Concept
Certainty and Alternative Remedies
Certainty of damages
Certainty and Alternative Remedies
Reasonable certainty restricts one remedy, the award of money. Section 352 of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts denies damages for loss beyond the amount the evidence permits to be established with reasonable certainty.1 Comment c draws the consequence for equitable relief: the necessity of proving damages can be avoided if a decree of specific performance or an injunction is granted instead.2 A decree compels the promised performance or forbids the prohibited conduct, so a claimant who wins one never has to forecast what the performance would have been worth. The certainty rule polices damages and sets no comparable ceiling on a decree.
The availability of an equitable remedy does not bar damages, however. Comment c says that its availability does not preclude an award of damages as an alternative, but it may justify a court in requiring greater certainty of proof if damages are to be awarded.3 The comment does not spell out its reasoning, but the logic follows from what each remedy asks of the court. A decree gives the claimant the performance itself. An award of damages gives a sum in its place, and the sum is only as dependable as the evidence behind it. Where the court could deliver the performance, it has less reason to accept an approximation. The same idea appears among the factors courts consider in deciding whether lost profits were proved with reasonable certainty: whether there is an alternative method of compensating the injured party.4
Illustration 8 to comment c shows the effect on a long-term contract. A, a steel manufacturer, agrees to sell all of its scrap-steel output for five years to B, a scrap dealer, at a price fixed in terms of the market price. A repudiates at the end of the first year.5 Because the price tracks the market, B's profit depends largely on two variables: the amount of A's output and the cost of transporting the scrap to B's purchasers. Whether B recovers lost profits for the remaining four years therefore turns on whether B can prove those two figures with reasonable certainty. If B can prove them for only part of the four years, B recovers lost profits for that part.6 The illustration closes by noting that the availability of specific performance is a factor that will influence a court in requiring greater certainty.7
Two lessons follow from how the illustration is built. The first is that the certainty rule operates period by period. It excludes only those elements of loss that cannot be proved with reasonable certainty, and here the elements are slices of time: proof of output and costs that holds up for the nearer years supports recovery for those years, while the later years, for which the evidence runs out, drop away.8 The second is that the damages claim sits beside a remedy that would make the forecast unnecessary. Because specific performance is available, B could ask the court to order A to keep delivering scrap, and no one would have to predict A's output at all. A court asked instead to award four years of profit is being asked to estimate what a decree could simply supply, and the comment treats that as a reason to insist on firmer evidence.
Van Wagner Advertising Corp. v. S & M Enterprises shows the same relationship from the defendant's side. Van Wagner claimed damages for S & M's breach of a lease of billboard space, and S & M had successfully resisted specific performance on the ground that there is an adequate remedy at law.9 S & M then argued that damages beyond 60 days must be denied as conjectural. The court rejected the argument for two reasons. First, where the value of commercial billboard space can be readily determined by comparison with similar uses, and Van Wagner itself had more than 400 leases, the value of the space between 1985 and 1992 could not be regarded as speculative.10 Second, S & M "cannot at the same time be heard to contend that damages beyond 60 days must be denied because they are conjectural."11 If damages for breach of the lease were indeed conjectural and could not be calculated with reasonable certainty, the court added, S & M should be compelled to perform its contractual obligation by restoring the tenant to the premises.12
The two arguments cannot be reconciled. Calling damages an adequate remedy presupposes that the loss can be measured, and calling them too conjectural to award denies that it can. A defendant may not choose whichever position suits the stage of the case, and if the second position were true, the court's answer was performance, not a recovery of zero.
A failed damages claim does not necessarily end the case. The certainty rule limits awards of money and does not itself bar a decree, so a claimant whose profit evidence collapses may still seek specific performance or an injunction, subject to the other requirements for equitable relief. A defendant who resists a decree by calling damages adequate has also committed to the position that the loss can be measured, and a later claim that it cannot be measured hands the claimant its best argument for the decree. Where a decree is available but the claimant asks for damages, the court may demand firmer proof, and partial proof supports a partial award.