Concept
Total and Partial Breach
Expectation interest (including direct, incidental, and consequential damages)
Total and Partial Breach
Every expectation problem starts with a sorting question: how much of the injured party's remaining rights to performance does the claim reach? Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 236 answers with two definitions. A claim for damages for total breach rests on all of those rights.1 A claim for damages for partial breach rests on only part of them.2 The sort comes before any arithmetic because the award must match the size of the wrong. When a breach destroys the exchange, the injured party has lost everything the promisor still owed, and damages must price that whole benefit. When the exchange survives, the injured party still holds the right to the rest of the performance, so the claim prices only the part that came up short. Pricing the whole bargain at that point would pay for performance the injured party may yet receive.
Two things place a breach in one class or the other. The first is materiality. A material breach is a failure to substantially perform, which leaves unmet an implied promissory condition precedent to the other party's duty to perform, so the other party need not continue performing.3 The second is the injured party's own choice. One who terminates and refuses to render any further return performance claims for total breach; one who does not terminate and stands ready to render the remaining return performance claims for partial breach.4 The breach reading develops materiality in full. Here the label does a narrower job: it fixes how much of the bargain the damages must cover.
Total Breach
Restatement § 236(1) defines the claim that governs when a breach ends the exchange: damages based on all of the injured party's remaining rights to performance.5 Remaining ties the claim to what is still owed when the breach occurs, so a party who has already received part of the bargain prices only the balance. All separates this claim from the partial-breach claim taken up below.
The award has three working parts, and each has its reason. First, it prices the whole benefit of the performance that will never arrive. Once the breach ends the exchange, nothing the promisor still owed will be delivered, so an award for less would leave the injured party holding part of a bargain that can no longer be completed, which is not the position performance would have given her.6 Second, the award takes account of what the breach saves her. The market measure, for example, is the difference between the contract price and the market price, so the price she no longer has to pay is already netted out; adding the full market value on top would pay her twice, once through the award and once through the money never spent.7 Third, any prepayment comes back. When the defendant commits a total breach after the plaintiff has prepaid, the plaintiff recovers the prepayment as well as additional expectation damages, such as a market-contract differential, because the prepayment bought a performance she will not receive.8 The next section develops the general formula behind these parts: loss in value plus other loss, less cost avoided and less loss avoided. A total-breach claim uses all four terms.
The arithmetic is easiest to see in dollars. A buyer orders 100,000 reams of paper for $500,000 and prepays 10 percent, $50,000, with the balance due on delivery. On the delivery date comparable paper costs $600,000, and the seller refuses to deliver any. Two routes reach the damages. Route one starts with the value of what the buyer should have received, $600,000, and subtracts the cost she avoids, the $450,000 balance that never falls due: $150,000. Route two starts with what she has already put in, the $50,000 prepayment, and adds the $100,000 gain from paying $500,000 for paper now worth $600,000: also $150,000.9
The routes must agree, because $600,000 less $450,000 is the same number as ($600,000 less $500,000) plus ($500,000 less $450,000), the gain on the bargain plus the price already paid. The award also delivers what the definition promises. If the buyer purchases replacement paper for $600,000, she has laid out $650,000 in all, counting the prepayment, and recovered $150,000, a net of $500,000, which is the contract price.10 The calculation leaves out any profit she would have made by using or reselling the paper. That ensuing loss may be added, subject to limits taught later in this chapter, because special damages are measured by the gains the promised performance could have produced for collateral reasons.11
The same arithmetic serves a party who was to perform. A builder agrees to build a house for $150,000 at an expected cost of $120,000, and the owner repudiates after the builder has spent $50,000. The builder recovers the $30,000 expected profit plus the $50,000 already spent, which is $80,000. Equivalently, it recovers the $150,000 price less the $70,000 of cost it no longer has to incur, which is again $80,000.12 Any progress payments the owner has made are credited against that figure.13 Courts reach the same structure for a manufacturer whose customer breaches. The plaintiff recovers the profit it would have made, measured by the contract price less the cost of performing, together with the labor and material it reasonably put into part performance to the extent they cannot be salvaged, and an allocated share of overhead such as management, plant, and power.14
Whether a failure ends the exchange depends on how badly it damages it. Restatement § 241 lists the circumstances that bear on whether a failure to render or offer performance is material.15 One is the extent to which the injured party will be deprived of the benefit she reasonably expected.16 Another is the extent to which she can be adequately compensated for the part of that benefit of which she will be deprived.17 The adequacy factor follows from what money can do. A buyer who receives no paper has lost the entire benefit, and only the full award described above replaces it. A deficiency that money repairs completely leaves most of the exchange intact, and the breach looks less like one that ends it.
