Concept
Defining the Restitution Interest
Restitution interest
The Restitution Interest
Defining the Restitution Interest
A promisee who sues over a broken deal may be asking for any of three different things, and the remedy changes with the request. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 344 lists the interests that judicial remedies protect and recognizes that a single remedy may protect more than one.1 The expectation interest is the interest in the benefit of the bargain: the promisee is put in as good a position as performance would have produced.2 The reliance interest covers the detriment the promisee incurred by changing position.3 The restitution interest, the subject of this chapter, is the interest in having restored any benefit the promisee conferred on the other party.4
The three definitions point in different directions. Expectation and reliance begin with the claimant and ask what the claimant hoped to gain or what the claimant gave up. Restitution begins with the other party and asks what that party received.5 The difference matters most when the claimant has little to claim under the other two interests. A claimant who paid money under a deal that collapsed may have no profit to recover, and the bargain may even have been a bad one, yet the other party may still hold value the claimant supplied. Each interest calls for its own yardstick, so a court, like a student answering an essay question, must decide which interest is in play before measuring anything.
The first subsection below explains why the law returns a benefit to the person who conferred it. The second sets restitution beside expectation and reliance, so that you can tell which interest each item of a claim belongs to.
Preventing Unjust Enrichment
Restitution begins with a simple picture: one party hands over something of value under a deal, the deal fails, and the other party keeps what was handed over. The law's answer is that a party who has received a benefit that in equity and good conscience should not be retained must not retain it. That is the policy of preventing unjust enrichment.6
Because restitution undoes a transfer, it measures the recipient's gain, not the claimant's loss.7 The two figures often match, and when they do the choice between them hardly matters. They can diverge, and the divergence shows what the interest is for. Suppose a defendant misappropriates $1,000 that the plaintiff had hidden in a mattress and invests it in stock the plaintiff would never have bought. The shares rise until they are worth $2,000. The plaintiff lost $1,000, and the defendant gained $2,000. Compensatory damages for conversion would be $1,000, while restitution reaches $2,000.8 Contract disputes seldom produce a windfall that large, but the same orientation governs every restitution problem in this chapter: ask what the other party now has.
The recipient need not have done anything wrong. Entitlement turns on whether keeping the benefit would be unjust, so an honest party who received value under an exchange that later failed must still return it, and money paid to the wrong party by mistake can be recovered for the same reason.9 Nor must the benefit be something that can be handed back. Services qualify, and the law holds the recipient responsible for their reasonable value.10
Restitution has little to offer when the recipient never asked for the benefit and has no reason to pay for it. An innocent party keeps the freedom to refuse benefits rather than be forced into an exchange, and a party who confers a benefit gratuitously cannot later call the recipient's gain unjust.11 Birchwood Land Co. v. Krizan applied the point to facts like these: a landowner improved its own property by building road access and extending utilities, a neighbor's previously landlocked parcel gained value as a side effect, and the court denied the landowner's restitution claim because the benefits were incidental and unrequested. Homeowner's position is the opposite. She bargained for the painting, so the only thing that failed was the exchange.
A second limit comes from the contract itself. While a valid contract defines the parties' obligations, its terms displace any inquiry into unjust enrichment. Restitution enters when the exchange fails: when the contract is unenforceable from the start, as with a contract that violates the Statute of Frauds or one made by a party who lacks capacity or authority, when performance becomes impossible, or when a material breach leads the injured party to treat the contract as ended.12 That sequence explains why the later sections of this chapter are organized around the events that open the door to restitution.
The word restitution names both a field of law and a narrower stake within a bargain, and students often blur the two. As a field, restitution can supply claims and remedies of its own, and it can also supply remedies that attach to other claims.13 The restitution interest is the narrower stake that a party holds in a bargained-for exchange.14 The Restatement (Third) of Restitution and Unjust Enrichment draws a matching line. Restitution for unjust enrichment appears in sections 31 through 36, and restitution for breach of an enforceable contract, which the Restatement expressly calls restitutionary remedies for breach of an enforceable contract, appears in sections 37 and 38.15
The vocabulary here is loose, and the old labels trace to the law courts. The common counts, such as money had and received, quantum valebant, and quantum meruit, were generally called quasi-contracts because the court ordered payment for goods or services on a fictional construct, not an actual contract.16 Lawyers also call these claims implied-in-law contracts. The unconscious accident victim is the standard illustration: the patient made no promise, so there is no true contract, express or implied, yet the law holds the patient responsible for the reasonable value of the care, and the basis is restitution.17 The label implied-in-law invites a slip, because a contract implied in fact is a true contract whose promise is inferred from conduct. Liability in a quasi-contract case rests on preventing unjust enrichment instead.
