Concept
Reliance Interest Defined
Reliance interest
Reliance Damages
Reliance Interest Defined
The reliance interest is a promisee's interest in being reimbursed for loss caused by reliance on the contract, by being put in as good a position as the promisee would have occupied had the contract not been made.1 Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 344(b) lists it beside two other interests a judicial remedy for breach may protect: the expectation interest and the restitution interest. The three differ chiefly in the reference point each uses to decide how much money the promisee receives, and the reliance reference point is a world in which the promise was never made. A promisee who trusted the promise may have spent money in preparing to perform, and a breach strands that outlay. Reliance damages reimburse those expenses, among other losses caused by reliance.2
The expectation interest uses a different baseline, and the contrast is the quickest way to see what reliance does. Under § 344(a), the expectation interest is the promisee's interest in having the benefit of the bargain, measured from the position the promisee would have occupied had the contract been performed.3 Expectation asks what performance would have delivered; reliance asks what trusting the promise has cost. Reliance therefore ignores lost profit. It returns the promisee to the starting line and adds none of the gain the bargain promised, so it is ordinarily less generous than expectation.4
The reliance baseline has a rationale rooted in the voluntary nature of contract. Unlike tort duties, which society imposes on everyone, contractual duties are voluntary, and people may refuse to make a promise at all. It therefore makes sense to ask where the plaintiff would have stood had the promise never been made. In that world the plaintiff would have enjoyed none of the contract's benefits but would also have incurred none of its expenses.5
Reliance reaches beyond cash paid out, because a promisee can lose by giving something up as well as by spending something. A buyer under a contract for the sale of land illustrates both kinds of loss. The buyer may pay to investigate the seller's title, or may neglect the opportunity to enter other contracts, and a court may award damages to undo the harm that reliance has caused.6 The value of opportunities forgone because of the contract is an opportunity cost, and an opportunity cost is a reliance cost. A worker who rejects one full-time job offer to accept a different full-time position has incurred one.7 The sections that follow take up which of these losses a court will actually award.
The third interest in § 344, the restitution interest, looks to the benefit the promisee conferred on the promisor rather than to the promisee's own loss, and it concerns only that aspect of reliance which benefits the promisor.8 It overlaps with reliance wherever the plaintiff's outlays also enriched the defendant, which is why a reliance recovery ordinarily includes the restitution interest as a subspecies.9 In the television example, the $200 deposit is both a reliance loss to the buyer and a benefit in the seller's hands. The courier's $50 is a reliance loss alone, because it conferred no benefit on the promisor and so falls outside restitution.10
Because reliance ignores profit, it is most useful when the plaintiff cannot prove how much profit the contract would have earned. Instead of recovering nothing, the plaintiff recovers expenses, which produces a profit of zero and no loss. A profit of zero seems as good an assumption as a loss, absent evidence to the contrary, and the recovery puts the plaintiff as close to expectation as the evidence allows.11 Section 349 writes this alternative into the Restatement: the injured party may recover reliance damages, including expenditures made in preparation for performance or in performance, less any loss the breaching party can prove with reasonable certainty the injured party would have suffered had the contract been performed.12 The subtraction matters because, in theory, reliance would exceed expectation whenever the contract would have lost money. Once the court subtracts a proven loss, a reliance award in a losing contract cannot exceed the expectation interest. That ceiling suggests reliance is less a separate remedial interest than an effort to approximate expectation when technical difficulties make expectation unavailable, an approach the Restatement (Third) of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment § 38 endorses.13