Concept
Affected Deliveries or Whole Contract
Discharge after notice claiming excuse
Affected Deliveries or Whole Contract
One sentence of § 2-616(1) opens the buyer's options and also fixes how far they reach. After notice of a material or indefinite delay or a justified allocation, the buyer may respond by written notification to the seller "as to any delivery concerned," and, where the prospective deficiency substantially impairs the value of the whole contract under § 2-612, "then also as to the whole."1 The buyer therefore holds one scope the moment the notice arrives and must earn the other. The word "also" shows that the wider reach adds to the narrower one: a buyer who qualifies for the whole contract keeps its rights over the delivery concerned.
A delivery is concerned when the seller's notice touches it, either because the notice reports that the delivery will be late or because the allocation cuts what the seller will ship under it. The buyer needs no further showing to respond as to that delivery. The seller, for its part, is excused, and an excused seller is not in breach.2 The buyer's response therefore rests on the statutory notice, not on a claim that the seller broke the contract.
The wider reach turns on a single question: does the prospective deficiency substantially impair the value of the whole contract? Section 2-616 takes that standard from § 2-612, the Code's rule on breach of installment contracts, by cross-reference instead of writing a second test.3 The measure is the whole contract, so the value of the single delivery does not answer it. The word "prospective" matters too, because the notice forecasts a shortfall that has not fully occurred, and the buyer must judge what that forecast does to the contract overall. If the value of the whole contract is not impaired, the buyer has no option as to the whole and may act only as to the installment or installments involved.4
Many students treat any allocation notice as license to cancel the entire contract, because a reduced quota feels like a broken promise about the whole deal. The statute does not permit that. A delay or an allocation opens the buyer's options as to the deliveries concerned and nothing wider until the buyer can show substantial impairment of the whole. A buyer who reaches for the whole contract without that showing has no authority under § 2-616 for the extra reach, though its rights as to the affected delivery remain.
This scope question sets the limits of whatever the buyer chooses to do next. The following sections take up the choices themselves.