Judges add to the confusion by calling any monetary award damages, even when the award is restitution. Classify a recovery by what it measures, not by what the opinion calls it: a recovery of the defendant's gain is restitution.18
Restitution Versus Other Interests
Each interest asks a different question about the same broken deal. Expectation asks where the claimant would stand had the promise been performed.20 Reliance asks what the claimant gave up by changing position.21 Restitution asks what the other party holds that the claimant supplied, and it seeks to put that party where she would have been had the contract never been made. Its focus is the defendant's gain, not the plaintiff's loss.22
An award does not always announce which of these questions it answers. In Sullivan v. O'Connor, a professional entertainer sued a plastic surgeon over an effort to shorten the plaintiff's nose; two operations were planned, a third was needed to undo the effects of the first two, and the Supreme Court of Massachusetts had to review a jury verdict awarding contract damages.23 Any award in such a case answers to one of the three interests, and naming which one is the first step in testing it.
Restitution also stands on a different footing from the other two. It counts neither the promisee's lost profit nor reliance that produced no benefit to the promisor, so it is ordinarily less generous than recovery measured by expectation or reliance.24 Its distinctive strength appears when the bargain was a bad one. Expectation then yields nothing, and restitution still returns what the other party received.
{{hypothetical}} Purchaser contracts to buy Blackacre from Vendor for $100,000, subject to obtaining a mortgage loan, and pays $10,000 down. Before closing, Purchaser spends $500 on a survey, $500 on bank fees for the loan application, and, as Vendor foresaw, $1,000 for an option on the adjoining lot, which Purchaser meant to use for parking. When Purchaser's bank appraises Blackacre at $120,000, Vendor repudiates. Four items now compete for a place in the claim. The $20,000 gap between value and price is an expectation item: Purchaser hoped to gain it, and no one holds it. The $10,000 down payment is the restitution item: it is Purchaser's money, and Vendor holds it. The $1,000 option and the $1,000 in survey and loan fees are reliance items: Purchaser spent them on the strength of the deal, and all of it went to third parties. Purchaser recovers $31,000, made up of the $20,000 expectation, the $10,000 down payment, and the $1,000 option. The survey and bank fees are left out because they were necessary expenses of obtaining the property, so the expectation figure already accounts for them.25 {{/key_rule_placeholder}}
The down payment is the only item on that list that restitution reaches, and the reason is the direction of the inquiry. Vendor received $10,000 of Purchaser's money, so repayment takes from Vendor nothing Vendor was not handed. The option money fails that test because it left Purchaser's hands without entering Vendor's, which means it can be recovered, if at all, as reliance. The labels are not uniform across sources, and that can mislead a student. Some treat the restitution interest as a subspecies of reliance, since a down payment is also money spent in reliance on the promise, and some use expectation broadly, to mean everything needed to put the claimant where performance would have.26 The analysis is the same under either usage. Only the labels move.
The down payment also comes back whatever the market did, and the Supreme Court has said so. Mobil Oil Exploration & Producing Southeast v. United States makes the point with a land-sale illustration. A contracts to sell land to B for $100,000, B makes a $20,000 part payment, and A wrongfully refuses to transfer title. B recovers the $20,000 in restitution, and the result is the same even if the land's market price is only $70,000, so that performance would have been disadvantageous to B.27 The opinion extends the logic to a lottery operator who fails to deliver a purchased ticket, who must refund the purchaser's money whether or not the ticket would have won, and to a party who receives an advance of money and then repudiates, who must refund it.28 On the land numbers, completing the deal would have cost the buyer $30,000 more than the land was worth, so expectation yields nothing, while restitution returns the whole $20,000.
Flour supplies a second illustration. A buyer pays $500,000 toward a $1,400,000 flour contract, the seller breaks the contract by never delivering, and by the time of delivery the market price of the flour has fallen to $1,100,000.29 Performance would have cost the buyer $300,000 more than the flour was worth, so the buyer has no expectation to claim. The seller nevertheless holds $500,000 of the buyer's money, and the part-payment illustration above points toward restoring it.
The interests also differ in how strongly they call for judicial intervention. The restitution interest presents the strongest case for relief, because it combines unjust impoverishment with unjust gain.30 The claimant has lost something and the other party has kept it, so the equities lean harder toward the claimant than when someone has merely been disappointed or merely been put out of pocket. That ranking concerns how compelling a claim is, and it does not predict the amount, which is why the interest with the strongest claim often recovers the least. Expectation remains the starting premise, because the legal system treats the performance interest as the primary one deserving protection, and protecting it fully requires protecting the restitution and reliance interests as well.31