Concept
Restitution After Rescission
Rescission
Restitution After Rescission
An agreement of rescission discharges every remaining duty of both parties, and that discharge settles only the future.1 Restitution looks the other way, to performance that one party delivered before the rescission and the other may still hold. The agreement may have been a clean break in which each side keeps what it has, or it may have carried an understanding that one side would be paid for work already done. Which it was is a question of interpretation: the parties' agreement decides whether they also agreed to make restitution for performance already rendered, so the first task is to read the agreement for what the parties meant.2
A harvesting contract shows the common-law default at work. X agrees to harvest Y's 1,000 acres of wheat at a stated price per acre. After X has harvested 50 acres, the parties rescind by mutual agreement and say nothing about those acres. Under the prevailing common-law view, no presumption or inference arises that X preserved the right to collect the contract price for the work already performed.3 The rescission undid the contract, and the per-acre price was a right under the contract the parties unmade. Silence fits a mutual walk-away as naturally as it fits an understanding that X would still be paid, so the law does not choose the second reading for them. Had the rescission agreement said that Y will pay for the 50 acres already harvested, the parties would have agreed to restitution, and X would recover on the strength of that term.4
Because nothing is presumed in X's favor, X must show that the parties meant to keep the right to payment alive. Y, who owes nothing under the contract for past work unless the agreement says so, has nothing to prove. An exam fact pattern that has the parties rescind by mutual agreement and then has the performing party sue at the contract rate is testing exactly this point, and the first question is what the rescission agreement said about the work already done.
Losing the claim under the contract does not end X's options. X may still recover in restitution the reasonable value of the benefits conferred, even though the parties preserved no rights under the rescinded contract.5 The two claims rest on different foundations. A claim under the contract needs a right the parties preserved and is measured by the contract price. A restitution claim needs a benefit conferred and is measured by its reasonable value, so the sum recovered need not match the agreed price. The source says X may recover, not that X will, and the restitution claim has to be made out on its own terms.
The common-law default can trap a party who says rescinded and nothing more, because a claim for past performance may disappear without anyone having decided to give it up. For transactions in goods, the Uniform Commercial Code avoids the trap by reversing the default. When the parties mutually terminate a contract, or when either party puts an end to the contract for the other's breach, remedies for breach of contract are preserved unless a contrary intention clearly appears.6 The burden thus falls on the party who wants a clean break, who must make that intention clear, and silence leaves in place whatever remedies had accrued. A seller of goods who held a claim against the buyer before a silent mutual termination keeps that claim. A harvester under a services contract in the same silent posture must prove a preserved right. The first sorting question is whether the contract is for goods.
Everything above concerns an agreed rescission, in which the parties' own terms govern the past. Rescission can also be the remedy a court awards, and then restitution follows as a matter of course: when rescission is the remedy, the parties must make restitution of the benefits exchanged.7 The source of the restitution marks the difference. After an agreed rescission, the agreement supplies it if the parties so intended, and the independent claim for reasonable value fills the gap when they did not. When rescission is the remedy, the law requires it.
The label rescission alone does not tell you whether restitution follows, and the way the contract ended does. A contract may be terminated under its own terms, without rescission and without restitution as to past performance, as when a lessor terminates a lease because the lessee has not paid rent.8 Money already paid can also come back without any rescission: a tenant who paid the contract rent while the landlord was in breach of the implied warranty of habitability may sue for the excess the tenant paid.9 In a fact pattern, ask who ended the contract and how, and then ask what the agreement or the law provides about performance already rendered.