficiary's right comes to vest belongs to the law of third-party beneficiaries. For present purposes it is enough to know that rescission does not reach a right once it has vested.
If step one shows that one side has fully performed, the discharge has little to act on, and the question becomes whether the release of the other side's duty is supported by consideration. The later sections on consideration for discharge answer that question.