Concept
The Right to Damages
Expectation interest (including direct, incidental, and consequential damages)
The Right to Damages
Before a court can price the expectation interest, it must decide whether the injured party has a claim at all. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 346 answers that threshold question broadly: the injured party has a right to damages for any breach by a party against whom the contract is enforceable, unless the claim for damages has been suspended or discharged.1 Three conditions sit inside that sentence. A breach must have occurred, the contract must be enforceable against the party who committed it, and the claim for damages must not have been suspended or discharged. When all three hold, the right exists, and only the amount remains to be decided. The comment adds that the claim may be one for total breach or for only partial breach, a distinction the next section develops.2
Proof of harm goes to the size of the award, not to the existence of the right, as the discussion of nominal damages below shows. What defeats the right is structural rather than evidentiary: the contract cannot be enforced against the defendant, the duty of performance was discharged before any breach, or the claim itself has since been discharged.
When No Claim Arises
The first limit is enforceability. Every breach carries a claim for damages unless the contract is not enforceable against the party in breach, as where that party is not bound because of the Statute of Frauds.3 A defendant protected in that way cannot be made to pay damages for refusing to perform, so the plaintiff has nothing to price. The comment notes one exceptional corner. When a contract to transfer an interest in land is unenforceable under the Statute of Frauds, action in reliance makes the contract enforceable by specific performance even though it gives rise to no claim for damages.4 That corner shows that enforceability and the damages claim are separate questions, since one remedy can be available on facts that produce no claim for the other.
The second limit is discharge, which works in two ways. If the duty of performance itself has been suspended or discharged, as by impracticability of performance or frustration of purpose, there is no breach and the damages rule never applies.5 A seller whose duty to deliver has been discharged and who then fails to deliver has broken nothing. The other form operates after a breach. A duty to pay damages may be suspended or discharged by agreement or otherwise, and once it is discharged the claim for damages is extinguished, along with the right to enforce by other means such as specific performance or an injunction.6 Parties may also vary these rules by agreement, as long as the agreement is not invalid for unconscionability or other grounds; for example, they may substitute repair or replacement for damages.7
The common error is to treat every failure to perform as a breach and move straight to measuring loss. The threshold question is whether an enforceable duty still in force was broken, and an answer that skips it computes damages on a claim that does not exist.
Nominal Damages
A breach by a party against whom the contract is enforceable always gives rise to a claim, yet some breaches cause no loss. Section 346(2) addresses that case: if the breach caused no loss, or if the amount of the loss is not proved under the rules stated in the chapter, a small sum fixed without regard to the amount of loss is awarded as nominal damages.9 The provision covers two situations. In the first, the breach caused no loss. In the second, loss occurred but cannot be recovered, either because it cannot be proved with reasonable certainty or because another limit on damages bars it, limits that later sections develop.10 In either case the injured party obtains a judgment, and no compensation follows.
The Restatement's illustration shows the first situation. A contracts to sell B 1,000 shares of X Corporation stock for $10 a share, to be delivered on June 1, and refuses to deliver. At trial B proves that the same number of shares could have been bought on the market on June 1 for $10 each. B has suffered no loss and receives nominal damages.11 A substitute available at the contract price leaves nothing for money to repair, and contract remedies are not aimed at penalizing breach.12 The buyer of a building who can purchase an equivalent building for the same or less money likewise has no recourse for expectation damages against the seller, beyond the nominal sum.13
The same economic focus explains why contract damages ignore noneconomic injury. Unlike tort law, which permits compensation for emotional trauma in some situations, contract law is dry-eyed and coldly commercial, and except in the most unusual cases it takes no account of noneconomic injury.14 A party who suffers aggravation, inconvenience, or emotional distress in coping with a breach and finding a replacement therefore recovers nothing for those harms.
The nominal sum is small and usually fixed by judicial practice in the jurisdiction. The court may, in its discretion, add court costs, which are generally awarded if a significant right was involved or the claimant made a good faith effort to prove damages, and denied if the action was frivolous or brought in bad faith.15 Unless a significant right is involved, a court will not reverse and remand for a new trial if only nominal damages could result.16 The word small has a ceiling. In MBM Financial Corp. v. The Woodlands Operating Co., a Texas decision, $1, $10, or even $100 could be nominal damages, but $1,000 was too much.17
Nominal damages also mark the limit of a promisee's recovery in one recurring pattern. When a promisee contracts to give a third party the benefit of the promised performance, both the intended beneficiary and the promisee have claims for damages if performance is not forthcoming. A promisee who seeks damages will usually be limited to nominal damages, because the promisee cannot recover for the beneficiary's loss and ordinarily has suffered none; specific performance is often the more appropriate remedy for the promisee.18 In the Restatement's illustration, a husband promises his wife in a separation agreement not to change the provision in his will for their son. After her death he changes it, and her personal representative recovers nominal damages.19
Plaintiffs seldom sue for nominal damages alone. Except where a plaintiff seeks vindication, as in a libel action by someone publicly and wrongly accused of unsavory conduct, lawsuits are not brought to recover merely nominal damages, and few plaintiffs would regard that outcome as more than a Pyrrhic victory.20 The award more often results from a mistake: the plaintiff misjudges the likely recovery and learns of the error only at trial. Some wrongs, though, affect rights important enough to justify litigation even when difficulty in assessing the loss makes actual damages hard to recover.21
The nominal-damages idea suits only wrongs that are actionable without harm. Where injury is an element of liability, no liability attaches unless the plaintiff suffers actual harm, so nominal damages are unavailable. The Sherman Antitrust Act requires proof of injury, and fraud and negligence typically do too, which is why negligent driving that injures no one is not actionable at all.22 A breach of an enforceable contract is different: the breach itself is the actionable wrong, with or without loss.23
The first three steps decide whether a claim exists, and the fourth decides only what the claim is worth. That ordering is why a plaintiff can win on liability and still recover a token sum.