Concept
Nontraditional Reformation
Reformation
Nontraditional Reformation
Traditional reformation repairs a document. Suppose you and Alice agree on a price of $127, but you make an arithmetical error when you write up the deal, the contract says $37, and Alice insists on holding you to it. Contract law seeks to enforce the contract the parties intended to make, not the one that results from a failure to record the terms correctly on paper, so you can ask the court to reform the writing to state the true price.1 The Restatement (Second) of Contracts frames the rule the same way. When a writing fails to express the parties' agreement because both were mistaken about its contents or effect, the court may reform it to express the agreement, except to the extent that doing so would unfairly affect the rights of third parties such as good faith purchasers for value.2
A smaller group of decisions uses the same word for a different job. In relatively rare cases, a court keeps a contract in force and adjusts its terms to counter the effect of a mistake, and in that setting the remedy is also called reformation, although the usual reformation case involves no mistake of fact at all, only an error in recording the terms.3 Other adjustments carry the label too. Some courts cut the price when land proves smaller than promised. Within limits, some unconscionable provisions are reformed to meet minimum legal standards. Insurance policies are in effect “reformed” to meet the insured's expectations, and judicial adjustment for unexpected conditions in long-term contracts is not unheard of. All of these forms of nontraditional reformation have generated controversy. They are remedial, in that they try to make the best of a bad situation, but they are not fundamentally restitutionary.4
One question sorts these decisions: does the court correct a record of the parties' agreement, or does it adjust the bargain itself? The sections below put that question to each.
The Alcoa Price Adjustment
Aluminum Co. of America v. Essex Group, Inc., 499 F. Supp. 53 (W.D. Pa. 1980), is one of the most controversial decisions dealing with changed circumstances.5 Late in 1967, after more than six years of negotiations, ALCOA contracted with Essex to convert Essex's alumina into molten aluminum by a smelting process.6 In an opinion of some forty pages, the trial court found that although ALCOA had sought a profit of four cents per pound, the parties had foreseen that the profit might vary either way, between one cent and seven cents per pound. It then reformed the price term so that ALCOA would earn not less than one cent per pound (unless the 65% cap should be less). The case was settled while on appeal.7
The one-cent floor sits at the bottom of the range the court said the parties had foreseen, yet the remedy is not the one traditional reformation supplies. The court adjusted a price term in light of changed circumstances; it did not correct a document that misrecorded the deal.
The standard objection to relief of this kind begins with what counts as a mistake. Professor Palmer put it this way: “In a lay sense the word ‘mistake’ is commonly used to describe an erroneous prediction of the future course of events, but this is not mistake in the legal sense. If any relief from the terms of a contract is available in such circumstances, it must be in accordance with contract doctrines relating to impossibility, impracticability, or frustration of purpose.”8 The parties can also settle the question in advance. Sale-of-goods contracts often contain force majeure clauses that allocate the risk that performance will be impossible or impracticable, or that its value will be frustrated, and such terms can enter the agreement by express agreement under U.C.C. § 1-302(a) or through usage of trade, course of dealing, and course of performance under § 1-303.9 The controversy over the Alcoa decision is therefore a dispute over which body of doctrine governs: reformation, mistake, or the excuse doctrines of impossibility, impracticability, and frustration.10
Because the case settled on appeal, the trial court's reasoning never received appellate review. Cite it as an example of the nontraditional approach, not as a statement of the general rule.
Abatement and Illegality
A mistake too small to justify rescission can still support a price adjustment when a fair and equitable method exists. Suppose a buyer and seller negotiate for a commercial lot at $6 per square foot and sign a $600,000 contract on the mistaken belief that the lot contains 100,000 square feet. It contains 97,000. The shortfall may not be material enough to rescind, but the court can reform the contract by reducing the price by $18,000, an adjustment sometimes called abatement.11 The parties negotiated on a per-square-foot basis, so the court has a method: it applies their own rate to the area that exists.
The same arithmetic works for land sold by the acre. If Blackacre is sold at $1,000 per acre for a total of $100,000 and contains only 90 acres, some courts might require the seller to accept $90,000. That result is likely to go under the name of specific performance with abatement, but it reforms the parties' contract, quite possibly in a way that does not match what they intended.12
Two other uses of the label measure the contract against a standard outside the parties' agreement. Within limits, some unconscionable provisions may be reformed to bring them within minimum legal standards of fairness, or to make them conform to rules against restraints on trade. That is reformation to meet a legal standard, not to meet the parties' intent. In insurance, a doctrine in effect reads policies to meet the insureds' reasonable expectations, which may arise from brochures or other representations despite printed policy provisions to the contrary, and the effect is similar to reformation.13
Illegality raises a related problem for the party who did nothing wrong. Even if an agreement is illegal, a party may in some situations recover for breach of an illegal executory bilateral contract. One such situation arises when a party enters the bargain justifiably ignorant of the facts that create the illegality and the other party is not. The innocent party may then recover on the contract by showing a readiness, willingness, and ability to perform but for the illegality.14 The standard illustration is a married man who promises to marry another woman; if she did not know he was married, she is the innocent party. This is relief on the contract itself, not a rewriting of it, but like the adjustments above it departs from the usual consequence to protect a party who bears no fault, and it turns on that party's position, not on any recording error.
The Nigeria Cement Case
In the Nigerian cement litigation, hardship appears to have driven the result. Nigeria renegotiated contracts to alleviate some of the ruin threatened by the payments the original contracts imposed. National American Corp. (NAC), a supplier under the original contract, signed a new contract fixing a price for its twelve shiploads of cement plus a reduced figure for delay time. That contract rested on an error: NAC had not dispatched twelve ships, was still loading half of them in New York, and had put only six into Nigerian territorial waters.15
The error lay in the premise of the bargain, how many ships had been dispatched, and not in the way a writing recorded an agreement. Reformation is more commonly used where the parties have made an error in recording their terms, and not a mistake of fact.16 The hardship on one side and the seeming inequity on the other suggest that the court used reformation in a non-traditional way. If so, the use is very non-traditional indeed, because hardship ordinarily serves to deny or limit a remedy, and here it supported affirmative relief.17 A court willing to adjust terms to deal with a disastrous mistake that could ruin a small emerging nation has not necessarily shown the same willingness to give private parties relief in more ordinary business situations.18
Each of these decisions measures the contract against something other than an earlier agreement the writing failed to record. The ALCOA court looked to the profit range it found the parties had foreseen. The abatement cases apply the parties' own unit price to the quantity that exists. The unconscionability and insurance doctrines look to a legal standard or the insured's expectations, and the Nigeria decision seems to rest on hardship. On an exam, first ask whether a writing misrecords an agreement. If it does not, treat any adjustment of terms as a controversial exception and identify what it actually rests on.