Concept
Consideration for Discharge
Rescission
Consideration for Discharge
A release is a promise to give up a right to performance, and a promise needs a reason the law will enforce. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 273 applies that idea to discharge. Except as §§ 274 through 277 provide, an obligee's manifestation of assent to a discharge is not effective unless it is made for consideration, is made in circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration, or has induced action or forbearance that would make a promise enforceable.1 The obligee is the party to whom the duty is owed, so the section asks when that party's agreement to give up the right actually frees the other side.
The requirement screens out gifts. Without it, an offhand "forget the rest" could extinguish a valuable right, and the other party could treat the right as gone. In a mutual rescission, consideration comes built in, because each party's surrender of counterperformance pays for the other's. That reasoning holds only while each party still has something to surrender. Once one side has nothing left to give, the release must find support somewhere else.
Three questions organize the analysis. First, has the party giving the release fully performed? If not, the discharge takes effect without consideration.2 If so, the second question is whether the releasing party got something new in exchange. If not, the third is whether the release qualifies on another ground: circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration, or reliance that would make a promise enforceable. The subsections below take the questions in that order.
Both Sides Still Owe Performance
A party who has not yet fully performed can release the other side's duty without getting anything in return. If a party, before fully performing its own duty, manifests assent to discharge the other party's duty to render part or all of the agreed exchange, that duty is discharged to that extent without consideration.3 The trigger is a fact about the person giving the release: that person still has performing to do. The release may reach all of the other side's performance or only part, and the discharge extends only as far as the release does.
Ordinary mutual rescission is the most familiar setting, and there consideration is present anyway. Assent to a discharge is effective when it is made for consideration,4 and when duties are executory on each side, the two releases pay for one another: each party gives up the right to receive performance and receives freedom from the duty to perform.5 That exchange is what an agreement of rescission contemplates, since each party agrees to discharge all of the other's remaining duties.6
The exception reaches past the mutual case. When only one party speaks and receives no release in return, there is no exchange of releases to supply consideration, yet the release still takes effect as long as the releasing party has not fully performed.8 The line follows the logic of exchange. A party with performance still owing remains in an open exchange, and giving up part of the other side's share merely adjusts it. A party who has finished holds only a right to performance, and surrendering that right for nothing is the bare gift that the consideration requirement screens out.
On an exam, then, the first question is whose performance is complete. The rule looks to the releasing party and not to the party being released.
One Side Fully Performed
A party who has fully performed stands outside the exception, so § 273 applies to that party's release in full. The difficulty is what such a party has left to trade.
Mutual rescission pays for itself when both sides still owe performance, because each party gives up the right to receive performance in exchange for escaping the duty to perform.10 That exchange requires a duty to escape on each side. A party who has fully performed owes nothing more and holds only a right to the other side's performance, so a release from that party discharges the other party's duty at no cost to the other party. Calling the arrangement a mutual rescission does not repair the gap. An agreement of rescission is one in which each party discharges the other's remaining duties,11 and a release by way of "mutual rescission" after one party has fully performed raises a consideration issue at common law.12 The attempted release of an obligation without any bargained exchange has troubled the common law at least since Foakes v. Beer was decided in 1884, and some states have legislated on the subject.13
The release fails for a reason that follows from what a release is. It is a promise to give up a right, and the neighbor sought nothing in return, so it is a gratuitous promise, and the law does not enforce such promises without something more. A party with duties outstanding receives something for the release, namely freedom from those duties, and that keeps the exchange two-sided. A party whose duties are finished has nothing to receive. When the release fails, the duty survives, and the neighbor may still sue for the $400.
A fully performed party can still release the other side effectively if the release is made for consideration.14 That condition asks for a real exchange: the other party must give something new, such as a promise or a performance, that the releasing party sought as the price of the release.
The buyer's return promise is the only difference between the two sellers, and it turns a gift into a bargain. Consideration, though, is one of three ways a release can take effect. A release is also effective when it is made in circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration, or when it has induced action or forbearance that would make a promise enforceable.15 The next subsection takes up those substitutes. A fact pattern in which the parties "mutually rescind" after one side has fully performed is built to test this point, and the first thing to ask is whether both sides still owed performance when they agreed.
Substitutes for Consideration
Two of the conditions in § 273 let a release take effect even though nothing was given for it, and they matter chiefly to a fully performed party, who has nothing left to trade. A release is effective if it has induced such action or forbearance as would make a promise enforceable.17 It is also effective if it is made in circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration.18
Neither clause writes a rule of its own about releases. Each sends the court to the general law of promissory enforcement and asks what that law would do with a promise on the same facts. The reason follows from what a release is: a promise to give up a right to performance. Consideration is only one ground on which the law binds a promisor, so a release that qualifies under another ground deserves the enforcement any other promise would receive.
The reliance route is the more concrete of the two. A release that induces the other party to act or refrain in a way the law would protect becomes effective, because the releasing party invited the change of position and cannot fairly undo it. Two phrases carry the weight. The action or forbearance must have been induced by the release, so a step the other party took before the release, or would have taken anyway, adds nothing. And it must be of a kind that would make a promise enforceable, so a purely passive response does not qualify.
What is missing in that scene is a change of position. The owner who merely held the money lost nothing when the contractor changed course, so there is no reliance harm for the law to prevent.
The second owner is now bound to a third party on the strength of the release. If the contractor could revive the debt, the owner would be committed to the expansion with the money gone, a loss the contractor's own words caused. Consideration is absent in both scenes, and the owner's change of position decides the second. A student who stops at the observation that the owner paid nothing has missed the route that makes the release effective.
The circumstances clause turns on the setting in which the release is made, whatever the other party does afterward. If the law of the jurisdiction would enforce a gratuitous promise made in those circumstances, the release is effective on the same footing. Local law varies on which gratuitous promises it enforces, and the common law has struggled with releases that lack any bargained exchange since Foakes v. Beer, with some states legislating on the subject.19 The clause therefore cannot be applied from the Restatement alone. The facts or a stated rule of the jurisdiction must supply a reason that a gratuitous promise of this kind would be enforced.
The three conditions in § 273 are alternatives, so a release takes effect if any one of them is met. An answer that rejects a fully performed party's release for want of consideration has finished only the first step. Next ask whether the release induced action or forbearance that would make a promise enforceable, and whether the circumstances are ones in which the governing law would enforce a gratuitous promise.