Concept
Limits on Reformation
Reformation
Limits on Reformation
Proving a prior agreement, a variance, and a shared mistake does not guarantee a decree. Two kinds of limit remain, and each protects someone other than the claimant. The first shields outsiders who dealt with the writing as the record presented it. The second follows from the equitable character of the remedy: the usual defenses to equitable relief stay open even when every element is proved.
Neither limit questions whether the writing is wrong. Each asks whether correcting it now would be fair. The next subsection takes up purchasers; the one after it turns to the defenses that any equitable remedy meets.
Good Faith Purchasers
Section 155 of the Restatement (Second) of Contracts lets a court reform a writing “except to the extent that rights of third parties such as good faith purchasers for value will be unfairly affected.”1 The words “to the extent” make the limit proportional: a court withholds correction only as far as it would burden the third party. Everything in the earlier sections concerned the two people who made the deal. This clause concerns someone who arrives later, deals with the property as the record presents it, and would lose something if the record were rewritten afterward. Courts apply the same limit when they refuse reformation whose effect would be to curtail the rights of a bona fide purchaser for value or others who have relied on the record.2
A bona fide purchaser for value acquires an interest by purchase, pays value for it, and takes without notice of the claim against it. Each part of that label excludes some takers. A party who acquires an interest by levy or attachment is not a purchaser. A purchaser who has notice of the claimant's rights is not in good faith. A donee gave no value. Donees and takers with notice are the standard examples of those who cannot count as bona fide purchasers.3
Reformation of an instrument is a purely equitable remedy, and purely equitable remedies do not lie to recover property, or an interest in it, from a bona fide purchaser for value who took legal title without notice of the plaintiff's claim. A constructive trust, an equitable lien, and subrogation share that limit.4 The reason begins with what a reformation claimant holds: an equity, a right to have a document corrected. The purchaser holds legal title and relied on the record as it stood. If reformation could reach such a purchaser, anyone buying on the strength of an instrument would risk losing the purchase to a mistake buried in an earlier link of the chain, so the law leaves the loss with the parties who made the mistake. Notice and value matter because the protection rests on the purchaser's reliance. A taker who knew of the claim has no equity to protect, and a taker who paid nothing has given up nothing in reliance. For that reason equitable remedies do take precedence over later takers who fail to qualify as bona fide purchasers.5
Gifts cut both ways in this doctrine. A donee who receives property through a mistaken deed takes it subject to the claimant's right, because a donee is not a bona fide purchaser.6 Yet reformation ordinarily will not be given against a donor of a gratuitous conveyance or other instrument of gift, so a donee cannot use reformation to enlarge what the donor chose to give.7
The same limit applies when the later taker is an assignee. If the assignee is a bona fide purchaser for value, the obligor's right to reformation is lost under general equitable principles.8 That is the § 155 exception applied to a contract right instead of a deed.
Reformation of a deed relates back to the time of the mistaken deed, and it has been held that this gives the corrected deed priority over intervening liens.9 The two rules fit together. A creditor whose lien arose by levy or attachment did not acquire the interest by purchase, so that creditor cannot claim the purchaser's protection.10 Among later claimants, then, the outcome turns on how each obtained the interest and what each gave and knew, and not merely on who came later.
The usual exam error is to treat every later owner as protected merely because the owner holds title. Protection depends on what the later owner gave and knew, so a donee and a buyer with notice both remain exposed to the claim even though each holds legal title.
Equitable Defenses
The purchaser limit protects outsiders. The equitable defenses concern the parties themselves: what the claimant did after the mistake, whether the claimant dealt honestly, and whether correcting the writing now would hurt the other side more than the original error did. Section 155 frames the remedy in permissive terms, saying the court “may at the request of a party reform the writing to express the agreement,”12 and the permissive verb fits the remedy's equitable character. Since reformation is an equitable remedy, defenses such as unclean hands and laches apply even after the claimant has proved the prior agreement, the variance, and the shared mistake, and the court may attach to its decree whatever conditions it deems equitable.13
The flexibility has a reason. Reformation rewrites a signed document on proof of an earlier understanding, so the claimant asks the court to set aside the ordinary effect of a signature. A court asked to do that can fairly insist that the claimant come promptly and honestly and that the decree leave no one worse off than the error did. These defenses do not turn on carelessness. On the weight of authority, negligence in failing to catch the error is no bar to reformation unless it has in some way harmed the other, non-negligent, party.14 The defenses here look instead to what happened after the mistake, to the claimant's own wrongdoing, and to the other side's reliance.
Ratification ends the right to reformation, as it ends the right to avoid a contract for mistake.15 A claimant who learns of the mistake and then affirms the writing has told the other side, by conduct, that the writing is acceptable, and the other side may rely on that message. Knowledge is essential, because a claimant who has not yet found the error cannot have affirmed it.16 Laches reaches delay that involves no affirming act: a claimant who knows of the error and waits unreasonably long before seeking relief loses the remedy.17 Delay is costly because the other party keeps building on the writing in the meantime.
Unclean hands bars a claimant whose own conduct in the transaction was dishonest, because equity will not lend its power to someone who asks for fairness after dealing unfairly.18 A claimant who misled the other side in negotiating the deal, for example, can lose the court's help even though the writing really does misstate the agreement.
Change of position by the other side looks to the defendant's reliance, not to the claimant's conduct. If an insurer mistakenly calculates annuity payments in the annuitant's favor, reformation can cure the mistake provided the annuitant has not reasonably changed position in reliance on the miscalculation.19 An annuitant who has relied on nothing holds only an unspent windfall, and correction takes away nothing on which the annuitant built. An annuitant who took on a commitment that depended on the larger payments would be worse off after correction than if the policy had been accurate from the start, because correction would charge that annuitant with a loss that traces to the insurer's own error. The change of position must be a genuine detriment. In the parallel setting of a mistaken overpayment, a payee who used the money to pay off the mortgage on her house had not changed position detrimentally, because her net worth rose with the payment. Merely spending the money may not show detriment where the expenditure would have been made from other funds anyway.20
Equity's flexibility also lets a court refuse relief that would itself be unjust. In one insurance case a policy carried an incorrect valuation of the insured property, and the court held that reforming the policy and returning the excess premiums would be inequitable. Its reasoning was that if a loss had occurred before the incorrect valuation was discovered, the company would have paid the insured value.21 The court looked at the transaction as a whole. Until the mistake surfaced, the insured had enjoyed protection at the stated value, and correcting the figure afterward would let the insured keep that protection while recovering part of its price.
The first two steps depend on what the claimant knew and when, so the date of discovery is the fact to look for in a problem. A claimant who proves every element and acts promptly and honestly can still lose where the other side has reasonably relied on the writing and correction would impose that loss on someone who did nothing wrong.