Concept
Notice That Opens the Choice
Discharge after notice claiming excuse
Discharge After Excuse Notice
Notice That Opens the Choice
A seller who can establish an excuse is not in breach, so the buyer has no damages claim to fall back on.1 The buyer still has to decide what to do: keep waiting, accept less, or buy elsewhere. Section 2-616 of the Uniform Commercial Code hands the buyer that decision, and it begins with a notice from the seller.
When a buyer receives notification of a material or indefinite delay, or of an allocation justified under § 2-615, the buyer may respond by written notification to the seller. The response reaches any delivery concerned. It also reaches the whole contract where the prospective deficiency substantially impairs the value of the whole contract under the installment-contract provisions of § 2-612.2 That opening clause fixes three things: the event that triggers the buyer's options (a notice of a particular kind), the form of the buyer's answer (a writing to the seller), and the answer's reach (the affected deliveries and, sometimes, the whole contract). This unit takes up the trigger and the form. The next takes up the reach. Note that the writing requirement attaches to the buyer's answer, not to the seller's notice.
Two kinds of notice qualify. In most § 2-615 cases the seller faces no allocation problem. It expects a material or indefinite delay that is excused, and it must still give notice, after which the buyer still has the option to cancel.3 Allocation arises when the excusing event impairs only part of the seller's capacity. The seller then divides what it can supply among its customers in a fair and reasonable manner, and it must tell the buyer seasonably that there will be delay or non-delivery and what quota it estimates for the buyer. An allocation notice therefore carries two facts: that deliveries will fall short, and by how much. A delay notice carries only the first.
The trigger is narrower than any announcement of trouble. The notice must report a delay that is material or indefinite, or an allocation that is justified under § 2-615. Two notices show where the line falls.
The same line runs through delay notices. A seller that reports an excused supply interruption and says it cannot estimate how long shipment will be held up has given notice of a delay that is both material and indefinite. A seller that says only that it will be two days late, with no excuse in view, has given neither kind of notice. The buyer's rights then follow the ordinary rules for late performance.
The purpose of the mechanism shows in how courts treat its timing. In Eastern Air Lines v. McDonnell Douglas, the seller argued, long after the fact, that every contract had terminated automatically under § 2-616(2) once thirty days passed. The buyer had not pursued its § 2-616 options, but both parties had kept performing for years as though the agreements remained in force, without ever mentioning the Code procedures. The court rejected the seller's argument. A seller cannot use the thirty-day termination provision to deprive an unwary buyer of its U.C.C. rights and remedies, because that would frustrate § 2-616's purpose of protecting the buyer confronted with a claim of excuse.4 The notice and the buyer's answer thus work as one protective system, and the lapse rule discussed later in this chapter must be read in that light.
Once the notice arrives, the buyer's choice ends in one of three places. The buyer may terminate and thereby discharge any unexecuted portion of the contract.5 It may instead modify the contract by agreeing to take its available quota in substitution.6 If it does neither within a reasonable time not exceeding thirty days, the contract lapses with respect to any deliveries affected.7 The sections that follow take the scope of the choice first and then each outcome in turn.