Concept
Certainty Beside Related Limits
Certainty of damages
Certainty Beside Related Limits
Reasonable certainty is one of five limits that stand between a breach and an expectation award, and it is easiest to understand beside the other four: foreseeability, mitigation, causation, and unfair forfeiture. Although called limitations, these factors are for the most part not external checks on damages but expressions of principles inherent in the goal of compensating for the loss of reasonable expectations.1 The Restatement's version of the certainty limit is that damages are not recoverable for loss beyond an amount that the evidence permits to be established with reasonable certainty.2
Each limit guards a different interest. Foreseeability keeps the extent and scope of damages consistent with what the parties reasonably contemplated at the time of contracting. Mitigation protects the breacher from the breach victim's unreasonable failure to control or curtail the harm: a wrongfully discharged employee recovers the agreed salary less what the employer proves the employee earned or with reasonable effort might have earned elsewhere, but the employer must show that the alternative work was comparable or substantially similar before the employee's failure to seek it can reduce the recovery.3 Causation restricts damages to losses that can be linked to the breach. Reasonable certainty places on the breach victim the burden of proving, by a preponderance of the evidence, both the fact and the extent of the loss. The doctrine of unfair forfeiture completes the group.4
Because the interests differ, a claim can pass one limit and fail another, and evidence that satisfies one does nothing for the next. The sales cases state the cumulative nature of the test plainly: a buyer seeking consequential damages must establish causation, foreseeability, reasonable certainty as to amount, and that mitigation doctrines do not bar the recovery.5 The two comparisons below take the neighbors most often confused with certainty. Foreseeability looks back to what the breacher knew at formation, and causation asks whether the breach produced the loss at all.
Foreseeability Compared
Foreseeability and certainty do their heaviest work on the same claims, which is why they are so often run together. The Restatement calls the requirement of certainty distinct from foreseeability but similar in impact, because the main impact of certainty comes in connection with recovery for lost profits.6 The two limits nevertheless ask different questions, at different moments, about different parties.
Foreseeability looks back to the moment the contract was made. Recovery is limited to losses that were a probable result of the breach, and a mere possibility that such losses might result does not satisfy the requirement.7 A loss qualifies in either of two ways: the breacher should reasonably have expected it as a likely consequence of breach in the ordinary course of events, or, outside the ordinary course, the breacher had information from which it had reason to know of special circumstances that could reasonably give rise to it.8 The timing protects the parties' ability to bargain. A defendant need not bargain over every remote possibility, but if the loss was a probable consequence the defendant should either bargain over it or pay for it, and if the loss was remote the plaintiff should raise it during negotiations or accept the risk.9 Disclosure therefore matters: once the plaintiff has mentioned the loss, a defendant will have difficulty persuading a court that it was unforeseeable merely because it was not inevitable.10
What must have been foreseeable is the kind of loss, not its exact amount or precise form. Foreseeability is not usually an issue in a claim for direct damages, because a party entering a contract should understand that breach will cost the other side whatever benefit was promised, and the breacher need not have foreseen the amount or exact nature of that loss.11 Certainty has no comparable exemption, and it applies to damages based on the reliance interest as well as the expectation interest.12 The first limit therefore turns on what the breacher knew at formation, while the second turns on what the claimant can prove at trial, and neither supplies what the other demands. Damages not within the parties' contemplation, or not communicated to the breacher so that it was on notice at the time of contracting, are not recoverable even when clearly proven.13
Hadley v. Baxendale shows a claim stopped at the first limit. A mill was shut down pending replacement of a shaft, the carrier misdirected the shaft and so delayed the replacement, and the claim for the mill's lost profits failed because those profits were not foreseeable.14 Because the claim died on foreseeability, it did not matter how well the mill could have documented its daily profit. The question was whether the carrier could fairly be held to a loss it had no reason to bargain over.
The Restatement's drive-in theatre illustration shows the opposite failure. A seller breaches a contract to sell land on which the buyer planned an outdoor drive-in theatre, and the theatre is never built. The illustration places the difficulty in proof: because the enterprise was new and speculative, the buyer's lost profit cannot be estimated with reasonable certainty, so recovery is limited to expenses incurred in reliance or, if none can be proved with reasonable certainty, to nominal damages.15 A finding that a loss was foreseeable clears only the first gate, because the claimant must still prove it.
A claim can fail at both gates, as the lost-profit claim did in Kenford Co. v. County of Erie. The court reviewed an award of $25.6 million in lost profits under a 20-year management contract and held the damages unrecoverable on a twofold basis: the county's liability for those profits was not in the contemplation of the parties when the contract was executed, and the damages were too speculative to satisfy the requirement of proof with reasonable certainty.16 The first ground addresses what the parties contemplated at formation and the second addresses the quality of the proof, so a claimant who answers one must still answer the other.
On an exam, the missing fact usually tells you which limit is in play. A stem that supplies audited records of the loss but says nothing about what the defendant was told at signing points toward foreseeability, and a stem that shows the defendant knew every detail of the claimant's plans but offers only a hopeful projection of profit points toward certainty. Consequential claims face both limits, whereas a claim for the value of the promised performance itself seldom raises foreseeability yet must still be proved.19
Causation Compared
Causation asks whether the breach produced the loss, while certainty asks whether the claimant can prove the loss, and a claim can fail on either. A breacher cannot be accountable for loss that was not caused by its breach, so the claimant must show a link between the breach and the loss.21 The inquiry concerns attribution rather than proof of amount, which is why it can defeat a claim even when the figure is beyond dispute.
Contract law gives causation less separate attention than tort law does, because the link is usually self-evident and its work can largely be accommodated within foreseeability, mitigation, and certainty. The treatise nonetheless finds it worth articulating as a distinct limitation on relief.22 When direct damages are claimed, causation is not usually an issue: unless the breach victim has broken the chain of causation by aggravating the damages, there is invariably a clear link between the breach and the loss of the contractual bargain. Consequential damages are by definition more remotely connected to the breach, so a claimant who seeks them must establish that they were in fact a consequence of it.23
One body of evidence often serves both inquiries. In the Restatement's plastic illustration, a wholesaler resells defective plastic and receives complaints from dealers, some of whom refuse to place further orders. The dealers' complaints and refusals tie the lost business to the defect, and the wholesaler's business records before and after the transaction, along with testimony from its salespersons and from dealers, can fix the loss of good will with reasonable certainty.24 The amount need not be calculable with mathematical accuracy, and doubts are generally resolved against the breacher where it is established that a significant loss has occurred.25 That rule presupposes an established loss. It does not make a breacher answer for harm that its breach did not produce.
Speculative opportunities show how the inquiries overlap. A claimant who says a breach cost a competition, and with it a career, faces many unknowns about whether the breach changed the result and about how the opportunities that winning might bring would have been exploited. The treatise observes that even a strong likelihood of success in the competition would leave too many unknowns that could affect successful exploitation of the opportunities it might present.26 It adds that such problems may be described in terms of mitigation, foreseeability, or reasonable certainty, but that causation is also present in the inquiry and is a useful adjunct in analyzing liability and justifying the result.27
The sales formulation confirms that these are separate requirements. It lists causation first among the four things a buyer must establish to recover consequential damages, alongside foreseeability, reasonable certainty as to amount, and the absence of a mitigation bar.28 When you analyze a problem, ask causation first. If the facts leave other explanations for the loss open, or show customers or events that had nothing to do with the breach, the problem is causation, and no showing about the amount repairs it. If the facts show that the breach clearly cost the claimant something and the dispute is over size, the problem is certainty, and the claimant recovers what the evidence supports.