Two errors recur. Students report the $600,000 replacement cost as the answer, which skips both the deduction for the $450,000 balance the buyer never pays and the return of her prepayment. And they call any breach that produces a large award a total breach, when the label turns on whether the exchange survives. The sequence that avoids both errors is to decide first whether the breach destroyed the exchange, asking how fully money can substitute for the lost benefit, and only then to price all remaining rights net of savings, with prepayments returned.
Partial Breach
Restatement § 236(2) defines the narrower claim: damages based on only part of the injured party's remaining rights to performance.19 The injured party's election after the breach decides which claim she has. One who terminates and refuses any further return performance claims for total breach; one who does not terminate and stands ready to render the remaining return performance claims for partial breach.20 The claim reaches only part of the bargain because the exchange is still alive. The injured party has received, or will still receive, the rest of what was promised, and the damages price the piece that came up short.
Two consequences follow, and each has its reason. The award covers the deficiency alone. A remedy that aims to leave the injured party where performance would have left her cannot hand her the performance and also its full value, and a court that priced the whole bargain whenever any part fell short would do exactly that.21 And whatever the breaching party has delivered, or is still owed, must be accounted for. A breaching party who has partly performed is normally entitled to a credit for the value of the part performance delivered.22 The damages are set off against any payment still due to the breacher, and only when no return performance is outstanding do they become a money judgment against her.23
The formula changes in the same way. A claim for total breach uses all four terms, but a claim for partial breach uses only the first two, loss in value and other loss. The two subtractions measure what a breach saves the injured party by freeing her from performing. A partial-breach claimant stands ready to render the remaining return performance,24 so the breach has saved her nothing. The set-off against the unpaid price does the accounting work that those subtractions do in a total-breach claim.
The loss in value of a deficient performance can be priced two ways, and the choice can decide the case. The usual measure is the cost of putting the injured party where full compliance would have: the cost of fixing defective work, the cost of finishing incomplete work, or the loss caused by delay.25 The cost-of-repair rules also apply in contract cases,26 where the cost to complete performance, whether to finish an unfinished building or to correct a defect in goods, offers an alternative to the value of full performance minus the value of the actual performance.27 An award of repair cost, plus incidental and ensuing losses, places the plaintiff in the position she would have occupied had no wrong been committed.28
The two measures part ways when correcting the defect costs far more than the defect is worth. In Jacob & Youngs v. Kent, a builder finished a house but installed pipe of a different manufacturer than the contract named, equal in quality to the specified brand. Replacing it would have meant tearing out finished walls, so the court limited the owner to the difference in value between the house as specified and as built, a difference of little or nothing. In a dental-crown case, a patient sued her dentist for fitting all-porcelain crowns instead of crowns of porcelain on gold. The court accepted that this was a breach, but the all-porcelain crowns cost no less and were therapeutically superior, and the breach was inadvertent. Replacement would have been unfairly disproportionate, so the court confined the patient to loss in value, and because she could show no actual injury she received nominal damages.29 That result fits the general rule that a party aggrieved by nonperformance is ordinarily entitled to some remedy, even if only nominal damages.30
On an exam, the classification comes first. If the injured party is keeping the performance and remains bound to pay for it, the answer prices the deficiency with loss in value and other loss, credits what has been delivered, and sets the result against the price still owing.