Concept
Forms of Restitutionary Relief
Restitution interest
Forms of Restitutionary Relief
Restitution is a family of recoveries, not a single remedy. What the members share is their aim, which is to prevent the defendant’s unjust enrichment, and their yardstick, which is the defendant’s gain rather than the plaintiff’s loss.1 The family has two historical branches. In equity it produced constructive trusts, equitable liens, accounting for profits, subrogation, cancellation, and reformation; at law it produced the “common counts,” such as money had and received and quantum meruit.2
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 345 lists the principal judicial remedies for protecting the interests defined in § 344, and two of its entries are restitutionary: a judgment requiring restoration of a specific thing to prevent unjust enrichment, and a judgment awarding a sum of money to prevent unjust enrichment.3 Those two orders are the forms of restitutionary relief. In practice, the one a court uses depends on what the claimant handed over, because only a thing that still exists in the defendant’s hands can be handed back.
The other principal entries, a sum due under the contract or as damages and specific performance or an injunction against non-performance, enforce the contract itself.4 The restitutionary orders ask a different question: they look back at what the claimant transferred and ask what the defendant must give up. The vocabulary can blur this line, because each side offers a “thing” remedy and a “money” remedy. Specific performance and specific restitution both concern an identified item, and damages and money restitution both concern dollars. The difference is the yardstick. A sum due under the contract is measured by the promise, while a restitution sum is measured by the benefit the defendant received.
The comment to § 345 adds two cautions. The list is not exhaustive, since replevin of a chattel, reformation, and cancellation of a writing supplement it. Its remedies are also not mutually exclusive, since a court may in the same action both require specific performance and award damages. The comment makes no attempt to match particular remedies to particular interests or grounds for relief.5 Treat the two restitutionary orders as the standard forms, not the only ones.
Specific Restitution
A court orders specific restitution when it requires the defendant to restore a specific thing to prevent unjust enrichment: the very parcel, goods, or patent the claimant transferred, in place of a payment equal to its value.6 The order matters most to a claimant who wants the thing back because no sum of money stands in for it. The thing returned need not be the original. Courts see property the defendant bought with the claimant’s money as a substitute for that money, so the claimant may recover the shares of stock the defendant bought, or their value. That point shows what restitution is about: the claimant receives the defendant’s gain, not the claimant’s loss.7
Specific restitution resembles specific performance, since both orders center on an identified item, but the two point in opposite directions. Specific performance compels the defendant to deliver what the contract promised, so a buyer who wins it receives the land the seller agreed to convey.8 Specific restitution compels the defendant to return what the claimant gave, so it unwinds a transfer without enforcing any promise. The court’s question is therefore what the defendant now holds that came from the claimant. If the defendant holds nothing traceable to the claimant, there is nothing for this remedy to restore, and money restitution becomes the fallback.
The traditional requirement for specific restitution is a showing that the legal remedy is inadequate.9 The patent cases show how that showing works. An inventor assigns a patent in return for a share of the profits the assignee will earn from exploiting it, and the assignee then commits a total breach. Damages are inadequate because the lost profits cannot be proved with sufficient certainty. Monetary restitution for the patent’s value is easier to prove, but the inventor never agreed to transfer the patent for a cash price, so the inventor may have the patent back.10
The Restatement (Second) takes a broader view. A party who is entitled to monetary restitution and is not in breach is entitled to specific restitution unless it would “unduly interfere with the certainty of title to land or otherwise would cause injustice.”11 That is a dramatic enlargement of the remedy, and wider acceptance of the rule would greatly advance the availability of specific restitution.12 Until a jurisdiction adopts it, the safer assumption is that the claimant must show money is inadequate.
