Concept
The Consideration Baseline
Release
Release of Contractual Duties
The Consideration Baseline
A creditor who says “forget the rest, we’re even” has not necessarily discharged anything. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 273 sets the default: except as §§ 274 through 277 provide, an obligee’s manifestation of assent to a discharge is ineffective unless a listed ground is present.1 The obligee is the person to whom the duty is owed, and a discharge is any means by which the duty is extinguished. Performance is the commonest means, but not the only one; an obligee’s agreement to give up the duty can also end it.2 The default burdens the obligor, who must point to a ground that makes the creditor’s words effective.
Three grounds are listed. The assent is effective if it was made for consideration; if it was made in circumstances in which a promise would be enforceable without consideration; or if it has induced such action or forbearance as would make a promise enforceable.3 Consideration comes first because it is the ordinary route, and this section is about how it is supplied. The other two grounds return later in the chapter.
Consideration exists when a promise is made for something in return as part of a bargain. The thing sought may be a return promise, or it may be the actual doing of an act or refraining from one.4 A creditor who forgives part of a debt and gets nothing back has made a gratuitous promise, and the law does not enforce such a promise merely because it was made. The requirement screens out casual or unconsidered statements. Without it, an obligor could turn an offhand “forget it” into a defense to a debt that was otherwise due. The common law has struggled with attempted releases of this kind at least since Foakes v. Beer was decided in 1884.5
Bargained-for exchange enters a discharge in two typical ways. The first is settlement. Suppose an injured plaintiff releases a negligence claim in return for the defendant’s promise to pay $50,000. The plaintiff’s surrender of the claim is the detriment for which the payment is exchanged. Courts hold that surrendering a validly disputed claim is sufficient consideration for a return promise, and a claim is validly disputed when its merits are uncertain on the facts or the law.6 The harder case is a claim that turns out to have had no foundation. Some jurisdictions still treat its release as consideration if the claimant held a good-faith belief in its validity, and opinions sometimes add that the belief must have some foundation in fact or law.7 The rule lets a settlement stand without a second trial of the underlying claim. The good-faith limit keeps it from rewarding a claimant who knew the claim was baseless.
The second way is a performance by the obligor that differs from what the duty already required. A debtor who pays a lesser sum before the debt is due, or pays at a place other than the one designated, does something the debtor was not yet bound to do. The creditor’s agreement to discharge the balance is exchanged for that extra act.8 Restatement § 73 sets a limit: the difference must reflect more than a pretense of bargain, so a token variation invented to dress up a gratuitous release will not do.9
Timing alone moved the answer. On the due date, the creditor receives nothing the creditor was not already entitled to, so the exchange is missing. Early payment gives the creditor something new, so the exchange exists.
The baseline also explains why the later sections matter. A bare promise to give up a right is unenforceable, but a completed gift is irrevocable. That contrast opens the door to treating a gratuitous discharge as effective once it is finished and no longer merely promised.10 The Restatement’s specific rules occupy that territory. One covers an obligee’s cancellation, destruction, or surrender of a writing customarily accepted as a symbol or evidence of the right.11 Another covers an obligee’s assent to the discharge of an obligor’s duty to transfer identified personal property that the obligor holds.12 Without the consideration baseline in view, those rules would look like ordinary law instead of departures from it.