Concept
Direct and Consequential Loss
Causation and foreseeability
Direct and Consequential Loss
Section 351(1) of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts withholds damages for loss that the party in breach did not have reason to foresee as a probable result of the breach when the contract was made.1 The limit does not press equally on every dollar a plaintiff claims. It screens one category of loss and seldom matters for another, so the first step in any damages problem is to sort each claimed item into its category.
The sorting follows the line drawn in Hadley v. Baxendale. That rule allows damages that arise naturally from the breach, according to the usual course of things, or that both parties may reasonably be supposed to have contemplated at contracting as the probable result of a breach.2 In large part, the rule restates the difference between general and consequential damages. General damages are always recoverable, because they are the value of the very performance promised. Consequential damages may or may not be recoverable, depending on whether the risk of them was part of the basis of the bargain.3 Section 351(2) keeps the two routes: loss that follows in the ordinary course of events,4 and loss that follows from special circumstances, beyond the ordinary course, that the party in breach had reason to know.5
Sources label loss of the promised performance either direct or general, and loss that follows as a secondary result either consequential or special. This chapter says direct and consequential.
Direct Loss: The Value of the Promise
Direct damages compensate for the value the breach victim would have gained from the contract itself.6 They result directly from the breach, trace readily to it, and compensate for the very performance promised. Foreseeability is therefore seldom an issue. A party entering a contract understands, or should understand, that breach will cost the other side whatever benefit the contract promised, whether that benefit is a profit or the acquisition of services or property on advantageous terms.7 The breacher need not have foreseen the amount or the exact nature of the loss, so long as it reasonably should have understood that breach would cost the victim whatever value was reasonably expected.8
Three examples show the pattern. A feed supplier who fails to deliver owes the value of the feed, which a court may measure as the difference between the contract price and the market value.9 A contractor who fails to build to specification owes the cost of correcting the defect and conforming the building to the contract, and that general-damages award requires no special showing of foreseeability.10 A client whose coach breaches recovers the cost of hiring a substitute trainer, which does no more than stand in for the performance itself, and the same is true of the outlay and expected profit claimed under a breached construction or manufacturing contract.11 In each case the award goes no further than the confines of the contract.
Consequential Loss: What the Promise Would Have Produced
Consequential damages are claimed as a secondary consequence of the defendant's non-performance. They rest not on the value of the performance but on the value of some consequence that the performance may produce.12 If the supplier's default leaves the rancher's cattle to starve, or leaves them too thin to fatten before sale, the lost cattle and diminished profits are consequential. The construction case divides the same way. The repair cost is general, but profits lost because the building opened late are special, and they require that the contractor had reason to foresee them.13 Consequential damages reach losses beyond the actual deprivation of the contract benefit.14
That is why the foreseeability limit aims at this category. The question is whether the risk of the loss formed part of the basis of the parties' bargain.15 In a sale of goods the loss usually sits in the buyer's own affairs, and the UCC says so directly. Section 2-715(2)(a) includes among the buyer's consequential damages any loss resulting from general or particular requirements and needs of which the seller at the time of contracting had reason to know and which could not reasonably be prevented by cover or otherwise.16
The Line Moves With the Promise
Direct and consequential describe a loss only in relation to a particular promise, so the same kind of loss can fall on either side of the line in different contracts. Lost profits show this most clearly. Profit that a party would have made under the breached contract itself is direct.17 Profit lost in the party's dealings with others, outside the immediate transaction, is consequential.18
Delay losses show the same relativity. In the construction example, the owner's repair cost is direct, while profits lost to a late opening are special and require foreseeability.19 That result does not make delay loss consequential by nature. Direct loss is measured against the performance the contract promised.20 A contract whose promised performance itself covers the plaintiff's need for timing or use therefore puts the loss of that performance on the direct side. A contract silent on the plaintiff's plans leaves the resulting profits on the consequential side. Labeling a delay or lost-profit claim consequential by reflex skips the question the classification asks: what did this contract promise?
Lost Profits Recast as Market Value
The foreseeability limit applies to consequential damages, typically lost profits, and may not apply to other contract damages. By building foreseeability into its definition of consequential damages, the UCC implies that it does not affect other measures. When shortages drive the cover price to unusual levels, the seller cannot resist paying cover price minus contract price on grounds of foreseeability. The same logic may carry outside sales of goods: a homeowner who refuses to deliver a deed after prices skyrocket may owe market price at the time for delivery minus the contract price, although she had no reason to know that prices would rise so far.21 Because fair market value is assessed as of the date of delivery, it includes the profits likely at that time even if they were unforeseeable when the contract was formed. In this way, damages may shift from consequential losses to market losses.22
Profit calculations can therefore prove a direct loss. An apartment building's value consists primarily of the net rental income it will provide, not of some intrinsic value in the real estate. Sales of comparable buildings help estimate that value, but their prices also depend on estimates of the net income they will produce. To prove the value of the building, which is a direct loss, the plaintiff may start by proving expected profits, which are an ensuing loss. Reduced to present value, that stream of income is the value of the building.23
The buyer in that hypothetical must place each item in one category only. Leaving an item out of both undercompensates the plaintiff, and counting it in both overcompensates.24
Exclusion Clauses Make the Label Decisive
A contract clause that excludes consequential damages turns the label into the whole dispute. Much then depends on the court's inclination to characterize particular damages as direct, and so recoverable as general damages, or as indirect, and so unrecoverable as excluded consequential damages.25
A treatise illustration that cites Applied Data Processing, Inc. v. Burroughs Corp. makes the point concrete. The seller there had reason to know all the special facts before the contract was made, so the seller would likely have been liable for the buyer's consequential damages. Because the contract excluded liability for consequential damages, the buyer still could not recover the two items classified as consequential.26 Foreseeability and an exclusion clause are separate filters, so a loss can pass the first and fail the second.
Clauses that treat incidental and consequential damages differently add a second line to draw. Incidental damages normally arise when a buyer or seller repudiates the contract or wrongfully rejects goods, and the other side incurs expenses such as transporting, storing, or reselling them. Consequential damages arise outside the immediate buyer-seller transaction. They stem from the non-breaching party's dealings, often with third parties, and must have been reasonably foreseeable to the breacher at the time of contracting.27 A clause that excludes some elements of damages but not others makes it essential to define which items fall where.28