Concept
Computing the Award
Reliance interest
Computing the Award
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 349 supplies the formula that every earlier section of this chapter feeds. The injured party recovers damages based on the reliance interest, including expenditures made in preparation for performance or in performance, less any loss the party in breach can prove with reasonable certainty the injured party would have suffered had the contract been performed.1
The formula works best as a ledger. Reliance puts the plaintiff back in the position occupied just before the parties made the agreement, compensating the detriments suffered in reliance on it.2 The plaintiff's position now equals that starting point, less everything spent or given up, plus whatever has since come back through salvage, resale, or the defendant's payments. The award is the gap between the two. Each deduction removes a dollar that the plaintiff already has back or would never have kept, so a plaintiff who collects the gross outlay is paid twice for the same money.
A claim for the plaintiff's gross outlay, with no credit for what has come back, fails at the third step. In one reported decision, the plaintiff bought three tanks, storage drums, demineralizing equipment, a pump, and an air compressor for $3,418.15 in anticipation of a valid contract, and the court treated these as reasonable expenditures made in a fair endeavor to perform. The tanks had since been sold for $700, so the court awarded $2,718.15.3 The $700 was already in the plaintiff's hands, and awarding it again would have put the plaintiff ahead of the starting position.
The same logic governs property the plaintiff has not resold but still holds. In Walser v. Toyota Motor Sales, U.S.A., Inc., a promissory estoppel case of the kind taken up in the next section, the plaintiffs paid $676,864 for land in reliance on Toyota's promise and conceded at trial that the land was still worth at least $550,000. The appellate court found no error in an instruction defining their out-of-pocket expenses as the difference between the property's actual value and the price paid, because that difference measures the damage from relying on the promise. Their loss was therefore no more than $126,864, since the land itself remained an asset.
The defendant's own payments and the plaintiff's leftover materials form a second class of deductions. One formulation, quoted in a judicial opinion, directs that installments of the contract price already received, and the value of materials on hand that would have been consumed in completion, must be deducted.4 The first deduction credits money the defendant has already paid. The second credits materials the plaintiff still holds, which are salvage under another name. A plaintiff who spent $50,000 and collected a $12,000 installment is out of pocket $38,000, because reliance reimburses a loss and the installment was never lost.
The fourth step differs in kind from the first three. Salvage and payments reduce the loss by money that has actually come back, while the offset reduces it by money that would never have come back even if the defendant had performed. A plaintiff whose contract would have left it below the starting point cannot use the reliance baseline to erase that shortfall, so in a losing contract a reliance award cannot exceed what expectation would have produced.5 The breaching party must prove the shortfall with reasonable certainty, so the step removes only what has been proved.
The contrast with expectation shows why the reliance figure has to be computed separately. Expectation aims at the plaintiff's net expectation, which is the value of the performance the defendant promised less the cost of the performance the plaintiff promised in return.6 Reliance aims lower, at break-even, which means no profit and no loss unless the defendant proves one.7 That is why reliance is the plaintiff's usual fall-back when lost profits cannot be proved.8 The limit on losing contracts suggests that reliance is less a separate interest than an effort to approximate expectation when technical difficulties make expectation unavailable.9
One set of facts separates the three measures. A seller agrees to deliver a copy of the Restatement tomorrow in exchange for $10 and a photocopy of the buyer's class notes. The book has a market value of $15, the notes are worth $1 to the seller, and copying them costs the buyer $3. The buyer pays the $10 and hands over the copy, and the seller then refuses to deliver the book or return anything. The measures come out as follows:
- Restitution looks to the benefit the seller received, which is the $10 plus the notes' $1 market value, so the figure is $11.
- Reliance reimburses the cost of trusting the promise, which is the $10 paid plus the $3 spent copying, so the figure is $13, with nothing subtracted because the buyer has recouped nothing and received nothing back.
- Expectation awards the value of the promised book, $15, with no deduction for the buyer's own side of the deal, because that side is complete.
The three figures differ for identifiable reasons. Reliance falls $2 short of expectation because it leaves out the profit the bargain promised: the buyer would have given up $13 in cost to receive a book worth $15. Reliance exceeds restitution by $2 because relying cost the buyer $3 in copying but gave the seller only $1 of value.
Now set the book's market value at $9 and leave every other fact unchanged. Performance would have left the buyer $4 behind, because the buyer would have given up $13 in cost for a book worth $9. If the seller proves that shortfall with reasonable certainty, the fourth step reduces the $13 claim by $4, and the buyer recovers $9. Expectation is also $9, so the two measures converge only because the offset forced reliance down to meet expectation. Restitution stays at $11, because the benefit the seller received does not depend on the book's market value.
When a problem hands you receipts together with a resale price, a payment history, or a cost forecast, each of those figures belongs to a specific step, and the usual error is to stop after totaling the receipts. A reliance figure need not equal the expectation or the restitution figure. It is correct when it records the plaintiff's actual net loss and nothing more.