Concept
Unsuccessful Efforts and Costs
Avoidable consequences and mitigation of damages
Unsuccessful Efforts and Costs
A plaintiff who makes reasonable efforts to avoid loss and fails does not lose recovery for that loss. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 350(2) says so directly: the injured party is not precluded from recovery by the avoidable-loss rule of § 350(1) to the extent that the party has made reasonable but unsuccessful efforts to avoid loss.1 Consider a wrongfully discharged employee who searches reasonably for a new job and finds none. She recovers the full salary her employer would have paid, plus the cost of the search.2 Courts reach that result by concluding that, because her reasonable efforts failed, reasonable efforts would not have prevented the loss.3
The question for a court is therefore never whether the efforts worked. It is whether the efforts were reasonable, the standard the preceding sections developed. When they were, the defendant receives no reduction for the loss that remained.
Section 350(2) works on step two. When the plaintiff's reasonable effort failed, no credit arises there, because reasonable effort would not have avoided the loss. Steps three and four both concern money the plaintiff spends, and each rests on its own reasoning.
Avoided losses are not recoverable, but the cost of avoiding a loss is. The discharged employee's résumé printing, postage, and cab fare to interviews would not have been incurred but for the employer's wrong, so the employer pays them; these expenses might be called incidental damages.5 Funds spent in a reasonable effort to minimize damages are recoverable under the third rule as a form of consequential damages. The key requirement is reasonableness, so recovery is appropriate even if the effort failed and even if the costs outran the savings.6 The expenses of seeking reasonable substitute employment enter the award of compensatory damages only if proven to result distinctly from the harm and not merely as an inconvenience or annoyance.7
Partial success earns the same protection. In Waters v. Massey-Ferguson, Inc., a defective tractor failed and the farmer hired the neighbors to plant soybeans. The delay left the crop yield low, so the substitute planting was not a fully effective mitigation. The court nonetheless awarded consequential damages in recognition of the farmer's attempt to mitigate.8 That result illustrates the second paragraph of Restatement § 350, and a party relying on U.C.C. § 2-715(2) can draw on the comments, examples, and cases cited under § 350 to support the same result.
Step four rests on arithmetic. Suppose a plaintiff actually earned $50 after the defendant's wrong, and reasonable effort would have earned $350 more, but only with $80 of substitute transportation. The first rule credits the defendant with the $50 actually earned, and the second credits the $350 the plaintiff should reasonably have earned. That second credit is itself reduced, because the plaintiff would have had to spend $80 to earn the $350. The defendant's real gain from proper avoidance is $270, and the reduction stops there.9
A plaintiff who skips an obvious step shows the other side of the rule. One farmer could afford to repair a pipe but declined to pay while waiting for the fencing company to admit liability. The court awarded the cost of repairing the pipe but excluded the lost crop, reasoning that the farmer could reasonably have paid a modest sum for the repairs and so avoided the much greater loss of the crop.10 Compare that farmer with the discharged employee. When reasonable effort was made and failed, the defendant owes the full loss plus the cost of trying. When no effort was made and a modest, reasonable one would have worked, the defendant owes only what the effort would have cost.