Concept
Restitution Versus Suing on the Contract
Restitution for the party in breach
Restitution Versus Suing on the Contract
A breacher who wants payment for what he already delivered has three theories to choose from: a suit on the contract, a suit on a divisible part of it, and a claim in restitution. Each theory answers a different question, so the first task in any problem is to decide which one the breacher's facts fit. Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 374(1) supplies the restitution theory. When a party justifiably refuses to perform because the other side's breach has discharged his remaining duties, the party in breach is entitled to restitution for any benefit he conferred by part performance or reliance, in excess of the loss his own breach caused.1 Section 374 asks whether the other side holds a benefit the contract no longer entitles it to keep. That question can be answered yes even when the breacher has no claim to enforce the contract at all.
The most direct route is a suit on the contract itself. A party who substantially performs remains entitled to the other side's return performance, less an offset for the damages his partial breach caused.2 When the other side refuses to pay, the breacher sues for the price, and the shortfall is handled by subtraction.
Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 241 marks the line between that case and a material breach by presenting several factors for deciding whether a breach is material.3 A material breach is a failure to perform substantially, and its effect is that the other party need not continue performing.4
When the breach is material and total, the breacher loses the contract claim. The breach operates as a renunciation of the contract, and the breacher forfeits his rights under it. That result follows from the discharge of the injured party's duty to render return performance.5 A party who withheld full performance cannot demand the price promised for it, and the other side, released from its own duty, has no promise left to honor. The forfeiture reaches only suits to enforce the contract. It leaves open a claim for unjust enrichment, which rests on the benefit the other side received rather than on any promise.
A warehouse lease shows how the two fit together. A lessee pays a $9,000 security deposit, then refuses to pay the first month's rent and announces that it will not take the lease. The lessor ends the lease and suffers $4,000 in damages. Termination also ends the lessor's contractual right to keep the deposit, because that right depended on a contract that no longer binds anyone. Keeping the money anyway would enrich the lessor at the lessee's expense, so the lessee has a claim in unjust enrichment.6 The lessee does not simply get the cash back, because the lessor's damages are offset against the restitution claim. The lessee recovers $5,000. Section 374 adopts exactly that arrangement.7 Courts commonly apply it to a contractor in material breach, allowing recovery in quantum meruit for the reasonable value of its services, less the harm the breach caused, as in Kreyer v. Driscoll.8
Divisibility is the third route, and it belongs with the contract theories rather than with restitution. If the contract is divisible, a court may allow the breacher to recover for the portions he completed.9 Under Restatement (Second) of Contracts § 240, a contract is divisible when the parties' performances can be apportioned into corresponding pairs of part performances and each pair can fairly be treated as agreed equivalents, so that one part of the work earns one part of the price. A contract to build 35 houses in groups of 10, as in Carrig v. Gilbert-Varker Corp., is the standard example, and the contractor who finished 20 houses recovers for them. The agreed-equivalents requirement protects the owner. A party who received only a fraction of the promised performance should not have to pay the same fraction of the price unless what he received is worth to him roughly that fraction of full performance.10 A contract for a single house offers no such pairs, since a half-built house is seldom worth half the price to an owner who needs a home. A builder who abandons that job has no divisibility claim and is left with restitution.
Because each theory demands something different, a court sorts the breacher's claim from the most contractual theory to the least:
The two contract routes measure recovery by the agreed price. Restitution measures it by the benefit the other side holds, less the loss the breach caused. The sorting matters in practice. In one appeal, the trial court rested its decision on the common-law forfeiture rule and so never considered whether the breacher was entitled to restitution under § 374(1), and the appellate court remanded for that question.11 The elements of § 374(1), beginning with the justified refusal it requires, come in the next sections.