Land sharpens the inadequacy question and cuts against a student’s first instinct. A court treats a parcel as unique when a buyer asks it to compel a conveyance, so land might seem to qualify easily for specific restitution too. Traditionally it does not, for a grantor who sold voluntarily for a price and was never paid. That grantor agreed to part with the parcel for money, so money is hard to call inadequate, and the grantor could have protected the sale with a condition in the deed or a purchase-money mortgage. The usual result is that the seller recovers the price, not the land.13
The defaulting-seller reasoning loses its force when the transfer itself was tainted. A party who avoids a contract for lack of capacity, mistake, misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, or abuse of a fiduciary relation is entitled to restitution for any benefit conferred by part performance or reliance, a rule the later section on voidable contracts develops.14 For land, the weight of authority supports a constructive trust where the conveyance was procured by fraud, misrepresentation, duress, undue influence, or mistake; where the transferee is a fiduciary; or where the transfer was made as security only. A minority of jurisdictions impose a trust whenever an oral agreement to convey is violated.15 In each of these situations the grantor’s transfer was procured by a wrong or a breach of trust, or was never meant as an outright sale.
An order to return a thing is useful only if the court can reach the thing, and equity’s tools for that job are restitutionary claims that operate on identifiable property.16 A constructive trust treats the defendant as holding the property for the claimant. The trust is called constructive because it is not based on the parties’ agreement but is imposed by law to avoid unjust enrichment and inequitable conduct. Equity may impose it on the land itself or, if the grantee has sold the land, on the proceeds.17 An equitable lien is a close cousin that serves as an alternative restitutionary remedy where a constructive trust may be inappropriate.18 The usual contrast lies in the scope of recovery. A lien charges the property with a sum, so the claimant’s recovery is limited to that sum, while a trust gives the claimant the property itself, including any rise in its value. Against an insolvent defendant who holds appreciated land, the trust is therefore the more valuable tool.
Money Restitution
A court orders money restitution when it awards a sum of money to prevent unjust enrichment.20 The remedy takes over where specific restitution leaves off. An order to return a particular thing works only if the thing still exists in the defendant’s hands, and most benefits conferred under a contract do not survive that way. Services are consumed as they are performed, materials are built into someone else’s structure, and cash is spent. When nothing identifiable remains to hand back, the court converts the benefit into dollars and orders the recipient to pay them.
The sum is tied to the benefit the recipient received, not to what the contract promised. A figure set by the promise would enforce the bargain, which is the job of a sum due under the contract. Tying the figure to the benefit lets restitution operate where the claimant cannot prove lost profits. It also explains why the claimant’s own cost is not the measure. What the claimant spent to confer the benefit is not what the recipient gained, and preparation that was not part of the performance confers no benefit at all, although the cost of actual part performance can be good evidence of its value.21
The Restatement offers two alternative yardsticks for the sum, which a court may choose as justice requires. One is the reasonable value to the other party of what he received, in terms of what it would have cost him to obtain it from a person in the claimant’s position. The other is the extent to which the other party’s property has been increased in value or his other interests advanced.22
When the benefit conferred was money paid as a price or part of a price, the usual measure is recovery of the price, plus interest.23 The interest follows the same logic as the principal. A recipient who kept the money has had the use of it, and returning only the original sum would let the recipient keep whatever that use was worth.
Opinions often attach older labels to this remedy. At law, restitution of this kind came through the common counts, including money had and received, quantum valebant, and quantum meruit. Courts called these quasi-contracts because they ordered payment for goods or services on a fictional construct, a contract implied in law to prevent unjust enrichment, rather than on any actual contract.24 Some courts instead treat quantum meruit as a contract implied in fact, one in which work is performed at another’s request and the price term is omitted, indefinite, or miscommunicated. That view can defeat the claim when no one requested the work. In T. Musgrove Construction Co. v. Young, a towing company stored and preserved a truck whose owner had never requested the services, so quantum meruit failed. The court still allowed restitution for the benefit the owner received from the storage and preservation, in an amount not to exceed the truck’s salvage value.25 When an opinion uses one of these labels, the safer habit is to ask what benefit the defendant received, because that benefit sets the figure.
The later section on measuring the benefit works out how a court fixes the figure, and it rests on the rule that restitution reaches only a benefit actually conferred by part performance or reliance.26 For now, the point is that this remedy is a sum of money set by the benefit conferred.