Concept
Mandatory Buyer Protection
Discharge after notice claiming excuse
Mandatory Buyer Protection
Subsection (3) of § 2-616 bars the parties from contracting out of the section. Its provisions "may not be negated by agreement except in so far as the seller has assumed a greater obligation under the preceding section," which is § 2-615.1 To negate a provision is to agree in advance that it will not apply. A buyer who receives a justified notice of delay or allocation therefore keeps the options § 2-616 gives it, terminating the unexecuted portion or taking the quota, whatever the contract says about them.
The rule runs in one direction only. Sections 2-615 and 2-616 on their face give the excuse to the seller, and subsection (3) is designed to protect the buyer, not the seller.2 The buyer's options are its answer to a claim of excuse. If the seller could write a waiver into the contract, that answer would be disclaimed before the claim was ever made.
Eastern Air Lines shows the same protective purpose at work. The buyer, Eastern, never pursued its options under § 2-616. Even so, the parties kept performing from 1966 through 1969 as though the agreements remained in force, and neither mentioned the Code procedures. The seller, McDonnell, later argued that every contract had terminated automatically under the thirty-day provision of § 2-616(2). The court refused to accept that "belated assertion." A seller cannot use the thirty-day termination provision to deprive an unwary buyer of its U.C.C. rights and remedies, because doing so would frustrate the section's purpose of protecting the buyer confronted with a claim of excuse.3 That case involved the thirty-day lapse, not a waiver clause. But the purpose it names is the one subsection (3) serves, and it would be odd if a form clause could achieve what the seller's reading of the lapse could not.
The exception for a greater obligation is where exam questions turn, because it appears to cut the other way.
The exception turns on what the seller assumed. Section 2-615 itself begins by reserving the case of a seller who "may have assumed a greater obligation."4 Excuse is what keeps a seller out of breach and avoids the contract.5 A seller whose own promise displaced the excuse has none to establish, so no justified notice exists for § 2-616 to answer. Enforcing the seller's promise therefore conflicts with nothing in the buyer's protection. The question in every such problem is whether the excuse existed at all, not whether the buyer agreed to give up its options.
The usual trap is a clause that reduces the seller's responsibility or the buyer's options, such as a disclaimer of liability for delay. That clause assumes less, not more. It cannot unlock the exception, and it cannot displace the buyer's rights under the section.